Axion Cosmology with Post-Newtonian Corrections

Axion 
cosmology
 
with post-
Newtonian corrections
 
J. Hwang (IBS) & H. Noh (KASI)
08 Jan.
 2023
 
 
 
Linear density perturbation for dust:
 
Lifshitz (1946) synchronous gauge
Bonnor (1957)
 Newtonian
Bardeen (1980) 
comoving gauge
Include 
Λ
 
and 
Κ
 
Post-Newtonian approximation:
 
Perturbation theory:
 
Fully relativistic but weakly nonlinear
 
Fully nonlinear but weakly relativistic
c
 
 
 
:
 
N
e
w
t
o
n
i
a
n
 
l
i
m
i
t
!
 
Expansions in
 
For axion
 
Expansions in
 
background density
 
cosmic scale factor
 
relative density
perturbation
 
gravitational
 
strength
 
Abbott-Sikivie (1983)
Dine-Fischler (1983)
Preskill-Wise-Wilczek (1983)
 
Khlopov-Malomed-Zel’dovich (1985)
 
Sikivie-Yang (2009) 
zero-shear gauge
JH-Noh (2009) 
axion comoving gauge
Noh-Park-JH (2017) 
axion comoving gauge
 
JH-Noh 2211.02197 
naturally
 
gauge-invariant
 
Madelung (1927)
 
Background order:
 
Newtonian:
 
Linear perturbation order:
 
Fully nonlinear and exact order:
 
Axion as a CDM (FDM) candidate, proofs:
 
From Schrödinger equation:
 
Post-Newtonian correction:
 
Re
 
 
Momentum conservation:
 
Im
  
Continuity:
 
Quantum stress
 
Identify:
 
Madelung (1927)
 
FNLE
Fully nonlinear and exact
perturbation formulation
 
JH-Noh (2013)
; 
Gong-JH-Noh-Wu-Yoo (2017)
 
Friedmann background
 
arbitrary
 
amplitude
 
transverse-tracefree
 
transverse
 
FNLE metric convention
 
Decomposition, possible
to nonlinear order
 
JH-Noh (2013)
 
Ignore TT
 
Spatial gauge condition
 
Inverse metric:
 
Exact!
 
FNLE formulation
: Fully nonlinear and 
exact
 perturbation equations
without imposing temporal gauge condition
 
Zero-pressure
irrotational fluid
Comoving gauge
 
Linear-order:
 
Lifshitz (1946) synchronous gauge = comoving gauge; Bonnor (1957)
 
Second-order
:
 
Noh-JH (2004) comoving gauge
 
Third-order
:
 
JH-Noh (2005) comoving gauge
 
Pure relativistic corrections
appear in the third-order.
All terms involve 
φ
 ~ 10
-5
 
Relativistic/Newtonian correspondence
to second-order. Valid to fully
nonlinear order in Newtonian theory.
 
Only for dust to linear order!
Jeong-Gong-Noh-JH (2011)
 
Unreasonable effectiveness of
Newton’s gravity in cosmology!
Vishniac 1983
 
Jeong 
et al
 2011
 
Pure Einstein
Leading nonlinear density power-spectrum
in comoving gauge
Fully nonlinear and exact order
RHS = pure Einstein’s gravity corrections,
starting from the third-order, all involving
 φ
Identify:
 
Axion!
 
Nonrelativistic  ⸪ ignored
Madelung (1927)
Khlopov-Malomed-Zeldovich (1985)
Noh-JH-Park (2017)
JH-Noh (2013)
Perturbed part of the trace of extrinsic curvature
Comoving gauge:
 
Axion
Massive scalar field
 
Einstein eq:
 
Action:
 
Klein-Gordon eq:
EOM
 
Scalar field
Popular in cosmology: steady-state theory, inflation, dark energy, dark matter
 
Axion:
 
Klein transformation:
(1926)
 
Madelung transformation:
(1927)
 
Equivalently,
 
Klein-Gordon eq. → Schrödinger eq. in nonrelativistic limit
 
or
 
Axion
As a massive scalar field
 
Schrödinger eq. → Hydrodynamic eqs.
 
Klein tr
 
    
 
Post-Newtonian metric:
 
Nonrelativistic limit:
 
Post-Newtonian Schrödinger eq:
 
0PN (Newtonian)
 
1PN
 
1PN
 
JH-Noh 2211.02197
 
Madelung tr
 
  
 
Perturbation:
subtracting BG
 
Quantum stress
 
 
Without imposing temporal gauge, 
naturally gauge-invariant
 
Nonrelativistic perturbation
, fully nonlinear:
 
JH-Noh JCAP (2022)
 
Quantum stress:
Uncertainty
 
principle,
 
quantum tunneling,
interference, …
Pilot wave theory (de Broglie 1927)
Bohmian mechanics (Bohm 1952)
 
Not identical 
to Schrödinger eq. 
at 
ρ
 = 0 → 
quantized vortex
 
Bose-Einstein condensate
Superfluid
Quantum turbulence
 
Relativistic
 
perturbation
 to linear order in
axion-comoving gauge:
 
 
Energy conservation:
 
JH-Noh (2009)
 
Raychaudhury eq:
 
Strictly ignore:
 
nonrelativistic
 
EOM:
 
Axion-comoving gauge:
 
Jeans scale:
 
Assumption violated, but somehow recovers
correct behavior in the sub-Compton scale
 
CDM
 
FDM
 
Ultralight axion
Fuzzy dark matter
 
Ultralight axion as a fuzzy (wave) DM
 
Hui-Ostriker-Tremaine-Witten (2017)
 
Park-JH-Noh
 
(2012)
 
Neutrino as a hot DM
 
Park-JH-Noh
 
(2012)
 
Post-Newtonian
corrections
 
0PN (Newtonian)
 
Chandrasekhar (1965); JH-Noh-Puetzfeld (2008)
 
1PN
 
1PN
 
Expansions in
 
For axion
 
Jeans scale:
 
Without imposing temporal gauge, 
naturally gauge-invariant
 
1PN correction
 
Gravitational instability, to
 
linear
 
order
 
Continuity:
 
Momentum:
 
Poisson:
 
1PN correction
 
JH-Noh 2211.02197
 
 
1PN correction
 
Thank you !
Slide Note
Embed
Share

Exploring axion cosmology with post-Newtonian corrections, this study delves into linear density perturbations for dust, the role of axion as a cold dark matter candidate, and fully nonlinear perturbation formulations. It addresses continuity, momentum conservation, and quantum stress to identify key aspects in the study of the universe. The research investigates the implications of fully nonlinear and exact perturbation formulations, metric conventions, and zero-pressure irrotational fluids within the context of comoving and synchronous gauges.

  • Axion Cosmology
  • Post-Newtonian Corrections
  • Dark Matter
  • Linear Perturbations
  • Nonlinear Formulations

Uploaded on Sep 11, 2024 | 0 Views


Download Presentation

Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author. Download presentation by click this link. If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Axion cosmology with post- Newtonian corrections J. Hwang (IBS) & H. Noh (KASI) 08 Jan. 2023

  2. Linear density perturbation for dust: cosmic scale factor Lifshitz (1946) synchronous gauge Bonnor (1957) Newtonian Bardeen (1980) comoving gauge Include and Perturbation theory: relative density perturbation background density Expansions in Fully relativistic but weakly nonlinear Post-Newtonian approximation: Expansions in gravitational strength For axion Fully nonlinear but weakly relativistic c : Newtonian limit!

  3. Axion as a CDM (FDM) candidate, proofs: Background order: Abbott-Sikivie (1983) Dine-Fischler (1983) Preskill-Wise-Wilczek (1983) Newtonian: Khlopov-Malomed-Zel dovich (1985) Linear perturbation order: Sikivie-Yang (2009) zero-shear gauge JH-Noh (2009) axion comoving gauge Noh-Park-JH (2017) axion comoving gauge Fully nonlinear and exact order: Post-Newtonian correction: JH-Noh 2211.02197 naturally gauge-invariant From Schr dinger equation: Madelung (1927)

  4. Identify: Im Continuity: Re Momentum conservation: Quantum stress Madelung (1927)

  5. FNLE Fully nonlinear and exact perturbation formulation arbitrary amplitude Friedmann background transverse transverse-tracefree JH-Noh (2013); Gong-JH-Noh-Wu-Yoo (2017)

  6. FNLE metric convention Decomposition, possible to nonlinear order Spatial gauge condition Ignore TT Inverse metric: Exact! FNLE formulation: Fully nonlinear and exact perturbation equations without imposing temporal gauge condition JH-Noh (2013)

  7. Zero-pressure irrotational fluid Comoving gauge

  8. Linear-order: Lifshitz (1946) synchronous gauge = comoving gauge; Bonnor (1957) Only for dust to linear order! Relativistic/Newtonian correspondence to second-order. Valid to fully nonlinear order in Newtonian theory. Second-order: Noh-JH (2004) comoving gauge Pure relativistic corrections appear in the third-order. All terms involve ~ 10-5 Third-order: JH-Noh (2005) comoving gauge

  9. Leading nonlinear density power-spectrum in comoving gauge Vishniac 1983 Pure Einstein Jeong et al 2011 Unreasonable effectiveness of Newton s gravity in cosmology! Jeong-Gong-Noh-JH (2011)

  10. Fully nonlinear and exact order Comoving gauge: RHS = pure Einstein s gravity corrections, starting from the third-order, all involving Axion! Nonrelativistic ignored Madelung (1927) Khlopov-Malomed-Zeldovich (1985) Noh-JH-Park (2017) Identify: Perturbed part of the trace of extrinsic curvature JH-Noh (2013)

  11. Axion Massive scalar field

  12. Scalar field Popular in cosmology: steady-state theory, inflation, dark energy, dark matter Action: Einstein eq: Klein-Gordon eq: EOM

  13. Axion As a massive scalar field Axion: Klein transformation: (1926) Klein-Gordon eq. Schr dinger eq. in nonrelativistic limit Madelung transformation: (1927) Schr dinger eq. Hydrodynamic eqs. Equivalently, or

  14. Klein tr 0PN (Newtonian) 1PN Post-Newtonian metric: 1PN Post-Newtonian Schr dinger eq: Nonrelativistic limit: JH-Noh 2211.02197

  15. Nonrelativistic perturbation, fully nonlinear: Madelung tr Quantum stress: Uncertainty principle, quantum tunneling, interference, Pilot wave theory (de Broglie 1927) Bohmian mechanics (Bohm 1952) Not identical to Schr dinger eq. at = 0 quantized vortex Bose-Einstein condensate Superfluid Quantum turbulence Perturbation: subtracting BG Quantum stress Without imposing temporal gauge, naturally gauge-invariant JH-Noh JCAP (2022)

  16. Relativistic perturbation to linear order in axion-comoving gauge: nonrelativistic Strictly ignore: Axion-comoving gauge: Energy conservation: Raychaudhury eq: EOM: Assumption violated, but somehow recovers correct behavior in the sub-Compton scale Jeans scale: CDM FDM JH-Noh (2009)

  17. Ultralight axion Fuzzy dark matter

  18. Ultralight axion as a fuzzy (wave) DM Hui-Ostriker-Tremaine-Witten (2017) Park-JH-Noh (2012)

  19. Neutrino as a hot DM Park-JH-Noh (2012)

  20. Post-Newtonian corrections 0PN (Newtonian) 1PN 1PN Expansions in For axion Chandrasekhar (1965); JH-Noh-Puetzfeld (2008)

  21. Gravitational instability, to linear order 1PN correction Continuity: Momentum: Poisson: 1PN correction Jeans scale: 1PN correction Without imposing temporal gauge, naturally gauge-invariant JH-Noh 2211.02197

  22. Thank you !

Related


More Related Content

giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#