Contemplating Cromwell: Was He a Hero or Villain?
Watch this short clip and think about why some people may
have disliked Cromwell, especially after he was dead!
BRAINSTORM!
In history we need to place facts into categories and
group information together in to sensible collections.
You are going to be given numerous facts about
Cromwell and your challenge is to place them in to the
correct category.
“Paint my picture exactly like me and
do not flatter me at all. Show all
these wrinkles, pimples, warts and
everything else as you see me.
Otherwise I will not pay a farthing
for it.”
This portrait was painted
around
1650 when Cromwell
was the most powerful man
in England
. This is what he
said to the painter, Sir Peter
Lely.
HERO OR VILLAIN?
Oliver , we
want you to
be our new
King!
Oliver Cromwell is a
good man. He has led us
through the Civil War,
one of the most
dangerous times in our
history.
It’s thanks to
him that we
have overcome
our enemies.
We look
forward to
peace under his
leadership.
HERO OR VILLAIN?
In 1657, while he was
still in power, people
said these things
about him:
Look at the following
sources and decide how
to organise them.
HERO OR VILLAIN?
“I tell you, we will cut off his
head with the crown upon it!”
Oliver Cromwell, speaking about wanting to
kill King Charles I in 1649. Charles I was
the rightful King but Cromwell persuaded
many people that he should be executed
after the Civil War. No-one had ever killed a
King before!
“Each of the attackers [Cromwell’s
men] picked up a child and used
it as a shield to keep themselves
from being shot. After they had
killed all in the Church, they went
into the vaults underneath where
all the women had hid
themselves.”
Written by Thomas Wood, an eyewitness, about
Cromwell’s attack on Ireland. Thomas wrote this
in 1663, three years after Cromwell’s death.
Charles II was King at the time, and he hated
Cromwell.
“The days of Oliver were
marvellous days of
prosperity, freedom and
peace.”
Written by a Bristol Baptist in 1685.
Puritan
religious leaders like this had
greater freedom under Cromwell.
“I did not call myself to be
the ruler of England.. I just
tried to do right, for God
and for the people.”
Oliver Cromwell, explaining why he
refused to be King. The title was offered
to him but he did not take it.
A painting of Oliver Cromwell
working with the Devil.
Painted in 1660, just after his
death.
Cromwell’s Home
HERO OR VILLAIN?
What can
this tell us
about
Cromwell?
How
useful
is it?
Can Cromwell’s head tell us
anything?
What can we learn from the story of
Cromwell’s head?
1658
- Funeral fit for a king at Westminster
Abbey.
1661
- Body dug up, executed by being hung &
beheaded. Head placed on a spike.
1685
- Blown off the spike in a storm. Found
by a soldier and stuffed up a chimney.
1702
- Sold to a waxwork show .
1789
- Bought by a group of businessmen. Put
on display in Bond Street.
1814
- Bought by a Doctor who examines it.
1960
- Given to Sidney Sussex College for
burial in a secret location!
Press the museum to
go there and listen to
their expert curator
answering question
from some local
children.
Why did some people respect
Cromwell while others did not?
•
When Cromwell took control of the country he
made many changes.
•
Some people liked the changes very much, whilst
others did not like the changes at all.
•
As a result, there are two very different
interpretations
of Cromwell –
OR
H
E
R
O
V
I
L
L
A
I
N
If you have finished, try the super-size extension!
For each of the sources look at:
Who
wrote it?
Why
do you think they wrote it?
Can we
trust
what they are saying about
Cromwell?
Based on this,
choose the source you think is
most useful
to us as historians.
•
In your groups, read the
sources about the different
things that Cromwell did.
•
Decide which side of the table
you should put them on – hero
or villain?
HERO OR VILLAIN?
Explore the complex legacy of Oliver Cromwell through various historical perspectives and sources. Discover why opinions on him varied widely during his time and even after his death, leading to debates on his portrayal as either a hero or a villain based on his actions. Dive into key events such as the English Civil War, Cromwell's rule, and his relationships with figures like King Charles I to form a deeper understanding of this controversial historical figure.
Download Presentation
Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author. Download presentation by click this link. If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.
E N D
Presentation Transcript
Cromwell: Hero or Villain? Watch this short clip and think about why some people may have disliked Cromwell, especially after he was dead!
CATEGORIES In history we need to place facts into categories and group information together in to sensible collections. You are going to be given numerous facts about Cromwell and your challenge is to place them in to the correct category.
This portrait was painted around 1650 when Cromwell was the most powerful man in England. This is what he said to the painter, Sir Peter Lely. Paint my picture exactly like me and do not flatter me at all. Show all these wrinkles, pimples, warts and everything else as you see me. Otherwise I will not pay a farthing for it. HERO OR VILLAIN?
In 1657, while he was still in power, people said these things about him: It s thanks to him that we have overcome our enemies. We look forward to peace under his leadership. Oliver , we want you to be our new King! Oliver Cromwell is a good man. He has led us through the Civil War, one of the most dangerous times in our history. HERO OR VILLAIN?
Look at the following sources and decide how to organise them. Each of the attackers [Cromwell s men] picked up a child and used it as a shield to keep themselves from being shot. After they had killed all in the Church, they went into the vaults underneath where all the women had hid themselves. Written by Thomas Wood, an eyewitness, about Cromwell s attack on Ireland. Thomas wrote this in 1663, three years after Cromwell s death. Charles II was King at the time, and he hated Cromwell. I tell you, we will cut off his head with the crown upon it! Oliver Cromwell, speaking about wanting to kill King Charles I in 1649. Charles I was the rightful King but Cromwell persuaded many people that he should be executed after the Civil War. No-one had ever killed a King before! The days of Oliver were marvellous days of prosperity, freedom and peace. Written by a Bristol Baptist in 1685. Puritanreligious leaders like this had greater freedom under Cromwell. I did not call myself to be the ruler of England.. I just tried to do right, for God and for the people. Oliver Cromwell, explaining why he refused to be King. The title was offered to him but he did not take it. A painting of Oliver Cromwell working with the Devil. Painted in 1660, just after his death. HERO OR VILLAIN?
Cromwells Home What can this tell us about Cromwell? How useful is it? HERO OR VILLAIN?
Can Cromwells head tell us anything?
What can we learn from the story of Cromwell s head? 1658 - Funeral fit for a king at Westminster Abbey. 1661 - Body dug up, executed by being hung & beheaded. Head placed on a spike. 1685 - Blown off the spike in a storm. Found by a soldier and stuffed up a chimney. 1702 - Sold to a waxwork show . 1789 - Bought by a group of businessmen. Put on display in Bond Street. 1814 - Bought by a Doctor who examines it. 1960 - Given to Sidney Sussex College for burial in a secret location!
Final Video Source from the Curator of the Huntingdon Cromwell Museum Press the museum to go there and listen to their expert curator answering question from some local children.
Why did some people respect Cromwell while others did not? When Cromwell took control of the country he made many changes. Some people liked the changes very much, whilst others did not like the changes at all. As a result, there are two very different interpretations of Cromwell OR HERO VILLAIN
HERO OR VILLAIN? In your groups, read the sources about the different things that Cromwell did. Decide which side of the table you should put them on hero or villain? Evidence to suggest Cromwell was a hero Evidence to suggest Cromwell was a villain If you have finished, try the super-size extension! For each of the sources look at: Who wrote it? Why do you think they wrote it? Can we trust what they are saying about Cromwell? Based on this, choose the source you think is most useful to us as historians.
