Challenges with Texas Tenure Law Modification

This content discusses the implications of the recent changes to the tenure laws in Texas, particularly Senate Bill 18. The Senate version of the bill introduces stringent requirements for earning tenure and limits the hiring of tenured faculty. Conversely, the House version adds specific definitions and procedures related to tenure and faculty dismissal. Concerns are raised regarding academic freedom, termination reasons, and potential impacts on faculty retention and institution rankings.

• Texas Tenure Law
• Academic Freedom
• Faculty Dismissal
• Senate Bill 18
• Tenure Implications

lailynnsu Follow

Uploaded on Mar 03, 2025 | 0 Views

Download Presentation

Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

You are allowed to download the files provided on this website for personal or commercial use, subject to the condition that they are used lawfully. All files are the property of their respective owners.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.

Presentation Transcript

1. New Texas Tenure Law Lauren Gutterman and Brian Evans UT Austin AAUP Chapter ljg300@gmail.com and halftoning@juno.com Speaking for myself as a private citizen Not speaking on behalf of any group, institution, or organization September 9, 2023

2. Senates Version of the Tenure Bill (SB 18) Tenure Earned after a rigorous review of six years of teaching, research and service Protects academic freedom to foster critical thinking & intellectual exploration Allows professors to take on long-term curriculum development, research projects, and leadership positions vital to student experience and success Initial Tenure Bill Passed by Senate on April 6th (SB18) Prohibits hiring of tenured & tenure-track faculty after Jan. 1, 2024 Allows faculty tenured before Jan. 1, 2024, to remain tenured Not the version passed by the Legislature Potential impacts of the Senate Version of SB 18 Tenure-track faculty will seek tenure-track and tenured positions elsewhere Due to the starvation of the tenure pipeline, tenured faculty members will leave Loss of quality, prestige and rankings by Texas public colleges and universities 2

3. Different Tenure Bill Passed by House & Now Law SB18 modified Texas Education Code on Post-Tenure Review Part 1 Adds Tenure Definition Codifies tenure as continuous employment Sec. 2 Part 4 Only a governing board may grant tenure Sec. 3(b) Supreme Court held tenure as a property right property amount in Sec. 3(c) ** Part 2 Faculty dismissal with due process in Sec. 3(c-1) Each governing board shall adopt policies and procedures regarding tenure Defines 10 ways to dismiss a tenured faculty member Continues provisions for periodic post-tenure review processes Underlined text means text added to existing law Part 3 Summary ( Immediate ) Dismissal in Sec. 3(c-4) Sets minimum standards for institutions that choose to have summary dismissal ** 14th Amendment of the US Constitution: Government cannot deprive an individual of property or liberty without due process, but each State defines the property interest. 3

4. Concerns About SB 18 (1/2) Academic Freedom not mentioned Connect academic freedom as a necessary safeguard of academic freedom Academic freedom: freedom from censorship by the institution or government Other academic freedom safeguards include due process & shared governance Part 2: Seven reasons for termination are undefined or vague and many do not indicate severity or pervasiveness exhibited professional incompetence failed to perform duties or meet professional responsibilities engaged in conduct involving moral turpitude violated laws or university system or institution policies engaged in unprofessional conduct that adversely affects the institution violated university system or institution policies other good cause as defined in the institution s policies 4

5. Concerns About SB 18 (2/2) Part 2: Additional grounds for termination in Sec. 3(c-1) include Failure to complete a development plan from post-tenure review other good cause as defined in the institution s policies Part 3: Add due process protections for summary dismissal in Sec. 3(c-4) A designated administrator is the sole arbiter in determining the outcome instead of a jury of one s peers Does not give faculty opportunity to examine evidence or talk to witnesses Does not provide faculty the option for legal representation Allows a faculty grievance process only after termination 5

6. Faculty Role in SB 18 Policies & Procedures the governing board shall seek advice and comment from the institution's faculty before adopting any policies and procedures under this section. The advice and comment from the faculty on the performance evaluation of tenured faculty shall be given the utmost consideration by the governing board. [SB 18, Sec. 3(c-2)] Jul. 27: UT System issued drafts of changes to four UT Regents Rules due to SB 18 Summary of draft changes Jul. 27 Aug. 7: Faculty at UT institutions asked to comment on drafts UT Austin AAUP Chapter submitted a response Aug. 24: UT Board of Regents approves changes Summary of approved changes Sep. 1: SB 18 and new UT Regents Rules took effect Fall 2023: UT campuses to develop their SB 18 policies UT Board of Regents approved its changes too late for UT campuses to complete their shared governance processes to develop SB 18 campus policies by Sept. 1st.

7. Gold Standard for Tenure Policies Statement of Principles on Academic Freedom & Tenure, jointly formulated by American Association of Colleges & Universities (AAC&U) representing college and university administrations and American Association of University Professors (AAUP) representing professors. AAC&U has more than 800 college/university members. Statement on Procedural Standards in Faculty Dismissal Proceedings, jointly formulated by the AAC&U and AAUP. Statement on Government of Colleges and Universities, jointly formulated by the AAUP, American Council on Education, and Association of Governing Boards of Universities & Colleges. The AAUP represents faculty members, ACE represents university administrations, and AGB represents University Systems, Boards of Regents and Boards of Trustees. ACE has more than 1500 college and university members and AGB has more than 1300 college, university, and system members. 7

8. Texas AAUP Statements on SB 18 Texas AAUP Press Release on Passage of SB 18, May 27, 2023 Texas AAUP SB 18 Summary and Analysis Texas AAUP, How the National Tenure System is Critical to Being Competitive for Federal Research Grants to Public Universities in Texas: A STEM Perspective , May 22, 2023. Brian Evans, Tenured and Tenure-Track Faculty in the US, Texas A&M & UT Austin , April 3, 2023. Related "Governor Abbott Congratulates Texas Universities on Earning Prestigious National Research Rankings", Feb. 16, 2022. 8