Insights into Mentor-Student Perceptions in Academia
Explore the nuanced perceptions and expectations between mentors and graduate students in academia, shedding light on common challenges faced by both parties. The images and descriptions provide a glimpse into the dynamics of mentorship relationships, highlighting the need for effective communication and mutual understanding for successful academic development.
Download Presentation
Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author. Download presentation by click this link. If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.
E N D
Presentation Transcript
Grad students vs. Mentors developed by R. Craft, based on student & faculty input Psychology Department Washington State University + material adapted from Fisher and Ury, Getting to Yes (1991)
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception My mentor keeps asking me to do more and more; s/he must think I have nothing else to do but eat and sleep research. This student keeps taking on more and more; s/he is so motivated and enthusiastic, s/he s really got what it takes to be a successful researcher. OR: I need to get the best/most performance that I can from this student; I just can t get to everything myself.
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception My mentor never lets me choose what I want to work on; s/he doesn t seem to think my ideas are valid. I have to keep this student focused on a single line of inquiry or s/he ll fall behind in the program (and we ll both look bad).
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception I'm afraid that any sign of weakness will be evaluated negatively by my mentor. I need to portray that I am handling everything well. My student is making mistakes but not owning up to them. S/he must be defensive (or clueless, or irresponsible).
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception My mentor is always criticizing my work. S/he must think I m really stupid. I need to make sure I m consistently offering feed- back to my student so that s/he can improve her/his performance as expediently as possible.
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception I never get any useful feedback from my mentor; s/he always says I m doing fine. How can I improve if I can t see what I m doing wrong? I m afraid to criticize my student too much; s/he may get frustrated if s/he sees me as too picky.
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception I have worked hard to gain admission here, plus paid a lot of money and risked a personal relationship to be here; this program owes me the best training possible. I have trained for many years to earn my qualifications, and my student needs to listen and learn from me in order to gain admission into the profession.
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception My mentor doesn t give me enough guidance. Graduate training is about developing a sense of independence.
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception My mentor always seems to change her/his mind on every draft of this paper I wish s/he would just make up her/his mind so I didn t have to keep making all these revisions. Drafting a good paper is a PROCESS it s important to try several possible ways of presenting and interpreting data, so that ultimately one arrives at the best product.
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception It seems like all my peers are getting a lot more/better ____________ (fill in the blank) than I am. It s really unfair that other students are getting all the breaks/support/funding (etc.). It s really important that I train my students the best way I know how. It s up to me to make sure my student leaves WSU well-prepared for their career.
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception My mentor gives me too much stuff to read there s no way anyone could digest all this in such a short period of time. I need to make sure I direct my student to all of the pertinent literature in this area so that s/he can gain competence and knowledge.
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception My mentor is not very friendly to me. Perhaps s/he doesn t like me, or is a cold person. My student seems overly friendly to me. The mentor- student relationship is about work, not play.
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception My mentor seems overly friendly to me; this is making me nervous because I will be evaluated by her/him. My student is not very friendly to me; perhaps s/he doesn t like me, or is a cold person.
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception My mentor never asks me how things are going; s/he must not care about my progress (or is too busy to make time for me). My student never brings up any concerns to me; everything must be going fine.
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception In comparison to my peers, I think I m doing fine in the program. When I compare my student s performance to mine when I was a graduate student, s/he is falling short.
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception I really need to take breaks in between tasks, in order to refocus/rejuvenate for the next task. It seems like every time I walk into the lab, my student is playing a computer game/texting a friend; s/he must not be getting anything done.
Mentor Perception Grad Student Perception My student seems to be struggling but I don t want to seem like I m prying, so I ll just wait until s/he talks to me. OR I can t risk getting involved in anything personal, because it s my job to evaluate this person. It s better to recommend that a student with problems seek therapy instead of talking to me. OR My student seems to be struggling, which scares me because I m afraid I won t be able to help, so I ll just ignore it and hope s/he gets help from someone else. OR Personal issues? I just thought s/he was lazy and unfocused (i.e., mentor completely misinterprets student s struggles). I m having a lot of personal issues that are impeding my progress in my program; I d talk to my mentor but s/he seems really unreceptive to discussing anything personal. I heard that s/he once told another student to go see a therapist if they were having problems.
How do I keep my relationship with my advisor on track? Ask for feedback at least once/semester Be proactive: keep your advisor informed of what you re doing (be visible: don t disappear ) Separate the problem from the person: avoid finger- pointing! ( I m having difficulty meeting this schedule rather than: You have unreasonable expectations ) Get on the same side of the table: I would really like to make better progress on my project, so I can continue to move through the program efficiently. Can you help me get past X roadblock?
