Nevada's Open Meeting Law (OML) in Washoe County

undefined
 
N
E
V
A
D
A
S
 
O
P
E
N
 
M
E
E
T
I
N
G
L
A
W
 
Washoe County District Attorney’s Office
Washoe County District Attorney’s Office
 
 
 
L
e
g
i
s
l
a
t
i
v
e
 
I
n
t
e
n
t
 
o
f
 
O
M
L
 
NRS 241.010 sets forth a legislative
NRS 241.010 sets forth a legislative
declaration:
declaration:
 
Public bodies exist to aid in the conduct
Public bodies exist to aid in the conduct
of the people’s business.
of the people’s business.
It is the intent of the OML that board
It is the intent of the OML that board
deliberations
deliberations
 and board 
 and board 
actions
actions
 be
 be
conducted openly.
conducted openly.
 
When Does the OML Apply?
 
In general, OML applies to all
meetings
 of a 
public body
 at which
deliberation takes place and/or
action may occur.
 
Pillars of the OML
Pillars of the OML
 
Public Body
Public Body
Meeting
Meeting
Notice
Notice
Agenda
Agenda
Minutes
Minutes
 
 
 
AB 253 (2021):
AB 253 (2021):
No major revisions
No major revisions
However, AB 253 put
However, AB 253 put
some structure around
some structure around
“remote technology”
“remote technology”
meetings
meetings
 
P
u
b
l
i
c
 
B
o
d
y
N
R
S
 
2
4
1
.
0
1
5
(
4
)
 
Any administrative, 
advisory
, executive
or legislative body of the state or local
government
which expends or disburses or is
supported in whole or in part by tax
revenue
or
 which 
advises or makes
recommendations
 to an entity which
expends or disburses or is supported in
whole or in part by tax revenue
includes any 
board
, commission,
committee, subcommittee or other
subsidiary thereof
 
M
e
e
t
i
n
g
N
R
S
 
2
4
1
.
0
1
5
(
3
)
(
a
)
(
1
)
 
In general, a “meeting” is:
In general, a “meeting” is:
The 
The 
gathering
gathering
 
 
of members 
of members 
of a public body
of a public body
at which a 
at which a 
quorum
quorum
 is present to 
 is present to 
deliberate
deliberate
toward a decision or to take 
toward a decision or to take 
action
action
 on any
 on any
matter over which the public body has
matter over which the public body has
supervision, control, jurisdiction or advisory
supervision, control, jurisdiction or advisory
power.
power.
 
What is a Quorum?
NRS 241.015(5)
A simple majority of the public
body’s membership
Or another proportion as required by
specific  statute
 
M
e
t
h
o
d
s
 
o
f
 
H
o
l
d
i
n
g
 
M
e
e
t
i
n
g
s
 
If properly noticed and open to the public,
If properly noticed and open to the public,
meetings may be held:
meetings may be held:
In person
In person
Via 
Via 
“remote technology system”
“remote technology system”
(teleconference or videoconference)
(teleconference or videoconference)
Hybrid (both in person & remote option)
Hybrid (both in person & remote option)
Exception: If public body comprised of all elected officials,
Exception: If public body comprised of all elected officials,
need physical meeting space
need physical meeting space
Qualification
Qualification
:  If using “remote technology system” only, the
:  If using “remote technology system” only, the
public must be able to hear/observe the meeting, provide live
public must be able to hear/observe the meeting, provide live
public comment during the meeting & have option to attend
public comment during the meeting & have option to attend
meeting via telephone (requires web-based link + phone
meeting via telephone (requires web-based link + phone
number)
number)
 
Special Note
 
 
Serial Electronic
communication must not be
used to circumvent the
spirit or letter of the Open
Meeting Law
(NRS 241.016(4))
 
So be careful when
communicating over email
 
Watch Out for “Walking Quorum”
NRS 241.015(3)(a)(2)
 
If a public body’s members engage in
If a public body’s members engage in
a 
a 
series
series
 of gatherings at which:
 of gatherings at which:
(I) Less than a quorum is present at any
(I) Less than a quorum is present at any
individual gathering;
individual gathering;
(II) But, the members of the public body
(II) But, the members of the public body
attending one or more of the gatherings
attending one or more of the gatherings
collectively constitute a quorum
collectively constitute a quorum
; and
; and
(III) The 
(III) The 
series
series
 of gatherings was held
 of gatherings was held
with the 
with the 
specific intent
specific intent
 to avoid the
 to avoid the
OML= 
OML= 
OML violation
OML violation
 
Exception:  Attorney-Client
Communications
 
Quorum of board members may gather to:
Quorum of board members may gather to:
Receive information from the public body’s
Receive information from the public body’s
attorney regarding potential or existing
attorney regarding potential or existing
litigation, and to deliberate toward a decision=
litigation, and to deliberate toward a decision=
NOT a meeting 
NOT a meeting 
(NRS 241.015(3)(b)(2))
(NRS 241.015(3)(b)(2))
Receive training from the public body’s
Receive training from the public body’s
attorney regarding legal obligations, if public
attorney regarding legal obligations, if public
body does NOT deliberate toward a decision=
body does NOT deliberate toward a decision=
NOT a meeting
NOT a meeting
E-mail communication with the board’s
E-mail communication with the board’s
attorney= 
attorney= 
generally
generally
 NOT a meeting
 NOT a meeting
 
 
- 
- 
But do not hit “Reply All”
But do not hit “Reply All”
 
E
x
c
e
p
t
i
o
n
:
 
 
S
o
c
i
a
l
 
F
u
n
c
t
i
o
n
N
R
S
 
2
4
1
.
0
1
5
(
3
)
(
b
)
(
1
)
 
 
Even if a quorum is present, social
Even if a quorum is present, social
functions are NOT meetings, as long as
functions are NOT meetings, as long as
the members do 
the members do 
not deliberate
not deliberate
 toward a
 toward a
decision or take action on any matter over
decision or take action on any matter over
which the public body has supervision,
which the public body has supervision,
control, jurisdiction or advisory power.
control, jurisdiction or advisory power.
 
Don’t turn a party into a
Don’t turn a party into a
meeting!!
meeting!!
 
N
o
t
i
c
e
 
o
f
 
M
e
e
t
i
n
g
N
R
S
 
2
4
1
.
0
2
0
 
Content
Content
Day, Time, Location (include room)
Day, Time, Location (include room)
If a meeting location is offered
If a meeting location is offered
, must make
, must make
reasonable efforts to ensure meeting location is large
reasonable efforts to ensure meeting location is large
enough to accommodate anticipated number of
enough to accommodate anticipated number of
attendees. 
attendees. 
(Capacity limits O.K.)
(Capacity limits O.K.)
If meeting held using “remote technology system”
If meeting held using “remote technology system”
ONLY:
ONLY:
How public can use system to hear/observe meeting
How public can use system to hear/observe meeting
How public can participate in meeting via telephone
How public can participate in meeting via telephone
How public can provide live public comment (and if authorized
How public can provide live public comment (and if authorized
by public body, pre-recorded public comment)
by public body, pre-recorded public comment)
List of locations where notice posted
List of locations where notice posted
Contact info 
Contact info 
(including business address) 
(including business address) 
for person
for person
who can provide supporting materials
who can provide supporting materials
Means of providing public comment (options)
Means of providing public comment (options)
Agenda
Agenda
 
N
o
t
i
c
e
 
o
f
 
M
e
e
t
i
n
g
 
c
o
n
t
N
R
S
 
2
4
1
.
0
2
0
 
Posting
Posting
Principal office of public body + 
Principal office of public body + 
3 prominent places (No
3 prominent places (No
longer a requirement)
longer a requirement)
Websites (public body website (if there is one) & state
Websites (public body website (if there is one) & state
noticing website))
noticing website))
Additional requirement for “Remote Technology”
Additional requirement for “Remote Technology”
meetings only:
meetings only:
Public body MUST have website & post notice,
Public body MUST have website & post notice,
supporting materials to the website.
supporting materials to the website.
Mailing
Mailing
Subscription- mail or email
Subscription- mail or email
3 Working Days prior to meeting (by 9 a.m.)
3 Working Days prior to meeting (by 9 a.m.)
 
A
g
e
n
d
a
N
R
S
 
2
4
1
.
0
2
0
 
Clear and Complete statement of topics to be
considered (stringent standard)
Could your neighbor understand what is going to happen
at the meeting?
 
Notation “For Possible Action” if action item
Informational Discussion
Deliberation
Collectively examining, weighing and reflecting upon the
reasons for or against an action.
Includes collective exchange of facts preliminary to
ultimate decision.
Action
Decision, commitment or promise, affirmative vote
 
 
 
A
g
e
n
d
a
 
c
o
n
t
N
R
S
 
2
4
1
.
0
2
0
 
Public Comment Periods
Block of time at beginning and end of meeting; or
During each action item
(After public body has discussed item, but before public
body has taken any action on that item)
Cannot restrict a speaker’s viewpoint
However, conduct that disrupts the meeting’s order,
efficiency or safety may be limited
Board cannot deliberate or take action in response to
public comment, unless item is already on the agenda
 
Notice that agenda items may be:
Taken out of order
Combined
Removed or delayed discussion
 
M
a
t
e
r
i
a
l
s
 
A
v
a
i
l
a
b
l
e
 
t
o
 
t
h
e
 
P
u
b
l
i
c
Agenda
Agenda
Supporting Materials
Supporting Materials
Must be posted on public body’s website
Must be posted on public body’s website
Upon being 
Upon being 
available
available
 to the “public body”
 to the “public body”
supporting materials must be made available to
supporting materials must be made available to
the public.
the public.
Can be before meeting or on the day of the meeting
Can be before meeting or on the day of the meeting
If on day of meeting, post to website within 24 hours
If on day of meeting, post to website within 24 hours
Can be made available by e-mail or emailed
Can be made available by e-mail or emailed
link if the requester approves
link if the requester approves
 
Action—Voting Minimums
 
If a public body may have a member
If a public body may have a member
who is 
who is 
not an elected official
not an elected official
, an
, an
affirmative vote taken by a 
affirmative vote taken by a 
majority
majority
of the members present 
of the members present 
during a
during a
meeting of the public body
meeting of the public body
NRS 241.015(1)(c)
NRS 241.015(1)(c)
 
If all the members of a public body
If all the members of a public body
are elected officials, an affirmative
are elected officials, an affirmative
vote taken by a majority of all the
vote taken by a majority of all the
members of the public body
members of the public body
NRS 241.015(1)(d)
NRS 241.015(1)(d)
 
M
i
n
u
t
e
s
N
R
S
 
2
4
1
.
0
3
5
Minutes must contain:
Minutes must contain:
Date, time, location of meeting
Date, time, location of meeting
Members present
Members present
Substance of all matters discussed or decided
Substance of all matters discussed or decided
Remarks made by member of public (if person requests
Remarks made by member of public (if person requests
minutes reflect remarks)
minutes reflect remarks)
Meetings must be 
Meetings must be 
audio-recorded
audio-recorded
 or transcribed by
 or transcribed by
certified court reporter. Recordings retained for 3
certified court reporter. Recordings retained for 3
years.
years.
Minutes must be available within 
Minutes must be available within 
30 working days
30 working days
after meeting. Can post 
after meeting. Can post 
draft 
draft 
minutes on website
minutes on website
prior to approval. Retained for 5 years.
prior to approval. Retained for 5 years.
Approved w/in 45 days or at the next meeting
Approved w/in 45 days or at the next meeting
(whichever later)
(whichever later)
 
Corrective Action
 
If an OML violation occurs, the public
body may take corrective action within
30 days
 
If appropriate corrective action taken,
Attorney General’s Office may elect not
to prosecute the OML violation.
 
E
n
f
o
r
c
e
m
e
n
t
 
Person may make OML complaint to
Nevada Attorney General’s Office
AG notifies public body of complaint w/in 14 days
If complaint submitted w/in 120 days of alleged
violation, AG MUST investigate.
If complaint submitted after 120 days, AG will NOT
investigate
Exception:  Alleged violation not previously discoverable &
complaint submitted w/in 1 year.
AG not required to investigate an alleged OML
violation if person’s interests are not “significantly
affected” by alleged violation.
Example:  Person doesn’t live within public body’s
geographic area
 
Enforcement, cont…
 
If AG conducts investigation, it will inform
public body
After investigation complete, AG will
issue:
A finding that NO violation occurred; OR
A finding that a violation occurred + an explanation
for this finding
Public body submits response w/in 30
days
If AG finds an OML violation, public body
must acknowledge finding on next agenda
 
OML Violations
 
AG may bring a legal proceeding to
AG may bring a legal proceeding to
void an action
void an action
 taken in violation of
 taken in violation of
the Open Meeting Law; or to 
the Open Meeting Law; or to 
obtain
obtain
an injunction
an injunction
 to prevent violations of
 to prevent violations of
the Open Meeting Law
the Open Meeting Law
 
A private citizen may also bring a
A private citizen may also bring a
legal proceeding
legal proceeding
 
O
M
L
 
V
i
o
l
a
t
i
o
n
s
 
Action taken in violation of the Open Meeting Law
Action taken in violation of the Open Meeting Law
is 
is 
void
void
 - NRS 241.036
 - NRS 241.036
 
OML violations may result in administrative fines
OML violations may result in administrative fines
against board members
against board members
1
1
st
st
 offense:  $500; 2
 offense:  $500; 2
nd
nd
: $1,000; 3
: $1,000; 3
rd
rd
: $2,500
: $2,500
 
Serious violations of the OML (member has
Serious violations of the OML (member has
knowledge of violation & participates in violation)
knowledge of violation & participates in violation)
can result in 
can result in 
misdemeanor
misdemeanor
 charges
 charges
 
However, if a board member violates the OML
However, if a board member violates the OML
because the board member is relying on legal
because the board member is relying on legal
advice of board counsel= no administrative fine or
advice of board counsel= no administrative fine or
criminal penalty.
criminal penalty.
 
A
d
v
i
c
e
 
 
Don’t assume that other public body
members will be able to spot every
issue!
 
Discuss any questions/issues with
legal counsel
 
S
o
u
r
c
e
s
 
o
f
 
I
n
f
o
r
m
a
t
i
o
n
 
NRS Chapter 241
NRS Chapter 241
Open Meeting Law Manual
Open Meeting Law Manual
published by the Attorney
published by the Attorney
General’s Office
General’s Office
Available online at
Available online at
http://ag.state.nv.us
http://ag.state.nv.us
Opinions from the Attorney
Opinions from the Attorney
General’s Office relating to
General’s Office relating to
the OML
the OML
Available online at
Available online at
http://ag.state.nv.us
http://ag.state.nv.us
 
 
A
n
y
 
Q
u
e
s
t
i
o
n
s
 
Slide Note
Embed
Share

Nevada's Open Meeting Law (OML) ensures that the deliberations and actions of public bodies are conducted openly in order to aid in the conduct of the people's business. The law applies to all meetings where deliberation or action may occur. Public bodies covered by OML include boards, commissions, committees, and other entities supported by tax revenue. OML sets out requirements for public body meetings, including notice, agenda, and minutes. The law also allows for meetings to be held in person, via remote technology systems, or in a hybrid format, with specific guidelines for public participation.

  • OML
  • Open Meeting Law
  • Public Body
  • Nevada
  • Washoe County

Uploaded on Aug 19, 2024 | 0 Views


Download Presentation

Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author. Download presentation by click this link. If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. NEVADAS OPEN MEETING LAW Washoe County District Attorney s Office

  2. Legislative Intent of OML NRS 241.010 sets forth a legislative declaration: Public bodies exist to aid in the conduct of the people s business. It is the intent of the OML that board deliberations and board actions be conducted openly.

  3. When Does the OML Apply? In general, OML applies to all meetings of a public body at which deliberation takes place and/or action may occur.

  4. Pillars of the OML Public Body Meeting Notice Agenda Minutes AB 253 (2021): No major revisions However, AB 253 put some structure around remote technology meetings

  5. Public Body NRS 241.015(4) Any administrative, advisory, executive or legislative body of the state or local government which expends or disburses or is supported in whole or in part by tax revenue or which advises or makes recommendations to an entity which expends or disburses or is supported in whole or in part by tax revenue includes any board, commission, committee, subcommittee or other subsidiary thereof

  6. Meeting NRS 241.015(3)(a)(1) In general, a meeting is: The gathering of members of a public body at which a quorum is present to deliberate toward a decision or to take action on any matter over which the public body has supervision, control, jurisdiction or advisory power.

  7. What is a Quorum? NRS 241.015(5) A simple majority of the public body s membership Or another proportion as required by specific statute

  8. Methods of Holding Meetings If properly noticed and open to the public, meetings may be held: In person Via remote technology system (teleconference or videoconference) Hybrid (both in person & remote option) Exception: If public body comprised of all elected officials, need physical meeting space Qualification: If using remote technology system only, the public must be able to hear/observe the meeting, provide live public comment during the meeting & have option to attend meeting via telephone (requires web-based link + phone number)

  9. Special Note Serial Electronic communication must not be used to circumvent the spirit or letter of the Open Meeting Law (NRS 241.016(4)) So be careful when communicating over email

  10. Watch Out for Walking Quorum NRS 241.015(3)(a)(2) If a public body s members engage in a series of gatherings at which: (I) Less than a quorum is present at any individual gathering; (II) But, the members of the public body attending one or more of the gatherings collectively constitute a quorum; and (III) The series of gatherings was held with the specific intent to avoid the OML= OML violation

  11. Exception: Attorney-Client Communications Quorum of board members may gather to: Receive information from the public body s attorney regarding potential or existing litigation, and to deliberate toward a decision= NOT a meeting (NRS 241.015(3)(b)(2)) Receive training from the public body s attorney regarding legal obligations, if public body does NOT deliberate toward a decision= NOT a meeting E-mail communication with the board s attorney= generally NOT a meeting - But do not hit Reply All

  12. Exception: Social Function NRS 241.015(3)(b)(1) Even if a quorum is present, social functions are NOT meetings, as long as the members do not deliberate toward a decision or take action on any matter over which the public body has supervision, control, jurisdiction or advisory power. Don t turn a party into a meeting!!

  13. Notice of Meeting NRS 241.020 Content Day, Time, Location (include room) If a meeting location is offered, must make reasonable efforts to ensure meeting location is large enough to accommodate anticipated number of attendees. (Capacity limits O.K.) If meeting held using remote technology system ONLY: How public can use system to hear/observe meeting How public can participate in meeting via telephone How public can provide live public comment (and if authorized by public body, pre-recorded public comment) List of locations where notice posted Contact info (including business address) for person who can provide supporting materials Means of providing public comment (options) Agenda

  14. Notice of Meeting cont NRS 241.020 Posting Principal office of public body + 3 prominent places (No longer a requirement) Websites (public body website (if there is one) & state noticing website)) Additional requirement for Remote Technology meetings only: Public body MUST have website & post notice, supporting materials to the website. Mailing Subscription- mail or email 3 Working Days prior to meeting (by 9 a.m.)

  15. Agenda NRS 241.020 Clear and Complete statement of topics to be considered (stringent standard) Could your neighbor understand what is going to happen at the meeting? Notation For Possible Action if action item Informational Discussion Deliberation Collectively examining, weighing and reflecting upon the reasons for or against an action. Includes collective exchange of facts preliminary to ultimate decision. Action Decision, commitment or promise, affirmative vote

  16. Agenda cont NRS 241.020 Public Comment Periods Block of time at beginning and end of meeting; or During each action item (After public body has discussed item, but before public body has taken any action on that item) Cannot restrict a speaker s viewpoint However, conduct that disrupts the meeting s order, efficiency or safety may be limited Board cannot deliberate or take action in response to public comment, unless item is already on the agenda Notice that agenda items may be: Taken out of order Combined Removed or delayed discussion

  17. Materials Available to the Public Agenda Supporting Materials Must be posted on public body s website Upon being available to the public body supporting materials must be made available to the public. Can be before meeting or on the day of the meeting If on day of meeting, post to website within 24 hours Can be made available by e-mail or emailed link if the requester approves

  18. ActionVoting Minimums If a public body may have a member who is not an elected official, an affirmative vote taken by a majority of the members present during a meeting of the public body NRS 241.015(1)(c) If all the members of a public body are elected officials, an affirmative vote taken by a majority of all the members of the public body NRS 241.015(1)(d)

  19. Minutes NRS 241.035 Minutes must contain: Date, time, location of meeting Members present Substance of all matters discussed or decided Remarks made by member of public (if person requests minutes reflect remarks) Meetings must be audio-recorded or transcribed by certified court reporter. Recordings retained for 3 years. Minutes must be available within 30 working days after meeting. Can post draft minutes on website prior to approval. Retained for 5 years. Approved w/in 45 days or at the next meeting (whichever later)

  20. Corrective Action If an OML violation occurs, the public body may take corrective action within 30 days If appropriate corrective action taken, Attorney General s Office may elect not to prosecute the OML violation.

  21. Enforcement Person may make OML complaint to Nevada Attorney General s Office AG notifies public body of complaint w/in 14 days If complaint submitted w/in 120 days of alleged violation, AG MUST investigate. If complaint submitted after 120 days, AG will NOT investigate Exception: Alleged violation not previously discoverable & complaint submitted w/in 1 year. AG not required to investigate an alleged OML violation if person s interests are not significantly affected by alleged violation. Example: Person doesn t live within public body s geographic area

  22. Enforcement, cont If AG conducts investigation, it will inform public body After investigation complete, AG will issue: A finding that NO violation occurred; OR A finding that a violation occurred + an explanation for this finding Public body submits response w/in 30 days If AG finds an OML violation, public body must acknowledge finding on next agenda

  23. OML Violations AG may bring a legal proceeding to void an action taken in violation of the Open Meeting Law; or to obtain an injunction to prevent violations of the Open Meeting Law A private citizen may also bring a legal proceeding

  24. OML Violations Action taken in violation of the Open Meeting Law is void - NRS 241.036 OML violations may result in administrative fines against board members 1st offense: $500; 2nd: $1,000; 3rd: $2,500 Serious violations of the OML (member has knowledge of violation & participates in violation) can result in misdemeanor charges However, if a board member violates the OML because the board member is relying on legal advice of board counsel= no administrative fine or criminal penalty.

  25. Advice Don t assume that other public body members will be able to spot every issue! Discuss any questions/issues with legal counsel

  26. Sources of Information NRS Chapter 241 Open Meeting Law Manual published by the Attorney General s Office Available online at http://ag.state.nv.us Opinions from the Attorney General s Office relating to the OML Available online at http://ag.state.nv.us

  27. Any Questions

More Related Content

giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#