Analysis of Norman MacCaig's Poem "Assisi
undefined
SCOTTISH SET TEXT
N5 CRITICAL READING
NORMAN MACCAIG
•
For this section of the Nat 5 course we will be
studying six poems by the Scottish poet Norman
MacCaig.
•
Each poem deals in some way with a
personal
experience
of the poet
•
He describes the experiences and his
thoughts,
feelings and emotions
using very effective
structure
and
language.
•
He uses the poems also to convey
wider ideas and
themes.
ASSISI
•
The first poem which we will study is called “Assisi”.
Have you ever heard of this place, or anything related to
it?
Assisi is a town in Italy, famous for being the birthplace of
Saint Francis of Assisi.
Saint Francis was born in Italy in 1181, and after receiving
visions from God, abandoned a life of luxury for poverty,
and became devoted to Christianity, and a life of caring
for others- the poor, the deformed, lepers… He is also
renowned for his love of Nature and his apparent ability to
talk to the birds.
THE POEM
•
MacCaig wrote this poem about the experience of
seeing a poor deformed beggar outside the huge
ornate church in Assisi, devoted to Saint Francis.
WHAT IS THE POEM ABOUT
•
It is about the beggar and how deformed and
pitiful he is
•
It is also about the church ( the organisation rather
than the building) and how hypocritical it is-
meaning that the poor beggar should be more
important than building a huge church.
•
Saint Francis would have helped the beggar. He
would not have been interested in the huge
church- he gave up all his own money to be a
good Christian.
VERSE ONE
•
Verse one, in lines 1-4 creates a very vivid picture of the
beggar as he sits on the steps of the huge church.
The dwarf with his hands on backwards
sat, slumped like a half-filled sack
on tiny twisted legs from which
sawdust might run,
•
On your sheet, underline or highlight any similes,
metaphors and examples of effective word choice
which help to create a picture of the “dwarf”. Think
about the sound of the words too. (Alliteration and
onomatopoiea)
WHERE IS THE BEGGAR?
•
“outside the three tiers of churches built
in honour of St Francis, brother
of the poor, talker with birds, over whom
he had the advantage
of not being dead yet.”
THINK ABOUT:
•
Why is the word “outside” important?
•
What does “three tiers of churches” tell us?
•
Who was the church built in honour of?
•
Why is it important that saint Francis was “brother of the
poor”?
•
What is the only “advantage” the dwarf has ?
•
What is the poet’s
tone
in the last two lines?
VERSE TWO
•
“A priest explained
how clever it was of Giotto
to make his frescoes tell stories
that would reveal to the illiterate the goodness
of God and the suffering
of His Son
.”
What is happening here?
A priest is explaining to tourists how clever the artist
was who painted the pictures on the walls of the
church.
Why does he think the artist was clever?
VERSE TWO
The priest thinks the artist was clever because his paintings
allowed the “illiterate” (people who could not read or
write) to understand about the goodness of God, and
how much Jesus suffered. MacCaig thinks he is being
patronising ( talking down to them).
•
Norman MacCaig disapproves of the priest( and the
Church) and what he is saying.
•
“
I understood
•
the explanation and
•
the
cleverness
.- this word has connotations of persuasion
and trickery
VERSE THREE
This verse brings the two aspects of the poem
together, and really conveys the themes of the
poem:
•
The hypocrisy of the church with their stories about
God’s goodness, when the priest (who represents
the church) is just ignoring the poor beggar outside.
He is more concerned with showing off the lovely
interior of the church.
•
How the poor and disabled are excluded from
society.
THE TOURISTS
“A rush of tourists, clucking contentedly,
fluttered after him as he scattered
the grain of the Word.”
What are the tourists being compared to?
What does that tell us about the poet’s attitude
towards them?
Do you understand the reference to”the grain of the
word”?
A COMMENT ABOUT THE TOURISTS
……………………It was
they
who had passed
the
ruined temple
outside
•
Who are “they”
•
Who is the “ruined temple?”
•
Why is the poet making this comment?
•
Why is he using the metaphor “ruined temple”?
THE DWARF
“…………………………..whose eyes
wept pus, whose back was higher
than his head, whose lopsided mouth
said Grazie in a voice as sweet
as a child's when she speaks to her mother
or a bird's when it spoke
to St Francis.”
We are given a clearer and much more pitiful picture of
the dwarf here. What does the poet want us to feel?
Notice that this is all one sentence, like a list of all the
aspects of the dwarf.
THE CONTRAST
“……………………..said Grazie in a voice as sweet
as a child's when she speaks to her mother
or a bird's when it spoke
to St Francis.”
What is the poet trying to do here by telling us about
the voice?
Look at the two things he compares it to.
What does he want to tell us about the dwarf?
THE DWARF
His eyes “wept pus”
Why use the word “wept”?
What is pus?
His “
back was higher
than his head”.
Can you picture this?
He has a
“lopsided mouth”
Add these details to what we found out in verse one,
and you will have the full description.
THE MAIN IDEAS
•
That “The Church”- the organisation rather than a
specific church is cold and uncaring. It wants
people (like the tourists) to listen to their stories
about how good God was, but it ( represented by
the priest) does not emulate God’s goodness.
•
The Church is hypocritical, spending so much
money on a huge ornate church, and yet ignoring
the poor and disabled. (Represented by the
beggar.)
•
Society also ignores the poor/ disabled. They are
left “outside”
Explore the powerful themes of poverty, hypocrisy, and humanity in Norman MacCaig's poem "Assisi," which vividly portrays the contrast between a deformed beggar and the opulent church dedicated to Saint Francis. Discover the poignant reflection on social justice, religious devotion, and ethical values through MacCaig's evocative language and imagery.
Download Presentation
Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.
You are allowed to download the files provided on this website for personal or commercial use, subject to the condition that they are used lawfully. All files are the property of their respective owners.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.
E N D
Presentation Transcript
N5 CRITICAL READING SCOTTISH SET TEXT
NORMAN MACCAIG For this section of the Nat 5 course we will be studying six poems by the Scottish poet Norman MacCaig. Each poem deals in some way with a personal experience of the poet He describes the experiences and his thoughts, feelings and emotions using very effective structure and language. He uses the poems also to convey wider ideas and themes.
ASSISI The first poem which we will study is called Assisi . Have you ever heard of this place, or anything related to it? Assisi is a town in Italy, famous for being the birthplace of Saint Francis of Assisi. Saint Francis was born in Italy in 1181, and after receiving visions from God, abandoned a life of luxury for poverty, and became devoted to Christianity, and a life of caring for others- the poor, the deformed, lepers He is also renowned for his love of Nature and his apparent ability to talk to the birds.
THE POEM MacCaig wrote this poem about the experience of seeing a poor deformed beggar outside the huge ornate church in Assisi, devoted to Saint Francis.
WHAT IS THE POEM ABOUT It is about the beggar and how deformed and pitiful he is It is also about the church ( the organisation rather than the building) and how hypocritical it is- meaning that the poor beggar should be more important than building a huge church. Saint Francis would have helped the beggar. He would not have been interested in the huge church- he gave up all his own money to be a good Christian.
VERSE ONE Verse one, in lines 1-4 creates a very vivid picture of the beggar as he sits on the steps of the huge church. The dwarf with his hands on backwards sat, slumped like a half-filled sack on tiny twisted legs from which sawdust might run, On your sheet, underline or highlight any similes, metaphors and examples of effective word choice which help to create a picture of the dwarf . Think about the sound of the words too. (Alliteration and onomatopoiea)
WHERE IS THE BEGGAR? outside the three tiers of churches built in honour of St Francis, brother of the poor, talker with birds, over whom he had the advantage of not being dead yet. THINK ABOUT: Why is the word outside important? What does three tiers of churches tell us? Who was the church built in honour of? Why is it important that saint Francis was brother of the poor ? What is the only advantage the dwarf has ? What is the poet s tone in the last two lines?
VERSE TWO A priest explained how clever it was of Giotto to make his frescoes tell stories that would reveal to the illiterate the goodness of God and the suffering of His Son. What is happening here? A priest is explaining to tourists how clever the artist was who painted the pictures on the walls of the church. Why does he think the artist was clever?
VERSE TWO The priest thinks the artist was clever because his paintings allowed the illiterate (people who could not read or write) to understand about the goodness of God, and how much Jesus suffered. MacCaig thinks he is being patronising ( talking down to them). Norman MacCaig disapproves of the priest( and the Church) and what he is saying. I understood the explanation and the cleverness.- this word has connotations of persuasion and trickery
VERSE THREE This verse brings the two aspects of the poem together, and really conveys the themes of the poem: The hypocrisy of the church with their stories about God s goodness, when the priest (who represents the church) is just ignoring the poor beggar outside. He is more concerned with showing off the lovely interior of the church. How the poor and disabled are excluded from society.
THE TOURISTS A rush of tourists, clucking contentedly, fluttered after him as he scattered the grain of the Word. What are the tourists being compared to? What does that tell us about the poet s attitude towards them? Do you understand the reference to the grain of the word ?
A COMMENT ABOUT THE TOURISTS It was they who had passed the ruined temple outside Who are they Who is the ruined temple? Why is the poet making this comment? Why is he using the metaphor ruined temple ?
THE DWARF ..whose eyes wept pus, whose back was higher than his head, whose lopsided mouth said Grazie in a voice as sweet as a child's when she speaks to her mother or a bird's when it spoke to St Francis. We are given a clearer and much more pitiful picture of the dwarf here. What does the poet want us to feel? Notice that this is all one sentence, like a list of all the aspects of the dwarf.
THE CONTRAST ..said Grazie in a voice as sweet as a child's when she speaks to her mother or a bird's when it spoke to St Francis. What is the poet trying to do here by telling us about the voice? Look at the two things he compares it to. What does he want to tell us about the dwarf?
THE DWARF His eyes wept pus Why use the word wept ? What is pus? His back was higher than his head . Can you picture this? He has a lopsided mouth Add these details to what we found out in verse one, and you will have the full description.
THE MAIN IDEAS That The Church - the organisation rather than a specific church is cold and uncaring. It wants people (like the tourists) to listen to their stories about how good God was, but it ( represented by the priest) does not emulate God s goodness. The Church is hypocritical, spending so much money on a huge ornate church, and yet ignoring the poor and disabled. (Represented by the beggar.) Society also ignores the poor/ disabled. They are left outside
