STREAM Trials

 
1
 
STREAM Trials
 
Andrew Nunn
MRC Clinical Trials Unit at UCL
 
26
th
 October 2016
 
Why is a randomised controlled trial needed?
 
To eliminate the risk that patient selection biased
results obtained from cohort studies
To assess the 9-month regimen in a variety of
settings including high levels of HIV-coinfection
To develop a better evidence base for MDR-TB
treatment
If successful, to provide a new standard of care for
comparison with potentially better regimens
 
2
 
A parallel approach to assessing the
effectiveness of the Bangladesh regimen
 
Cohort studies
 
African countries including:
Cameroon
Benin
Niger
Swaziland
 
Afghanistan
Uzbekistan
 
Randomised trials
 
STREAM Stage 1
STREAM Stage 2
 
STREAM Stage 1 study design
 
STREAM Stage 1 is a randomised controlled trial of 
non-
inferiority design
 
currently being conducted in Ethiopia,
South Africa, Vietnam and Mongolia
 
The control regimen
 
(A) 
is the locally used WHO 2011
recommended regimen
The study regimen 
(B) 
is closely similar to the regimen used
in Bangladesh with the exception that high dose
moxifloxacin replaces high dose gatifloxacin
 
 
The
 9-month regimen (B)
 
 
 
 
                
Weeks
  
Drug doses by weight group
Drug
   
< 33 kg 
 
         33 - 50 kg 
 
             > 50 kg
Kanamycin* 
 
1 - 16
 
     15 mg per kilogramme body weight
Isoniazid (H) 
 
1 - 16
 
 300 mg 
  
400 mg 
 
              600 mg
Prothionamide 
 
1 - 16
 
 250 mg 
  
500 mg 
 
              750 mg
Clofazimine 
 
1 - 40
 
   50 mg 
  
100 mg 
 
              100 mg
Moxifloxacin
 
 
1 - 40
 
 400 mg 
  
600 mg 
 
              800 mg
Ethambutol 
 
1 - 40
 
 800 mg 
  
800 mg 
 
            1200 mg
Pyrazinamide     
 
1 - 40       1000 mg                   1500 mg 
 
            2000 mg
 
Kanamycin 3 times/week after week 12
 
The intensive phase may be extended by 4 or 8 weeks if smear conversion has
not occurred by 16 or 20 weeks
 
5
 
Stage 1: current status
 
Enrolment to Stage 1 commenced: July 2012
Sites: Ethiopia (2), South Africa (3), Vietnam and Mongolia
424 of initial target of 400 patients enrolled
Intake closed: June 30th 2015
Primary endpoint at 30 months
Last patient visit: Q4 2017
Results from Stage 1 expected:  Q1/2 2018
95% seen at 52 weeks or known to have died
 
6
 
STREAM Stage 2
 
Following the provisional licensing of bedaquiline 
we were
asked to consider:
is it possible to include additional regimens to the
STREAM trial in its present form?
if so, what would be the appropriate regimen(s) to
evaluate?
 
After extensive discussions between the study partners and
other experts it was agreed that the primary interest to
patients and programmes would be:
a fully oral regimen (no kanamycin) and/or
a shorter and simpler regimen
 
 
 
7
Regimens for Stage 2
 
Stage 2: two new regimens
 
Regimen C
fully oral regimen
involves the removal of the injectable, kanamycin, to avoid the
associated risks of hearing loss and kidney damage
 
Regimen D
treatment is shortened to 28 weeks
with a shorter intensive phase (reduced duration of kanamycin
and isoniazid)
and removal of ethambutol (of questionable efficacy)
and removal of prothionamide (commonly associated with severe
gastric symptoms)
 
In both regimens 
bedaquilin
e is given throughout and moxifloxacin is
replaced by levofloxacin to reduce the risks of QTc prolongation
 
10
 
STREAM Study Population
(Stage 1 and 2)
 
Adults (18 years or older
) who has given consent for treatment
and follow-up – 
adolescents aged 15 or older eligible in Stage 2
Smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis, unless
 HIV-infected
Evidence
 of initial resistance to rifampicin 
on
 line-probe assay,
GeneXpert or other DST
No evidence 
of initial resistance to fluoroquinolone or 2
nd
-line
injectables on line-probe assay
No pre-existent QT prolongation >500msec
     (450 ms in Stage 2)
 
 
STREAM Stage 2 design
 
 
Because it is possible that the control regimen, Regimen B,
might not be found to be non-inferior to Regimen A it was
decided to continue to enrol patients to Regimen A
 
Secondary objectives include the comparisons of Regimen C
and Regimen D to Regimen A; these will be particularly
important if Regimen B is found to be inferior to Regimen A
 
11
 
STREAM Stage 2 Design
 
Primary objectives:
To assess whether 
Regimen C (fully oral), 
and/or 
Regimen D (6-
months)
, are as effective as, or are superior to, 
Regimen B
(modified Bangladesh regimen) 
at 76 weeks (18 months)
 
Randomisation ratio: 1:2:2:2 (A:B:C:D)
Sample size: 1155
Long term follow-up to 132 weeks (~2.5 years)
 
Funding from USAID & Janssen
Intention to submit results to FDA for full licensing application
 
 
 
May 2016
WHO issued new guidelines
Which is the shorter MDR-TB regimen that
WHO-recommends?
The regimen recommended by WHO is the one
which has been used more recently in different
geographical sites and in the STREAM trial
What is the dosage of medicines to use in
the WHO-recommended shorter MDR-TB
regimen?
The recommended dosage by weight is the
one which has been published earlier by the
Global Drug-resistant TB Initiative (GDI) in
2015 and the STREAM trial
Why is WHO recommending the use of the shorter MDR-TB regimen if the
certainty in the evidence is very low?
There are considerable benefits to both the patients and to the health systems if the
shorter MDR-TB regimen is used instead of longer treatment options. Although the
evidence for the effectiveness of the shorter MDR-TB regimen is still considered of
very low quality, the outcomes from the observational studies assessed to date do
show high levels of success in selected patients treated in different settings.
 
Implications of WHO recommendations for STREAM
 
In view of WHO’s recommendations it is likely that arm A
(the 24 month regimen) will have to be dropped from
some sites in Stage 2 of STREAM
 
South Africa is likely to be the first country to adopt the
new regimen.
 
In the meantime patients will continue to be randomised
to all four arms, A, B, C and D
 
What if?
 
What if Regimen B is inferior to Regimen A
   - will there be sufficient patients randomised to  Regimen A to
     compare with C and D?
   - if not a network meta-analysis will be needed to compare:
 
   
B with A (Stage 1)
                C and D with B (Stage 2)
In a network meta-analysis three or more treatments are compared using
both direct comparisons of interventions within randomised controlled trials
and indirect comparisons across trials based on a common comparator.
 
STREAM Stage 2
 
April 2016
: First patient enrolled (Mongolia)
 
Five sites now open to recruitment (recruitment
paused in Ethiopia due to state of emergency)
 
Additional sites planned for Africa, Asia and Eastern
Europe
 
Community Engagement
 
In STREAM Stage 2, Mongolia and South Africa have
established regular community engagement activities and
CAB meetings
 
Preliminary CE meetings were held in Ethiopia in
September 2016
 
STREAM Community Engagement Plan launched in in
Durban in July 2016 (available on TREAT TB website
together with video)
Slide Note
Embed
Share

STREAM Trials involves a randomized controlled trial conducted in multiple countries, focusing on different drug regimens for tuberculosis treatment. The study design, drug doses, and current enrollment status are detailed, with plans for future stages discussed.

  • Trials
  • Study Design
  • Tuberculosis
  • Drug Regimens
  • Clinical Research

Uploaded on Feb 15, 2025 | 0 Views


Download Presentation

Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

You are allowed to download the files provided on this website for personal or commercial use, subject to the condition that they are used lawfully. All files are the property of their respective owners.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. STREAM Trials Andrew Nunn MRC Clinical Trials Unit at UCL 26th October 2016 1

  2. STREAM Stage 1 study design STREAM Stage 1 is a randomised controlled trial of non- inferiority design currently being conducted in Ethiopia, South Africa, Vietnam and Mongolia The control regimen (A) is the locally used WHO 2011 recommended regimen The study regimen (B) is closely similar to the regimen used in Bangladesh with the exception that high dose moxifloxacin replaces high dose gatifloxacin

  3. The 9-month regimen (B) Drug Kanamycin* Isoniazid (H) Prothionamide Clofazimine Moxifloxacin Ethambutol Pyrazinamide Weeks Drug doses by weight group < 33 kg 33 - 50 kg > 50 kg 1 - 16 1 - 16 1 - 16 1 - 40 1 - 40 1 - 40 1 - 40 1000 mg 1500 mg 2000 mg 15 mg per kilogramme body weight 300 mg 250 mg 50 mg 400 mg 800 mg 400 mg 600 mg 500 mg 750 mg 100 mg 100 mg 600 mg 800 mg 800 mg 1200 mg Kanamycin 3 times/week after week 12 The intensive phase may be extended by 4 or 8 weeks if smear conversion has not occurred by 16 or 20 weeks 5

  4. Stage 1: current status Enrolment to Stage 1 commenced: July 2012 Sites: Ethiopia (2), South Africa (3), Vietnam and Mongolia 424 of initial target of 400 patients enrolled Intake closed: June 30th 2015 Primary endpoint at 30 months Last patient visit: Q4 2017 Results from Stage 1 expected: Q1/2 2018 95% seen at 52 weeks or known to have died 6

  5. STREAM Stage 2 Following the provisional licensing of bedaquiline we were asked to consider: is it possible to include additional regimens to the STREAM trial in its present form? if so, what would be the appropriate regimen(s) to evaluate? After extensive discussions between the study partners and other experts it was agreed that the primary interest to patients and programmes would be: a fully oral regimen (no kanamycin) and/or a shorter and simpler regimen 7

  6. Stage 2: two new regimens Regimen C fully oral regimen involves the removal of the injectable, kanamycin, to avoid the associated risks of hearing loss and kidney damage Regimen D treatment is shortened to 28 weeks with a shorter intensive phase (reduced duration of kanamycin and isoniazid) and removal of ethambutol (of questionable efficacy) and removal of prothionamide (commonly associated with severe gastric symptoms) In both regimens bedaquiline is given throughout and moxifloxacin is replaced by levofloxacin to reduce the risks of QTc prolongation

  7. STREAM Study Population (Stage 1 and 2) Adults (18 years or older) who has given consent for treatment and follow-up adolescents aged 15 or older eligible in Stage 2 Smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis, unless HIV-infected Evidence of initial resistance to rifampicin on line-probe assay, GeneXpert or other DST No evidence of initial resistance to fluoroquinolone or 2nd-line injectables on line-probe assay No pre-existent QT prolongation >500msec (450 ms in Stage 2) 10

  8. STREAM Stage 2 design Because it is possible that the control regimen, Regimen B, might not be found to be non-inferior to Regimen A it was decided to continue to enrol patients to Regimen A Secondary objectives include the comparisons of Regimen C and Regimen D to Regimen A; these will be particularly important if Regimen B is found to be inferior to Regimen A 11

  9. STREAM Stage 2 Design Primary objectives: To assess whether Regimen C (fully oral), and/or Regimen D (6- months), are as effective as, or are superior to, Regimen B (modified Bangladesh regimen) at 76 weeks (18 months) Randomisation ratio: 1:2:2:2 (A:B:C:D) Sample size: 1155 Long term follow-up to 132 weeks (~2.5 years) Funding from USAID & Janssen Intention to submit results to FDA for full licensing application

  10. May 2016 WHO issued new guidelines Which is the shorter MDR-TB regimen that WHO-recommends? The regimen recommended by WHO is the one which has been used more recently in different geographical sites and in the STREAM trial What is the dosage of medicines to use in the WHO-recommended shorter MDR-TB regimen? The recommended dosage by weight is the one which has been published earlier by the Global Drug-resistant TB Initiative (GDI) in 2015 and the STREAM trial Why is WHO recommending the use of the shorter MDR-TB regimen if the certainty in the evidence is very low? There are considerable benefits to both the patients and to the health systems if the shorter MDR-TB regimen is used instead of longer treatment options. Although the evidence for the effectiveness of the shorter MDR-TB regimen is still considered of very low quality, the outcomes from the observational studies assessed to date do show high levels of success in selected patients treated in different settings.

  11. Implications of WHO recommendations for STREAM In view of WHO s recommendations it is likely that arm A (the 24 month regimen) will have to be dropped from some sites in Stage 2 of STREAM South Africa is likely to be the first country to adopt the new regimen. In the meantime patients will continue to be randomised to all four arms, A, B, C and D

  12. What if? What if Regimen B is inferior to Regimen A - will there be sufficient patients randomised to Regimen A to compare with C and D? - if not a network meta-analysis will be needed to compare: B with A (Stage 1) C and D with B (Stage 2) In a network meta-analysis three or more treatments are compared using both direct comparisons of interventions within randomised controlled trials and indirect comparisons across trials based on a common comparator.

  13. STREAM Stage 2 April 2016: First patient enrolled (Mongolia) Five sites now open to recruitment (recruitment paused in Ethiopia due to state of emergency) Additional sites planned for Africa, Asia and Eastern Europe

  14. Community Engagement In STREAM Stage 2, Mongolia and South Africa have established regular community engagement activities and CAB meetings Preliminary CE meetings were held in Ethiopia in September 2016 STREAM Community Engagement Plan launched in in Durban in July 2016 (available on TREAT TB website together with video)

Related


More Related Content

giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#