The Beauty of Smallness: Exploring the Advantages and Challenges of Small States
Exploring the concept of smallness in states, this article delves into the advantages and disadvantages of being a small country, using Tuvalu as a case study. It discusses the governance challenges faced by small states, such as limited resources and vulnerability, while also highlighting the cohesive political economies and high social capital that often characterize smaller nations. The article questions whether being small enables or constrains a nation's ability to achieve lofty aims and govern effectively.
Uploaded on Sep 26, 2024 | 0 Views
Download Presentation
Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author. Download presentation by click this link. If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.
E N D
Presentation Transcript
Is small really beautiful? Graham Teskey Ministry of Foreign Affairs ad Trade Wellington August 7th, 2019
Contents 6 slides Preliminary reflections Take Tuvalu . Advantages of smallness Disadvantages The public service Concluding Abt Associates | pg 2
Lots of blue Abt Associates | pg 3
Preliminary reflections Little interest Little interest in VSIDS No common definitions No common definitions: 1957 - The International Economics Association suggested small states to be those less than 10 million people 1969 UN said less than 1 million, Commonwealth and WB say 1.5 million .which gives 49 countries (36 island states, and 13 non-island countries: Botswana, Djibouti, Equatorial Guinea, Estonia, Gabon, the Gambia, Guinea-Bissau, Guyana, Lesotho, Montenegro, Namibia, Qatar and Swaziland) Why hy not size or contribution to global GDP or size of EEZ not size or contribution to global GDP or size of EEZ? Well population won out population won out: UN says 10 m the cut off meaning 105 out of 193 UN members are small What about micro micro- -states states? UN says 1 million The number of islands number of islands will affect politics, economy, society and public administration: single islands (Nauru; Dominica; St. Lucia); pairs of islands (Antigua and Barbuda; St. Kitts and Nevis); consolidated groups of islands (Grenada; St. Vincent and the Grenadines); archipelagos of many islands (Kiribati s 3.5 million square kilometres contain 33 atolls. Most pacific states fall into this category) Abt Associates | pg 4
The challenge: Tuvalu The world s fourth smallest state by population Just how difficult can it be to govern 9,000 people about the size of Greymouth on the west coast of South Island . Big ambition. Its Constitution declares that: the guiding principles of Tuvalu are agreement, courtesy and the search for consensus, in accordance with traditional Tuvaluan procedures, rather than alien ideas of confrontation and divisiveness . Does the country s size enable or constrain such a lofty aim? When Tuvalu gained independence in 1978, its civil service employed 387 officials Is this a viable state? How to deliver functions such as foreign office or defence? Challenges: economies of scale; remoteness, vulnerability, HR, natural resource shortages But .in terms of governance- about what one would expect given the level of GNI per capita Abt Associates | pg 5
Advantages of smallness Cohesive political economy with high levels of social capital Everyone is related so trust is high Public service closer to the population so more responsive and aware of needs and aspirations Leadership roles may be more respected than in larger societies (?) Abt Associates | pg 6
Disadvantages From the simple to the profound .: x Cannot possibly cover all sovereign needs x Cannot overtrain cadres x Those with skills and competencies often overstretched x Reciprocal obligations threatens decision making in the public interest x Patronage politics x What Max Everest-Phillips has called bureaupathology: anxiety due to alienation, limited promotion prospects, less-than-adequate pay and conditions, pessimism, sense of powerlessness, and the apathy of muted frustration over the erosion of independence and professionalism with the blurring of roles between politics and bureaucracy x short-term interests dominate due to impact on close knit (and physically close_ communities x The impossibility of impersonal service delivery: again reciprocal obligations and expectations dominate Abt Associates | pg 7
The Public Service Hypothesis: Hypothesis: The rational-legal-impersonal model of professional public service may not be applicable in VSIDS, and smallness actually makes things harder not easier But if we discard this notion, what can we offer small island countries? Do we know enough to give any advice on PSM / PSR? Are we limited to what the management geeks call business process re- engineering , or tinkering around with organisational structures, rather than incentives, motivations and the rules of the game (or at least the rules of what we think the game is .)? Abt Associates | pg 8
But..concluding Size is not destiny Vulnerability is not the same as a lack of capacity Importing public service reform models from outside may be even less appropriate than in larger countries, as the prevailing system may be easier to overwhelm Abt Associates | pg 9
