Discourse Analysis: Exploring Language & Power
Analyzing written
language
Text and discourse analysis
•
„The value of having some explicit knowledge of the grammar of written
language is that you can use this knowledge, not only to analyse the texts
but as a critical resource for asking questions about them”- (Halliday 1966)
•
Methods of text and discourse analysis help explain language in its context
of use
Discourse
•
Totality of interaction between humans within a given sphere or context
(e.g. political discourse: speeches, editorials in newspapers, books about
politics, comments by politicians in public arenas)
Discourse analysis
•
Analyzes not just the text, but also relevant background from the wider
discourse, such as what other texts have had to say, what the relationships
among participants, etc.
Discourse analysis
•
Methods focus on text, although they are in no way confined to it, and
include ways of analyzing how text is organized beyond the level of the
sentence as well as at the level of the sentence and below
Topics of interest
•
Genres
of discourse (various types of discourse in politics, the media, education, science,
business, etc.)
•
The relations between discourse and the
emergence of syntactic structure
•
The relations between text (discourse) and
context
•
The relations between discourse and
power
•
The relations between discourse and
interaction
•
The relations between discourse an
d cognition
Critical discourse analysis (CDA)
•
The analysis of texts in their social context
Research questions in CDA
•
Why was this text constructed at all?
•
To whom is it addressed, and why?
•
Does the writer of speaker have hidden purposes, and what are they?
•
What hidden assumptions and biases underlie the text?
Topics
•
Unequal power relations determined by gender, ethnicity, nationality, age,
wealth, education and culture
•
Not only does discourse reflect and illustrate these inequalities: it creates
them
CDA in law
•
The law of the land is created and implemented linguistically in courtroom
dialogue, written statutes and other texts
•
The legality or illegality of e.g. slavery is determined through such textual
processes
•
The phenomen of racism is inseparable from its textual manifestations
Ideology
•
CD analysts believe that ideology underpins most discourse and that in
order to critically deconstruct a text, it is necessary to make the ideology
explicit
•
E.g. racist utterances are often prefaced by a denial of bigotry (‘I’m not a
racist but…’) and sometimes this denial and the expression of prejudice can
take a much more subtle form
CDA
•
Examines any features of the text that will shed light on its meaning,
especially on those aspects that are hidden
•
Lexical choices, presuppositions, implicatures, metaphors, cohesive ties,
politeness pehnomena, grammatical options, stance and appraisal
CDA fields of interest
•
Racism and related forms of discrimination
•
Economic globalization
•
Gender studies
•
Discourse of advertising
CDA in legal contexts
•
Discourse-based injustices suffered during the trial by e.g. rape victims,
child abuse victims, aboriginal Australians charged with crimes, etc.
Genre analysis
•
Examines texts which are considered members of a genre to describe their
typical configuration in terms of their features, such as layout and
organization of concepts, and their use of vocabulary and grammar (their
lexicogrammar)
•
Texts take on certain characteristics which allow us to identify for whom
they were written and for what purposes
•
Another clue is the subject matter of the text
Exercise: identify the following texts in terms of where you think it
would be found, what its purpose is, who is writing for whom, what
might have come immediately before it and what might come
immediately after
•
Text 1: Preheat oven to 180 degrees. Grease one 9x13 inch pan.
•
Mix the flour, baking soda, baking powder, white sugar, brown sugar,
cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg, and salt in a large bowl until well blended. Beat
the eggs, oil, and vanilla in a separate bowl until smooth. Fold in the flour
mixture, then stir in the pumpkin.
Text 2
•
Mary has also been involved this year as a volunteer ESL teacher in our
Community English Language program. This program provides free English
language instruction for members of the community, and classes ate taught
by our university students. Mary has brought to the program an incredible
amount of enthusiasm and insight, and her students enjoyed having her as a
teacher, and also felt that they had learned quite a bit of English.
•
Mary’s enthusiasm, willingness to work hard, and ability to communicate
with people are all qualities which have been of great nenefit to our campus.
Text 3
•
Last summer, I worked as a receptionist at the Northern Hospital Health
Clinic. My position involved me in greeting and helping patients, scheduling
appointments, and handling insurance bulling under the guidance of the
office manager.
•
I hope you find that my background and skills would be beneficial to your
practice.
Text 4
•
Once upon a time, there was a little girl who lived on the edge of the forest.
Text 5
•
Discussion
•
Ellis and Mellsop (1985) concluded that de Clerambault’s syndrome is an
aetiologically heterogeneous disorder. Theories of aeiology have
encompassed alcholism, abortion, post-amphetamine depression, epilepsy,
head trauma and neurological disorders. None of these is relevant in this
case.
Genre
A staged, goal-oriented, purposeful activity in which speakers engage as
members of a culture
•
While there is variation within a given genre, as genres are not fixed, they
tend to follow a series of ‘moves’
•
E.g. Academic articles: Introduction – methods – results – discussion -
conclusion
Genre
•
Letter of recommendation:Recommendation, willingness to provide further
information if needed
•
Job application:Declaration of intention, willingness to provide more
information and attend an interview, along with contact details
•
Recipies: list of ingredients, step-by-step procedure
Recognizing Genre
•
These staged moves help us recognize genres and form the basis for our
own writing in recurring situations, allowing us to participate in
communicative situations in a way which others will recognize as targeted
toward a communicative purpose
•
In addition, we can recognize genres by the lexicogrammatical choices text
producers make
Discourse community
•
A group of people with a set of shared goals and purposes for
communicating, which leads to a type of communication which tends to be
replicated in similar ways
•
Many studies within genre-based research include descriptions of the
context in which the genres are embedded
Textual patterns
•
Labov’s analysis of spoken interview data:
•
Narrative structure:
•
Abstract (What was this about? – optional element)
•
Orientation (time, persons, place, situation)
•
Complication (a crisis point, turning point)
•
Evaluation (the teller’s attitude; not a separate step, pervades the whole narrative)
•
Result (What happened? Resolution to crisis)
•
Coda (optional way of finishing by returning listeners to present)
Textual patterns
•
Problem/solution pattern:
•
Situation
•
Problem
•
Response
•
Evaluation/result
Sample analysis: situation, problem, response,
result
•
So often in my teaching, I find students whose English is communicatively
strong, and possibly accurate too, until pen hits paper. Many are badly let
down and held back by their spelling. U decided to find out how I could help
these learners imrove this skill. There is very little EFL material on the
subject, so I also researched spelling for native speaker children and adults.
The results of that research have led to the following ideas on how to learn
spelling, some ways to teach it and some games to revise itl
Other patterns
•
Problem – solution (unable)
•
Goal – achievement (want to, would like to, in order to)
•
Opportunity – taking pattern (taking advantage of)
•
Desire - fulfillment pattern (attractive, helpful)
•
Gap in knowledge-filling pattern (in the absence of, given the lack of…)
Decide which pattern best describes the texts
below
•
If you would like to have a nice vacation in a Branson cabin rental we have
some of the nicest vacation rentals and cabins available anywhere
Lexical signaling
•
Patterns in text are often signaled by the word choices we make
Delve into the world of discourse analysis to uncover the intricate connections between written language, social contexts, and power dynamics. Explore topics such as text and discourse analysis, critical discourse analysis, and the impact of unequal power relations on communication.
Uploaded on Sep 08, 2024 | 0 Views
Download Presentation
Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.
You are allowed to download the files provided on this website for personal or commercial use, subject to the condition that they are used lawfully. All files are the property of their respective owners.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.
E N D
Presentation Transcript
Analyzingwritten language
Textand discourseanalysis The value ofhaving some explicit knowledge ofthe grammarofwritten language is that youcanuse this knowledge, notonlyto analyse the texts but as a critical resourcefor asking questionsaboutthem - (Halliday 1966) Methods oftext anddiscourse analysis help explainlanguage in its context ofuse
Discourse Totality ofinteraction between humanswithin a given sphere orcontext (e.g. political discourse: speeches, editorials in newspapers, booksabout politics, commentsby politicians in public arenas)
Discourse analysis Analyzes notjust the text, but also relevant backgroundfromthe wider discourse, suchas what othertexts have had to say, what the relationships amongparticipants, etc.
Discourse analysis Methods focuson text, although theyare in no wayconfinedto it, and include ways ofanalyzing how text is organizedbeyond the level ofthe sentence as well as at the level ofthe sentence andbelow
Topics of interest Genres of discourse (various types of discourse in politics, the media, education, science, business, etc.) The relations between discourse and the emergence ofsyntacticstructure The relations between text (discourse) and context The relations between discourse and power The relations between discourse and interaction The relations between discourse and cognition
Critical discourse analysis (CDA) The analysis oftexts in their social context
Research questions inCDA Why wasthis text constructedat all? To whomis it addressed, andwhy? Doesthe writer ofspeakerhave hidden purposes, andwhat are they? What hidden assumptions andbiases underliethe text?
Topics Unequalpowerrelations determined bygender, ethnicity, nationality, age, wealth, education andculture Notonlydoesdiscourse reflect andillustrate these inequalities: it creates them
CDA inlaw The law ofthe land is created andimplemented linguistically incourtroom dialogue, written statutes andother texts The legality orillegality ofe.g. slavery is determined throughsuchtextual processes The phenomenofracismis inseparable fromits textual manifestations
Ideology CD analysts believe that ideology underpins most discourse andthat in orderto critically deconstructa text, it is necessaryto make the ideology explicit E.g. racist utterances are oftenprefacedby a denial ofbigotry( I mnota racist but ) andsometimes this denial andthe expression ofprejudicecan take a muchmore subtle form
CDA Examinesanyfeaturesofthe text that will shedlight on its meaning, especially on those aspects that are hidden Lexical choices, presuppositions, implicatures, metaphors, cohesive ties, politeness pehnomena, grammaticaloptions, stance andappraisal
CDA fieldsof interest Racism andrelated formsofdiscrimination Economicglobalization Genderstudies Discourseofadvertising
CDA in legal contexts Discourse-basedinjustices sufferedduringthe trial by e.g. rapevictims, child abuse victims, aboriginalAustralians charged with crimes, etc.
Genre analysis Examines texts which are considered membersofa genreto describe their typical configurationinterms oftheir features, suchas layoutand organizationofconcepts, andtheir use ofvocabularyandgrammar(their lexicogrammar) Texts take on certain characteristics which allow usto identify for whom theywere written andfor what purposes Another clueis the subjectmatter ofthe text
Exercise: identify thefollowing texts in terms of whereyouthink it wouldbe found, what its purpose is, whois writing for whom, what might havecome immediately beforeit and what might come immediately after Text 1: Preheat oven to 180 degrees. Greaseone 9x13 inch pan. Mix the flour, baking soda, baking powder, white sugar, brownsugar, cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg, andsalt in a large bowl until well blended. Beat the eggs, oil, andvanilla ina separate bowl until smooth. Foldinthe flour mixture, then stir in the pumpkin.
Text 2 Maryhasalsobeen involved this yearas a volunteer ESL teacher inour CommunityEnglish Language program. This program provides free English languageinstruction for membersofthe community, andclasses ate taught by ouruniversity students. Maryhasbroughtto the program anincredible amountofenthusiasm andinsight, andherstudents enjoyedhaving heras a teacher, andalso felt that they had learnedquite a bit ofEnglish. Mary senthusiasm, willingness to workhard, andability to communicate with people are all qualities which have been ofgreat nenefit to ourcampus.
Text 3 Last summer, I workedas a receptionist at the Northern Hospital Health Clinic. My position involved me ingreeting andhelping patients, scheduling appointments, andhandling insurancebulling underthe guidanceofthe officemanager. I hopeyoufindthat mybackgroundandskills wouldbe beneficial to your practice.
Text 4 Onceupona time, there was a little girl who lived on the edge ofthe forest.
Text5 Discussion Ellis andMellsop (1985) concludedthat de Clerambault s syndromeis an aetiologically heterogeneousdisorder. Theories ofaeiologyhave encompassedalcholism, abortion, post-amphetamine depression, epilepsy, headtrauma andneurologicaldisorders. None ofthese is relevant inthis case.
Genre A staged, goal-oriented, purposefulactivity in which speakers engage as membersofa culture While there is variation within a given genre, as genres are notfixed, they tend to follow a series of moves E.g. Academicarticles: Introduction methods results discussion - conclusion
Genre Letter ofrecommendation:Recommendation, willingness to provide further informationif needed Jobapplication:Declaration ofintention, willingness to provide more informationandattend aninterview, alongwith contact details Recipies: list ofingredients, step-by-step procedure
RecognizingGenre These staged moveshelp usrecognize genres andformthe basis for our ownwriting inrecurringsituations, allowing usto participate in communicative situations ina waywhich others will recognize as targeted towarda communicative purpose In addition, we canrecognizegenres by the lexicogrammatical choices text producersmake
Discourse community A groupofpeople with a set ofshared goalsandpurposesfor communicating, which leads to a type ofcommunicationwhich tends to be replicated insimilar ways Many studies within genre-based researchinclude descriptions ofthe context inwhich thegenres are embedded
Textual patterns Labov sanalysisofspokeninterview data: Narrativestructure: Abstract (Whatwasthis about? optionalelement) Orientation(time, persons, place, situation) Complication(a crisispoint, turningpoint) Evaluation(the teller s attitude; nota separate step, pervadesthe wholenarrative) Result(Whathappened? Resolutionto crisis) Coda(optionalwayoffinishingby returning listeners to present)
Textual patterns Problem/solution pattern: Situation Problem Response Evaluation/result
Sample analysis: situation, problem, response, result Soofteninmyteaching, I find students whose English is communicatively strong, andpossibly accuratetoo, until penhits paper. Manyare badly let downandheld backby their spelling. U decided to findouthow I couldhelp these learners imrove this skill. There is very little EFL material on the subject, soI also researchedspelling for native speakerchildren andadults. The results ofthat researchhave led to the following ideas on how to learn spelling, some waysto teachit andsome games to revise itl
Other patterns Problem solution (unable) Goal achievement (want to, wouldlike to, in orderto) Opportunity taking pattern (taking advantage of) Desire - fulfillment pattern (attractive, helpful) Gap in knowledge-filling pattern (in the absence of, given the lackof )
Decidewhich pattern bestdescribesthe texts below Ifyouwouldlike to have a nice vacation ina Branson cabinrental we have some ofthe nicest vacation rentals andcabins available anywhere
Lexical signaling Patterns intext are oftensignaled by the word choiceswe make
