Kentucky Attorney General's Involvement in Tobacco Enforcement and the Master Settlement Agreement
K
e
n
t
u
c
k
y
O
f
f
i
c
e
o
f
t
h
e
A
t
t
o
r
n
e
y
G
e
n
e
r
a
l
I
n
v
o
l
v
e
m
e
n
t
i
n
T
o
b
a
c
c
o
E
n
f
o
r
c
e
m
e
n
t
a
n
d
t
h
e
M
a
s
t
e
r
S
e
t
t
l
e
m
e
n
t
A
g
r
e
e
m
e
n
t
T
o
b
a
c
c
o
S
e
t
t
l
e
m
e
n
t
A
g
r
e
e
m
e
n
t
F
u
n
d
O
v
e
r
s
i
g
h
t
C
o
m
m
i
t
t
e
e
M
a
y
1
8
,
2
0
2
1
Master Settlement Agreement Background
•
Kentucky and 51 other states and territories signed the Master Settlement
Agreement(“MSA”) in November 1998 with the major US tobacco
companies.
•
Four states have their own MSAs: MS, MN, TX and FL.
•
States dropped lawsuits over smoking-related costs in return for annual
payments from the companies to address these expenditures, as well as
marketing restrictions to reduce youth smoking.
•
Allegations in the state suits included youth targeting, fraud regarding the
health effects of cigarettes and nicotine, conspiracy and defective design
.
2
MSA Background (cont.)
•
MSA payments are based on cigarettes sold in the US by the participating
manufacturers.
•
The payments are calculated by an independent auditor, currently Price
Waterhouse.
•
Kentucky has received $2.4 billion so far.
•
Payments will continue as long as MSA companies sell traditional cigarettes
or Roll Your Own(“RYO”),
but
money was not the only goal of the MSA.
3
MSA Background (cont.)
•
MSA marketing restrictions included limits on advertising only possible
through agreement without years of litigation.
•
The MSA parties “are committed to reducing underage tobacco use by
discouraging such use and by preventing Youth access to Tobacco
Products.”
•
Attacking youth smoking reduces health costs in the long run as well
as improving health as most smokers become addicted by age 20.
•
The MSA created and funded a foundation(first “American Legacy,”
now “Truth”) with the purpose of reducing youth smoking.
•
Substantial reductions in youth smoking as well as adult rates have
occurred (now 10-15% compared to 30-35% in 1998).
•
State funding for Kentucky's tobacco control programs comes from
annual MSA payments, along with agricultural diversification and other
important programs.
4
MSA Background (cont.)
MSA marketing restrictions include:
•
Prohibiting “youth targeting” by tobacco companies
•
Ban on cartoons in ads
•
Limitations on brand name sponsorships
•
Ban on outdoor advertising/billboards
•
Ban on brand name merchandise, free samples,
misrepresentation of the health effects of smoking
5
MSA Background (cont.)
•
The Attorneys General from MSA states have working groups
designed to investigate and enforce MSA violations as well as
to maximize payments from the companies.
•
Marketing, nationally and at retail, is reviewed to look for
compliance issues and some cases have been filed by states.
•
Ad placement in magazines, Kool Mixx, Camel Farmrocks, and
Eclipse are some examples of state actions.
•
With FDA authority expanded since 2010, some enforcement
has moved to the federal level.
6
Kentucky MSA-Related Legislation
2000: ALLOCATION OF MSA FUNDS (KRS 248.654)
ESCROW STATUTE (KRS 131.600-131.602)
MSA COMPLIANCE ADVISORY BOARD (KRS 15.300)
2003: DIRECTORY STATUTE (KRS 131.604-131.630)
2015: ENHANCED ESCROW ENFORCEMENT (various KRS)
7
Kentucky MSA-related legislation (cont.)
ALLOCATION OF MSA FUNDS
:
•
Divided MSA proceeds into three accounts:
•
50%-agricultural development/diversification,
•
25%-early childhood development,
•
25%-health care improvement.
ESCROW STATUTE
:
•
Required non-MSA cigarette makers to escrow about the same per
carton as MSA companies pay to the states per carton;
•
Currently over $100 million deposited in escrow accounts for KY sales.
MSA COMPLIANCE ADVISORY BOARD
:
•
Created a six-member board to review and discuss potential MSA
violations in quarterly meetings (OAG, Health, Public Protection and
Agriculture agencies represented, along with two citizen members).
8
Kentucky MSA-Related Legislation (cont.)
DIRECTORY STATUTE
:
•
Created tobacco directory to require manufacturers to certify each year to be
listed on the approved list of brands to be stamped. (Currently 18 MSA
companies and 10 non-MSA companies are listed).
•
OAG reviews and approves changes.
•
DOR and OAG jointly enforce and coordinate to create and post the directory
of approved brands with changes to it as needed.
ENHANCED ESCROW ENFORCEMENT AMENDMENTS
:
•
Bonding for all non-MSA companies to ensure compliance ($50k+)
•
Made delisted cigarettes contraband after 30 day notice of removal
•
Joint liability for importers must be agreed to for certification
9
10
11
12
•
https://www.cdc.gov/tobac
co/data_statistics/fact_shee
ts/youth_data/tobacco_use
/index.htm
13
The Toll of Tobacco in Kentucky
•
High school students who smoke: 8.9% (21,000)
•
High school students who use e-cigarettes: 26.1%
•
Kids (under 18) who become new daily smokers each year: 1,800
•
Adults in Kentucky who smoke: 23.6% (817,900)
•
Proportion of cancer deaths attributable to smoking: 34.0%
•
Adults who die each year from their own smoking: 8,900
•
Annual health care costs in Kentucky directly caused by smoking: $1.92 billion
Source: Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids
14
R
e
c
e
n
t
K
e
n
t
u
c
k
y
A
n
n
u
a
l
M
S
A
P
a
y
m
e
n
t
s
•
2021:
$127 million
•
2020:
$112 million
•
2019:
$117 million
•
2018:
$102 million
•
2017:
$93 million
•
2016:
$90 million
15
P
o
t
e
n
t
i
a
l
C
a
u
s
e
s
o
f
F
u
t
u
r
e
D
e
c
l
i
n
e
s
i
n
M
S
A
P
a
y
m
e
n
t
s
1.
MSA brand sales decline.
•
MSA payments are based on national excise tax-paid
cigarette volumes of the participating companies.
•
Reductions in the volume of those sales in the future
will reduce MSA payments. Such sales had been
declining 2-4% each year, until 2020 when sales stayed
the same as the prior year.
•
Sales of non-MSA brands also reduce state payments.
16
P
o
t
e
n
t
i
a
l
C
a
u
s
e
s
o
f
F
u
t
u
r
e
D
e
c
l
i
n
e
s
i
n
M
S
A
P
a
y
m
e
n
t
s
2.
E-cigarettes/vapor/”Heat not burn”
product sales growth.
•
These products which are generally not covered by MSA
payments are estimated to displace a growing share of
the traditional cigarette market.
•
Altria has obtained FDA approval for sale of IQOS
products (heat not burn).
https://csnews.com/heat-
not-burn-next-big-thing-tobacco
.
•
Other non-MSA products include e-cigarettes, oral
pouches/SNUS and little cigars.
17
E-cigarette use
increasing
18
The Future of MSA Payments
•
MSA payments will continue as long as cigarettes are sold by
the party tobacco companies.
•
As sales of traditional cigarettes decline, that trend will
lower future payments.
•
Kentucky must continue to enforce the escrow statutes
against non-party companies to avoid and reduce NPM
adjustments.
•
Payments have averaged $110 million over the twenty years
of the agreement so far.
•
There is no limit in years of payments in the agreement.
19
Office of the Attorney General
Michael Plumley
Assistant Attorney General
Michael.Plumley@ky.gov
(502) 696-5613
Carmine Iaccarino
General Counsel
Carmine.Iaccarino@ky.gov
(502) 696-5369
Vic Maddox
Associate Attorney General
Victor.Maddox@ky.gov
(502) 696-5336
20
Kentucky's Office of the Attorney General is actively involved in tobacco enforcement efforts and the Master Settlement Agreement (MSA) with major U.S. tobacco companies. The MSA, signed by Kentucky and other states in 1998, aims to address smoking-related costs, restrict tobacco marketing, and reduce youth smoking. Kentucky has received significant funds from the MSA, which also supports tobacco control programs and youth smoking prevention initiatives.
Download Presentation
Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author. Download presentation by click this link. If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.
E N D
Presentation Transcript
Kentucky Office of the Attorney General Kentucky Office of the Attorney General Involvement in Tobacco Enforcement and the Master Involvement in Tobacco Enforcement and the Master Settlement Agreement Settlement Agreement Tobacco Settlement Agreement Fund Tobacco Settlement Agreement Fund Oversight Committee Oversight Committee May 18, 2021 May 18, 2021
Master Settlement Agreement Background Kentucky and 51 other states and territories signed the Master Settlement Agreement( MSA ) in November 1998 with the major US tobacco companies. Four states have their own MSAs: MS, MN, TX and FL. States dropped lawsuits over smoking-related costs in return for annual payments from the companies to address these expenditures, as well as marketing restrictions to reduce youth smoking. Allegations in the state suits included youth targeting, fraud regarding the health effects of cigarettes and nicotine, conspiracy and defective design. 2
MSA Background (cont.) MSA payments are based on cigarettes sold in the US by the participating manufacturers. The payments are calculated by an independent auditor, currently Price Waterhouse. Kentucky has received $2.4 billion so far. Payments will continue as long as MSA companies sell traditional cigarettes or Roll Your Own( RYO ), but money was not the only goal of the MSA. 3
MSA Background (cont.) MSA marketing restrictions included limits on advertising only possible through agreement without years of litigation. The MSA parties are committed to reducing underage tobacco use by discouraging such use and by preventing Youth access to Tobacco Products. Attacking youth smoking reduces health costs in the long run as well as improving health as most smokers become addicted by age 20. The MSA created and funded a foundation(first American Legacy, now Truth ) with the purpose of reducing youth smoking. Substantial reductions in youth smoking as well as adult rates have occurred (now 10-15% compared to 30-35% in 1998). State funding for Kentucky's tobacco control programs comes from annual MSA payments, along with agricultural diversification and other important programs. 4
MSA Background (cont.) MSA marketing restrictions include: Prohibiting youth targeting by tobacco companies Ban on cartoons in ads Limitations on brand name sponsorships Ban on outdoor advertising/billboards Ban on brand name merchandise, free samples, misrepresentation of the health effects of smoking 5
MSA Background (cont.) The Attorneys General from MSA states have working groups designed to investigate and enforce MSA violations as well as to maximize payments from the companies. Marketing, nationally and at retail, is reviewed to look for compliance issues and some cases have been filed by states. Ad placement in magazines, Kool Mixx, Camel Farmrocks, and Eclipse are some examples of state actions. With FDA authority expanded since 2010, some enforcement has moved to the federal level. 6
Kentucky MSA-Related Legislation 2000: ALLOCATION OF MSA FUNDS (KRS 248.654) ESCROW STATUTE (KRS 131.600-131.602) MSA COMPLIANCE ADVISORY BOARD (KRS 15.300) 2003: DIRECTORY STATUTE (KRS 131.604-131.630) 2015: ENHANCED ESCROW ENFORCEMENT (various KRS) 7
Kentucky MSA-related legislation (cont.) ALLOCATION OF MSA FUNDS: Divided MSA proceeds into three accounts: 50%-agricultural development/diversification, 25%-early childhood development, 25%-health care improvement. ESCROW STATUTE: Required non-MSA cigarette makers to escrow about the same per carton as MSA companies pay to the states per carton; Currently over $100 million deposited in escrow accounts for KY sales. MSA COMPLIANCE ADVISORY BOARD: Created a six-member board to review and discuss potential MSA violations in quarterly meetings (OAG, Health, Public Protection and Agriculture agencies represented, along with two citizen members). 8
Kentucky MSA-Related Legislation (cont.) DIRECTORY STATUTE: Created tobacco directory to require manufacturers to certify each year to be listed on the approved list of brands to be stamped. (Currently 18 MSA companies and 10 non-MSA companies are listed). OAG reviews and approves changes. DOR and OAG jointly enforce and coordinate to create and post the directory of approved brands with changes to it as needed. ENHANCED ESCROW ENFORCEMENT AMENDMENTS: Bonding for all non-MSA companies to ensure compliance ($50k+) Made delisted cigarettes contraband after 30 day notice of removal Joint liability for importers must be agreed to for certification 9
https://www.cdc.gov/tobac co/data_statistics/fact_shee ts/youth_data/tobacco_use /index.htm 13
The Toll of Tobacco in Kentucky High school students who smoke: 8.9% (21,000) High school students who use e-cigarettes: 26.1% Kids (under 18) who become new daily smokers each year: 1,800 Adults in Kentucky who smoke: 23.6% (817,900) Proportion of cancer deaths attributable to smoking: 34.0% Adults who die each year from their own smoking: 8,900 Annual health care costs in Kentucky directly caused by smoking: $1.92 billion Source: Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids 14
Recent Kentucky Annual MSA Payments Recent Kentucky Annual MSA Payments 2021: 2020: 2019: 2018: 2017: 2016: $127 million $112 million $117 million $102 million $93 million $90 million 15
1. MSA brand sales decline. Potential Potential Causes of Causes of Future Future Declines in Declines in MSA MSA Payments Payments MSA payments are based on national excise tax-paid cigarette volumes of the participating companies. Reductions in the volume of those sales in the future will reduce MSA payments. Such sales had been declining 2-4% each year, until 2020 when sales stayed the same as the prior year. Sales of non-MSA brands also reduce state payments. 16
2. E-cigarettes/vapor/Heat not burn product sales growth. Potential Potential Causes of Causes of Future Future Declines in Declines in MSA MSA Payments Payments These products which are generally not covered by MSA payments are estimated to displace a growing share of the traditional cigarette market. Altria has obtained FDA approval for sale of IQOS products (heat not burn). https://csnews.com/heat- not-burn-next-big-thing-tobacco. Other non-MSA products include e-cigarettes, oral pouches/SNUS and little cigars. 17
E-cigarette use increasing 18
The Future of MSA Payments MSA payments will continue as long as cigarettes are sold by the party tobacco companies. As sales of traditional cigarettes decline, that trend will lower future payments. Kentucky must continue to enforce the escrow statutes against non-party companies to avoid and reduce NPM adjustments. Payments have averaged $110 million over the twenty years of the agreement so far. There is no limit in years of payments in the agreement. 19
Office of the Attorney General Michael Plumley Assistant Attorney General Michael.Plumley@ky.gov (502) 696-5613 Carmine Iaccarino General Counsel Carmine.Iaccarino@ky.gov (502) 696-5369 Vic Maddox Associate Attorney General Victor.Maddox@ky.gov (502) 696-5336 20
