Evolution of E-Procurement System in Macedonia

e-Procurement system in Macedonia - e-government application with an impact - 
 
2008-2009
 
Parallel functioning of WIS and e-Procurement system in Macedonia
Although increased usage of the two systems – 
potential problems of parallel
functioning!! 
 need for integration
 
 2008
 - launch of a web-information system (WIS) for publishing contract
notices/notifications (implemented through the Public Procurement Bureau)
 Public section of all published notices and notifications
 Mandatory usage of WIS – all CA’s are obliged to publish their CN’s and CAN’s
on this website
 
2006-2007
 – period for extensive development, testing and pilot
procurements; Legal basis for e-procurement provided
End of 2007 
– new Law on PP adopted → modifications to the system made →
detailed technical instructions prepared
01.01.2008
fully fledged e-PP system installed
2005
2006/2007
2008
2008/2009
 
2005
Initial idea through USAID eGov Project – technical
specifications prepared according to the PP process of a pilot institution
Consortium of 2 local IT companies selected to develop the software
solution
INITIAL DEVELOPMENT
INITIAL DEVELOPMENT
PROCES OF INTEGRATION
PROCES OF INTEGRATION
https://www.e-nabavki.gov.mk
oglasi-izvestuvanja.finance.gov.mk
https://e-nabavki.gov.mk
https://e-nabavki.gov.mk
SETUP AND DEVELOPMENT OF THE NEW
SETUP AND DEVELOPMENT OF THE NEW
INTEGRATED SYSTEM
INTEGRATED SYSTEM
 Prepared
 
Action Plan 
for e-Procurement
 Preparatory phase 
- 
development of the functional requirements,
development of the application 
(phase programming and modeling),
testing
 Promotion
 of the new integrated system 
as well as the e-procurement as a
field of public procurement
 Manuals
 
with instructions on how to use the EPPS for CA’s and EO’s
 Start up 
January 2010
 Exstensive trainings 
of the users 
both Contracting Authorities and
Economic Operators
FUNCTIONALITIES AND MAIN ASPECTS OF
FUNCTIONALITIES AND MAIN ASPECTS OF
THE SYSTEM (1)
THE SYSTEM (1)
Notification
       and
  publishing
Tendering,
     evaluation
  and selection
  e-auction
e-invoicing
       and
e-payment
Covered by the e-Procurement system
Within the scope of the EU Directives
Other relevant EU 
Legislation
Future plans
FUNCTIONALITIES AND MAIN ASPECTS OF
FUNCTIONALITIES AND MAIN ASPECTS OF
THE SYSTEM (2)
THE SYSTEM (2)
Web-based
 
- 
simple and user-friendly system
Centralized system
 
one location for all e- procurement transactions in Macedonia
Aligned
 
with the IDABC Functional Requirements (23 out of 26)
Enables conducting the 
entire
 
public procurement procedure electronically
Enables
 
electronic communication
 
between contracting authorities and domestic and
foreign economic operators
Eliminates paper work
 
thus ensuring efficiency and cost-effectiveness of the contract
award procedures
Overall internal (preparatory) procedure of the CA is automated (optional usage) –
Tender Workspace creation
Publication
 
of the Contract notice and tender documentation
FUNCTIONALITIES AND MAIN ASPECTS OF
FUNCTIONALITIES AND MAIN ASPECTS OF
THE SYSTEM (3)
THE SYSTEM (3)
Subscribe for INFO
 
on new Contract Notices published
Free download
 
of tender documentation (only registered EO)
Posting
 
questions
 
and
 
answers
Online submission
 
of tenders/requests to participate
Public opening
 
and
 
evaluation
 
of tenders
Selection of the most favorable tenderer, 
winner announcement
 
and notification to all
tenderers
Electronic Auctions
Generation of different 
statistical reports
Maintaining of electronic 
Tender Dossier
Wide use of 
digital signatures
It Architecture of the software solution
Security Addressed
All actions traced 
(logged in the system)
All confidential data encrypted/protected 
(256 bit data encryption
for all data transmitted and stored)
Access restricted 
to authorized persons only
Attempts  for access are logged and
 
available to auditors
System for electronic identification
2 IT Security Audits performed 
 recommendations implemented
Stress test performed 
 all PP procedures in the country can be
conducted electronically
Security Addressed
It Architecture of the software solution
Centralized 
web-based
 
application
Browser based: 
Internet Explorer, Mozilla, Opera, Chrome
3-tier architecture: 
Presentation, Business Logic & Database
Servers Operating system: 
MS Windows Server 2008 Enterprise R2 x64
Database:
 
Microsoft SQL Server 2008 R2 Enterprise x64
Programming Languages: 
C#, DHTML, Java Scripts, SQL, XML
Microsoft .NET Framework 4.
Microsoft Internet Information Services 7.5
Load Balancing
Clustering
FLOW OF THE E-PROCUREMENT PROCESS
FLOW OF THE E-PROCUREMENT PROCESS
e-Procurement
e-Procurement
System
System
Public
Public
Tenderer
Tenderer
Contracting Authority
Contracting Authority
 
6. Public opening
and evaluation
USERS OF THE SYSTEM
USERS OF THE SYSTEM
Public Procurement Bureau
 
– management, promotion and
monitoring of e-Procurement system
Contracting Authorities
 
– All state Institutions and Public
enterprises
Economic Operators 
– all interested companies
State Appeal Commission
State Audit Office
Public
 
– wide public information accessible
PROCUREMENT IN MACEDONIA –
PROCUREMENT IN MACEDONIA –
GENERAL REMARKS
GENERAL REMARKS
 In 2013 the volume of public procurement was 
52.5 billio
n
 
denars
(850 million euro) or 
12% 
of GDP
E-PROCUREMENT AS E-GOV SERVICE
E-PROCUREMENT AS E-GOV SERVICE
In 2013,
 15% 
of the procurement procedures were conducted completely by
electronic means via Electronic System for Public Procurement (ESPP) – 
e-
nabavki.gov.mk
Significant increase in e-procurement compared with previous years (shown
below)
 
Increased
number of
Contracting
authorities are
conducting
the
procedures via
ESPP
E-Auctions Defined
E-Auctions Defined
Macedonian solution 
for e-Auction – how it is performed on the system?
Only bidders with 
acceptable offers 
are invited
Conducted 
after the evaluation of bids 
and before awarding the contract
Can be used both in 
paper-form
 
and in 
electronic procedures
E-Auction 
Electronic auction shall not be used for awarding public
procurement certain services or works whose subject is the intellectual services
such as designing the design and similar services, as in cases where due to the
specificity subject of the contract is feasible to implement electronic auction
At least 2 acceptable offers
Submission of Final Price
Submission of Final Price
E-Auctions Defined
E-Auctions Defined
Two concepts 
for performing e-Auctions in Macedonia – lowest price and MEAT
E-auction when criteria is 
lowest 
price – the bidders are decreasing the initial
lowest price – the winner is always the one with the lowest price
E-auction when the criteria is 
MEAT
 
– the bidders are decreasing their OWN
price – the winner is the one with the highest number of points
In the
 
MEAT concept 
of e-Auction the points for the other elements (quality,
technical characteristics etc.) are given before the starting of the auction and
during the auction the rank of the bidders is calculated by formula (including all
variables)
Submission of Final Price
Submission of Final Price
E-Auctions Defined
E-Auctions Defined
Submission of Final Price
Submission of Final Price
 
 
Submission of Final Price
 - introduction of an additional step in the procedures when 
only
one acceptable tender 
is received or only one acceptable tender remained after the
evaluation of bids and before awarding the contract
 The single tenderer is given the possibility to reduce the initially offered price 
only once
,
thus obtaining its final price.
 Can be used both in 
paper-form
 
and in 
electronic procedures
 
This contributes to 
increasing the transparency
, on one hand, and 
reducing the number of
cancelled procedures
, on the other, in case when only one tender is submitted or only one
tender remained.
 
With the submission of final price can be avoided carrying on 
negotiated procedure
without prior publication of a contract
 
notice (in case of only one acceptable offer)
E-AUCTIONS – OBLIGATORY USAGE
E-AUCTIONS – OBLIGATORY USAGE
Electronic reverse auction 
may not start sooner than two da
ys
 from the date on which
invitations are sent to participate in electronic auction
Public opening
3 min. more 
in case of new price
Duration of e-auction 
minimum 15 min.
Average duration of auction 
35 minutes
Average decreasing per auction 
8 times
Average. Auctions on day 2013 – 
130  auctions
The most e-auctions on one day were carried out on 25
th
 November 2013 - 
372 e-
auctions
E-AUCTIONS (1)
E-AUCTIONS (1)
 
As obliged by law, nearly 
100%
 
of the procurement procedures in 2013 ended
with e-auction
 Average 
savings
 
per procedure when using e-auctions 
up to 17% 
compared
to the lowest price submitted in the pre-qualification phase (more than 
41
millions euro
 
in total)
E-AUCTIONS (1)
E-AUCTIONS (1)
 The ratio of conducted 
e-Auctions
in 2013
 
is biggest compared with
previous years
 In some industry sectors, there are
evidenced 
significant savings 
using e-
Auctions
IMPACT AND USAGE OF E-
IMPACT AND USAGE OF E-
PROCUREMENT
PROCUREMENT
1.350
 
registered Contracting Authorities (100% of all CA’s – public and state
bodies and agencies)
Over 
9.000
 
registered Economic Operators (domestic and foreign private
companies)
Approx.
 
18.500
 
Published Contract Notices on ESPP and over
 
11.000
published tender documentations (more than half of the procedures)
35.000
 
auctions were carried out in 2013, or  around 
70 per day
more than 
3.300
 
daily visitors on the ESPP platform (public sector, private
companies and NGOs)
IMPACT
IMPACT
Real benefits
For public institutions 
- 
Increased 
transparency
 and 
efficiency
 -
significant money savings,
 
time savings when processing and evaluating
the bids,
 
more efficient and standardized work procedures
, 
expanded
supplier base
For private sector 
- 
Increased 
competition
 and 
new business
opportunities
 to become government suppliers,
 
potential for corruption
significantly reduced, increased confidence in the public procurement
process, significantly reduced cost to bid.
For the society
 
- 
Accountability
 and 
trust
 in the process of spending
the public money, public money savings
Examples from real experiences – good practice
AWARDS AND RECOGNITIONS
AWARDS AND RECOGNITIONS
Prize awarded from the Government of
Republic of Macedonia for the 
best
implemented project 
- Electronic System
for Public Procurement according with
the Methodology “barometer of the
quality of institutions”(July 2013)
Recognitions from our Twinning partner
from Germany for being 
leader in the
region
 in the E-procurement (January
2013)
LESSONS LEARNT
LESSONS LEARNT
Strong political will 
- 
The implementation of EPPS would not have been
possible, had it not been for the crucial support and dedication of the leaders at
the highest levels of Government, the Ministry of information society, as well as
the Public Procurement Bureau.
Intensive promotional/training activities
 
- It is necessary to introduce
and implement continuous education and training for all potential system users 
Mandatory use regulated by the legislation
 
- The mandatory use of the
system, entirely or partially, has to be enabled through the national legislation
The approach taken must be 
step-by-step
 
addressing all of the stakeholders
The users
 
must first learn the procedures and legal framework
, then can easily
adopt the e-procurement platform
CURRENT AND FUTURE PLANS
CURRENT AND FUTURE PLANS
Stimulate and 
increase
 
the use of
electronic procedures
Introduce 
e-Catalogues
Introduce
 
e-Invoicing 
and
 
e-Payment
Introduce
 
Dynamic Purchasing system
M-r Marija Jovanoska
M-r Marija Jovanoska
 
Slide Note
Embed
Share

The e-Procurement system in Macedonia has evolved significantly since its initial development in 2008, with the launch of a web-information system for publishing contracts. The process of integration of various functionalities, setup, and development of the new integrated system have been crucial steps. The system covers tendering, evaluation, e-auction, notification, e-invoicing, e-payment, and complies with relevant EU legislation. Extensive trainings have been conducted for users, enhancing the efficiency of public procurement in the country.

  • E-Procurement
  • Macedonia
  • Integration
  • Public Procurement
  • EU Legislation

Uploaded on Sep 21, 2024 | 0 Views


Download Presentation

Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author. Download presentation by click this link. If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. e-Procurement system in Macedonia - e-government application with an impact -

  2. INITIAL DEVELOPMENT 2008 - launch of a web-information system (WIS) for publishing contract 2006-2007 period for extensive development, testing and pilot 2005 Initial idea through USAID eGov Project technical 2008-2009 Parallel functioning of WIS and e-Procurement system in Macedonia notices/notifications (implemented through the Public Procurement Bureau) procurements; Legal basis for e-procurement provided specifications prepared according to the PP process of a pilot institution Although increased usage of the two systems potential problems of parallel functioning!! need for integration Mandatory usage of WIS all CA s are obliged to publish their CN s and CAN s on this website 01.01.2008 fully fledged e-PP system installed Public section of all published notices and notifications End of 2007 new Law on PP adopted modifications to the system made detailed technical instructions prepared solution Consortium of 2 local IT companies selected to develop the software 2005 2006/2007 2008 2008/2009

  3. PROCES OF INTEGRATION oglasi-izvestuvanja.finance.gov.mk https://www.e-nabavki.gov.mk Kept functionalities of the two systems @ Improved and upgradedfunctionalities @ https://e-nabavki.gov.mk

  4. SETUP AND DEVELOPMENT OF THE NEW INTEGRATED SYSTEM Prepared Action Plan for e-Procurement Preparatory phase - development of the functional requirements, development of the application (phase programming and modeling), testing Promotion of the new integrated system as well as the e-procurement as a field of public procurement Manualswith instructions on how to use the EPPS for CA s and EO s Start up January 2010 Exstensive trainings of the users both Contracting Authorities and Economic Operators

  5. FUNCTIONALITIES AND MAIN ASPECTS OF THE SYSTEM (1) Covered by the e-Procurement system Future plans Tendering, evaluation and selection e-auction Notification and publishing e-invoicing and e-payment Other relevant EU Legislation Within the scope of the EU Directives

  6. FUNCTIONALITIES AND MAIN ASPECTS OF THE SYSTEM (2) Web-based - simple and user-friendly system Centralized system one location for all e- procurement transactions in Macedonia Aligned with the IDABC Functional Requirements (23 out of 26) Enables conducting the entire public procurement procedure electronically Enables electronic communication between contracting authorities and domestic and foreign economic operators Eliminates paper work thus ensuring efficiency and cost-effectiveness of the contract award procedures Overall internal (preparatory) procedure of the CA is automated (optional usage) Tender Workspace creation Publication of the Contract notice and tender documentation

  7. FUNCTIONALITIES AND MAIN ASPECTS OF THE SYSTEM (3) Subscribe for INFO on new Contract Notices published Free download of tender documentation (only registered EO) Posting questions and answers Online submission of tenders/requests to participate Public opening and evaluation of tenders Selection of the most favorable tenderer, winner announcement and notification to all tenderers Electronic Auctions Generation of different statistical reports Maintaining of electronic Tender Dossier Wide use of digital signatures

  8. Security Addressed It Architecture of the software solution All actions traced (logged in the system) All confidential data encrypted/protected (256 bit data encryption for all data transmitted and stored) Access restricted to authorized persons only Attempts for access are logged and available to auditors System for electronic identification 2 IT Security Audits performed recommendations implemented Stress test performed all PP procedures in the country can be conducted electronically

  9. It Architecture of the software solution Security Addressed Centralized web-based application Browser based: Internet Explorer, Mozilla, Opera, Chrome 3-tier architecture: Presentation, Business Logic & Database Servers Operating system: MS Windows Server 2008 Enterprise R2 x64 Database: Microsoft SQL Server 2008 R2 Enterprise x64 Programming Languages: C#, DHTML, Java Scripts, SQL, XML Microsoft .NET Framework 4. Microsoft Internet Information Services 7.5 Load Balancing Clustering

  10. FLOW OF THE E-PROCUREMENT PROCESS 1. Registration Contracting Authority 4. Download Call Notices & Documentation 6. Public opening and evaluation 7. Winner announcement 3. Search for notices 8. Publication of Award Notices e-Procurement System Tenderer 1. Registration 9. Forwarding of Award Notices 2. Publication of Call Notices & Call Documents 5. Bid preparation and submission Public

  11. USERS OF THE SYSTEM Public Procurement Bureau management, promotion and monitoring of e-Procurement system Contracting Authorities All state Institutions and Public enterprises Economic Operators all interested companies State Appeal Commission State Audit Office Public wide public information accessible

  12. PROCUREMENT IN MACEDONIA GENERAL REMARKS In 2013 the volume of public procurement was 52.5 billion denars (850 million euro) or 12% of GDP

  13. E-PROCUREMENT AS E-GOV SERVICE In 2013, 15% of the procurement procedures were conducted completely by electronic means via Electronic System for Public Procurement (ESPP) e- nabavki.gov.mk Significant increase in e-procurement compared with previous years (shown below) Increased number Contracting authorities are conducting the procedures via ESPP of

  14. Submission of Final Price E-Auctions Defined Macedonian solution for e-Auction how it is performed on the system? Only bidders with acceptable offers are invited Conducted after the evaluation of bids and before awarding the contract Can be used both in paper-form and in electronic procedures E-Auction Electronic auction shall not be used for awarding public procurement certain services or works whose subject is the intellectual services such as designing the design and similar services, as in cases where due to the specificity subject of the contract is feasible to implement electronic auction At least 2 acceptable offers

  15. Submission of Final Price E-Auctions Defined Two concepts for performing e-Auctions in Macedonia lowest price and MEAT E-auction when criteria is lowest price the bidders are decreasing the initial lowest price the winner is always the one with the lowest price E-auction when the criteria is MEAT the bidders are decreasing their OWN price the winner is the one with the highest number of points In the MEAT concept of e-Auction the points for the other elements (quality, technical characteristics etc.) are given before the starting of the auction and during the auction the rank of the bidders is calculated by formula (including all variables)

  16. E-Auctions Defined Submission of Final Price Submission of Final Price - introduction of an additional step in the procedures when only one acceptable tender is received or only one acceptable tender remained after the evaluation of bids and before awarding the contract The single tenderer is given the possibility to reduce the initially offered price only once, thus obtaining its final price. Can be used both in paper-form and in electronic procedures This contributes to increasing the transparency, on one hand, and reducing the number of cancelled procedures, on the other, in case when only one tender is submitted or only one tender remained. With the submission of final price can be avoided carrying on negotiated procedure without prior publication of a contract notice (in case of only one acceptable offer)

  17. E-AUCTIONS OBLIGATORY USAGE Electronic reverse auction may not start sooner than two days from the date on which invitations are sent to participate in electronic auction Public opening 3 min. more in case of new price Duration of e-auction minimum 15 min. Average duration of auction 35 minutes Average decreasing per auction 8 times Average. Auctions on day 2013 130 auctions The most e-auctions on one day were carried out on 25th November 2013 - 372 e- auctions

  18. E-AUCTIONS (1) As obliged by law, nearly 100% of the procurement procedures in 2013 ended with e-auction Average savings per procedure when using e-auctions up to 17% compared to the lowest price submitted in the pre-qualification phase (more than 41 millions euro in total)

  19. E-AUCTIONS (1) The ratio of conducted e-Auctions in 2013 is biggest compared with previous years In some industry sectors, there are evidenced significant savings using e- Auctions Activity/sector Percentage of savings IT and telecommunication goods and services 25.7% Fixed assets 21.3% Construction works 20.9% Industrial machines and equipment and related services 18.7%

  20. IMPACT AND USAGE OF E- PROCUREMENT 1.350 registered Contracting Authorities (100% of all CA s public and state bodies and agencies) Over 9.000 registered Economic Operators (domestic and foreign private companies) Approx. 18.500 Published Contract Notices on ESPP and over 11.000 published tender documentations (more than half of the procedures) 35.000 auctions were carried out in 2013, or around 70 per day more than 3.300 daily visitors on the ESPP platform (public sector, private companies and NGOs)

  21. IMPACT Real benefits For public institutions - Increased transparency and efficiency - significant money savings,time savings when processing and evaluating the bids,more efficient and standardized work procedures, expanded supplier base For private sector - Increased competition and new business opportunities to become government suppliers,potential for corruption significantly reduced, increased confidence in the public procurement process, significantly reduced cost to bid. For the society - Accountability and trust in the process of spending the public money, public money savings Examples from real experiences good practice

  22. AWARDS AND RECOGNITIONS Prize awarded from the Government of Republic of Macedonia for the best implemented project - Electronic System for Public Procurement according with the Methodology barometer of the quality of institutions (July 2013) Recognitions from our Twinning partner from Germany for being leader in the region in the E-procurement (January 2013)

  23. LESSONS LEARNT Strong political will - The implementation of EPPS would not have been possible, had it not been for the crucial support and dedication of the leaders at the highest levels of Government, the Ministry of information society, as well as the Public Procurement Bureau. Intensive promotional/training activities - It is necessary to introduce and implement continuous education and training for all potential system users Mandatory use regulated by the legislation - The mandatory use of the system, entirely or partially, has to be enabled through the national legislation The approach taken must be step-by-step addressing all of the stakeholders The users must first learn the procedures and legal framework, then can easily adopt the e-procurement platform

  24. CURRENT AND FUTURE PLANS Stimulate and increase the use of electronic procedures Introduce e-Catalogues Introduce e-Invoicing and e-Payment Introduce Dynamic Purchasing system

  25. M-r Marija Jovanoska

Related


More Related Content

giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#