Philosophical Perspectives on the Meaning of Life
The Meaning
The Meaning
of Life
of Life
James Fodor, Mar 2021
James Fodor, Mar 2021
My Philosophical Views
•
Atheism: disbelief in existence of God
•
Naturalism: belief in natural entities only
A Theory of Meaning
•
Susan Wolf’s hybrid theory of meaning (spectrum)
•
Subjective aspect: the way someone feels
•
Objective aspect: what exists outside of feelings
Subjective Aspect
•
Why subjective: Gandhi disillusioned
•
Meaningful: satisfied, gripped, engaged, fulfilled,
interested
•
Not meaningful: alienated, bored, disengaged,
despairing
Objective Aspect
•
Why objective: Sisyphus
fulfilled
•
Something ‘larger than oneself’ or ‘outside oneself’
•
Something objectively valuable
A Theory of Value
•
Intrinsic vs extrinsic value
•
Joseph Raz’s humanistic principle: ‘the explanation
and justification of the goodness or badness of
anything derives ultimately from its contribution... to
human life (sentient life) and its quality’
•
Theories of human flourishing (wellbeing):
Hedonism
Preference satisfaction
Objective list theory
The Meaning of Life
“Our interest in being able to see our lives as
worthwhile from some point of view external to
ourselves... seem to me to be pervasive. By engaging
in projects of independent value, by protecting,
preserving, creating, realizing value whose source lies
outside of oneself, one can satisfy these interests.
Indeed, it is hard to see how one could satisfy these
interests in any other way.” (Susan Wolf)
The Meaning of Life
“A person’s life is meaningful to the extent that they
positively engage in objectively valuable projects.”
The Role of God
•
Unclear what this adds to the picture
•
Might affect what is valuable
•
Not needed for a theory of meaning
•
Is worship of God meaningful?
Notes
•
Uthman’s opening
•
Atheism not a view that is consistent with human life
•
Meaning is what something is directed towards – reason why it exists
•
Material objects/entities don’t have any mean in themselves. Meaning must be
provided by external agent (mind).
•
No objective meaning on the materialist worldview
•
Going from nothing to nowhere. ‘Lost train to nowhere’
•
Many prominent atheists share this view of atheism
•
Everything destined to extinction
•
Design vs purpose vs meaning
•
You can ‘make up’ meaning/subjective meaning
•
‘Finding meaning in life even if there is no meaning of life’
•
Subjective meaning is inadequate
•
If we make up our own meaning it is fiction. ‘Doesn’t have the grounding.
•
Our lives are the accidental product of mindless mechanical processes
•
Alex Rosenberg
•
Judging worldviews by coherence and justification/grounding
•
Argument against the coherence of atheism
•
Meaning while on the train, even though the train came from nothing and is going
nowhere
My Blog
•
Unclear what this adds to the picture
•
Might affect what is valuable
Delve into discussions on atheism, naturalism, theories of meaning, subjective and objective aspects of experience, theories of value, and the role of God in understanding the purpose and significance of human life. Philosophers like Susan Wolf and Joseph Raz offer insights into how engaging in valuable projects and understanding intrinsic and extrinsic value contribute to a meaningful life.
Download Presentation
Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.
You are allowed to download the files provided on this website for personal or commercial use, subject to the condition that they are used lawfully. All files are the property of their respective owners.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.
E N D
Presentation Transcript
The Meaning of Life James Fodor, Mar 2021
My Philosophical Views Atheism: disbelief in existence of God Naturalism: belief in natural entities only
A Theory of Meaning Susan Wolf s hybrid theory of meaning (spectrum) Subjective aspect: the way someone feels Objective aspect: what exists outside of feelings
Subjective Aspect Why subjective: Gandhi disillusioned Meaningful: satisfied, gripped, engaged, fulfilled, interested Not meaningful: alienated, bored, disengaged, despairing
Objective Aspect Why objective: Sisyphusfulfilled Something larger than oneself or outside oneself Something objectively valuable
A Theory of Value Intrinsic vs extrinsic value Joseph Raz shumanistic principle: the explanation and justification of the goodness or badness of anything derives ultimately from its contribution... to human life (sentient life) and its quality Theories of human flourishing (wellbeing): Hedonism Preference satisfaction Objective list theory
The Meaning of Life Our interest in being able to see our lives as worthwhile from some point of view external to ourselves... seem to me to be pervasive. By engaging in projects of independent value, by protecting, preserving, creating, realizing value whose source lies outside of oneself, one can satisfy these interests. Indeed, it is hard to see how one could satisfy these interests in any other way. (Susan Wolf)
The Meaning of Life A person s life is meaningful to the extent that they positively engage in objectively valuable projects.
The Role of God Unclear what this adds to the picture Might affect what is valuable Not needed for a theory of meaning Is worship of God meaningful?
Notes Uthman s opening Atheism not a view that is consistent with human life Meaning is what something is directed towards reason why it exists Material objects/entities don t have any mean in themselves. Meaning must be provided by external agent (mind). No objective meaning on the materialist worldview Going from nothing to nowhere. Lost train to nowhere Many prominent atheists share this view of atheism Everything destined to extinction Design vs purpose vs meaning You can make up meaning/subjective meaning Finding meaning in life even if there is no meaning of life Subjective meaning is inadequate If we make up our own meaning it is fiction. Doesn t have the grounding. Our lives are the accidental product of mindless mechanical processes Alex Rosenberg Judging worldviews by coherence and justification/grounding Argument against the coherence of atheism Meaning while on the train, even though the train came from nothing and is going nowhere
My Blog Unclear what this adds to the picture Might affect what is valuable
