NPRM 19-138 5.9 GHz Comment Review
This document provides a summary of a quick review conducted by the authors regarding FCC filings related to Docket 19-138 on the use of the 5.850-5.925 GHz band. The review focused on determining which filings may necessitate further review and the potential need for reply comments. Specific areas of concern were identified, such as reallocation of frequencies and comments on DSRC. The document also highlights the breakdown of supportive, neutral, and opposing positions within the reviewed filings.
Download Presentation
Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.
You are allowed to download the files provided on this website for personal or commercial use, subject to the condition that they are used lawfully. All files are the property of their respective owners.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.
E N D
Presentation Transcript
13 Mar 2020 doc.: IEEE 802.18-20/0038r02 NPRM 19-138 5.9 GHz Comment Review Date: 12 March 2020 Authors: Name Jay Holcomb, Chair Joseph LEVY Affiliations Address Itron, Inc. Phone +1(509)891-3281 jholcomb@ieee.org email Liberty Lake (Spokane) WA jslevy@ieee.org InterDigital, Inc. Toyota +1.631.622.4139 jkenney@us.toyota-itc.com John Kenney Agenda Slide 1 Joseph Levy (InterDigital)
13 Mar 2020 doc.: IEEE 802.18-20/0038r02 Abstract This document summarizes a quick review done by the authors of the filings received by the FCC in regard to Docket 19-138, Use of the 5.850-5.925 GHz Band Total Filings: 390 The focus of this review was to determine which of these filings may require additional review and possibly the generation of reply comments. The areas that we agreed were of concern at the 11 March 802.18 ad hoc meeting are: 1. If the document is supportive of reallocation of 45 MHz from ITS to U-NII (Pro/Con) 2. If the document comments on DSRC either positively or negatively 3. If the document comments on OOBE Note: there were many documents filed by amateur radio operators which uniformly protested the changes which would impact their access to the band. This review did not address these comments. r1- Corrected some typos and cut and past errors. r2 Updated to include additional filing reviews Agenda Slide 2 Joseph Levy (InterDigital)
13 Mar 2020 doc.: IEEE 802.18-20/0038r02 Review Summary Of the 393 total filings the authors have reviewed 182 filings Of these: Supportive of reallocation of 45 MHz from ITS to U-NII Pro: 21 (11.8%) Con: 151 (84.8%) Neutral: 6 (3.4%) Commented on DSRC Pro: 43 (23.6 %) Con: 21 (11.5%) ITS tech Neutral 118 (64.8%) Discussed technical issues regarding OOBE Yes: 23 (13.2%) No: 151 (86.8%) Note the reviewers only provided feed back on filings where in their opinion it made sense to, hence the different number of total positions. Agenda Slide 3 Joseph Levy (InterDigital)
13 Mar 2020 doc.: IEEE 802.18-20/0038r02 DSRC Con Filings BMW Group General Motors LLC Open Technology Institute at New America Open Technology Institute and Public Knowledge Qualcomm Incorporated T-Mobile USA, Inc. 5G Americas FCA US LLC HARMAN International Inc. 5G Automotive Association Ford Motor Company Intel Corp. Applied Information Inc.,Temple, Inc.,Traffic Products LLC NPRM Traffic Products Ai support.pdf BMW Submission ET Docket No. 19-138 (003).pdf 3-09-20 GM FINAL.pdf OTI_Issue Brief_5.9 GHz Comments_CoverLetter_030920.pdf 5.9 GHz NPRM_Comments_OTI+PK_FINAL_030920.pdf Qualcomm Comments on 5.9 GHz NPRM.pdf T-Mobile 5.9 GHz Comments (As-Filed) 3.9.20.pdf 5G Americas 5.9 GHz Comments 3.9.20 FINAL.pdf Final FCA Comments to FCC NPRM.pdf HARMAN Comments_ET Docket No. 19-138_Mar 9 2020.pdf 5GAA Comments (3-9-2020).pdf Ford Submission to FCC Mar 9 2020.pdf Intel Corporation - FCC NPRM COMMENT_5_9GHz.pdf Jaguar Land Rover response for Comment Submission (ET 19- 138) in Support of C-V2X.pdf 5.9 GHz comments Garretson-IPI.pdf Scribner and Hedger - CEI comments to FCC in 19-138 proceeding.pdf Final R Street 5.9 GHz Comments.pdf FSF Comments 5.9 GHz.Final.030620.pdf Ex Parte_AGoldberger_6GHzC- band5.9GHz_FINAL_120919.pdf 5.9 GHz Ex Parte Notice 12.05.19.pdf Hackett Letter to The Honorable Ajit Pai 11-21-19.pdf Jaguar Land Rover Limited Institute for Policy Innovation,Dan Garretson Competitive Enterprise Institute R Street Institute The Free State Foundation Open Technology Institute at New America 5G Automotive Association Ford Motor Company Agenda Slide 4 Joseph Levy (InterDigital)
13 Mar 2020 doc.: IEEE 802.18-20/0038r02 DSRC Pro Filings RR Filing on FCC NPRM 19-138 09 Mar 2020.docx DSRC Auto Safety Coalition 5.9 GHz Band Comment.pdf USTAG TC204 Comments on FCC NPRM 19-138 2020-03-09.pdf KYTC Comment - FCC NPRM - 19-138 - 5.9 GHz Band.pdf UPS Comments docket 19-138.pdf GWTCA Comments On DSRC - ET Docket No. 19-138.pdf FCC Proposed Rule- Docket No. 19-138- NYC Comment.pdf Oregon DOT Comments_FCC 5.9 GHz Band NPRM.docx.pdf SES and Intelsat Comments on 5 GHz UNII NPRM 9 March 2020.pdf APPENDIX B 191219_Performance Analysis of LTE-V2X v7.pptx u-Blox_Comments_on_FCC-19-138-NPRM-5.9GHz.pdf FCC_NPRM_2019_5.9 GHz_CAR2CAR_Communication_Consortium.pdf NACTO DSRC Comment Letter.pdf NXP TC 1028.pdf TDOT_FCC Docket No. 19-138_ Comments.pdf CDOT_Response_5.8-5.9GHz_Band.pdf Dortch, Marlene - GHz Band Rulemaking - 03092020.pdf Dr. Richard Roy DSRC Auto Safety Coalition US Technical Advisory Group to ISO/TC 204 Intelligent Transport Systems Kentucky Transportation Cabinet United Parcel Service, Inc. Government Wireless Technology & Communications Association The City of New York Oregon Department of Transportation SES Americom, Inc.,Intelsat License LLC Toyota Motor Corporation u-blox America CAr 2 CAR Communication Consortium National Association of City Transportation Officials NXP Semiconductors Tennessee Department of Transportation Colorado Department of Transportation Pennsylvania Department of Transportation (PennDOT) Aly Geller,Stephen Bingham,Alvin Lester,Julie Mitchell,John Alex Lowell,Fenell Doyle,Jen Holt,Nancy Harrison,Jenny Yu,Amanda Lamb City of Fremont Kristin R. White RS&H, Inc Mr. Gregory Slater, Secretary, Maryland Department of Transportation Washington State Department of Transportation American Public Works Association (APWA) American Public Transportation Association Institute of Transportation Engineers Michael H. Stevens Vision Zero Network Tampa Hillsborough County Expressway Authority (THEA) Maricopa County Department of Transportation Jason Levine - Center for Auto Safety Julie Evans William T. Panos, Director - North Dakota Department of Transportation Hawaii Bicycling League IEEE 802 LAN/MAN Standards Committee Matthew E. Moore, M.A. Wyoming Department of Transportation Montana Department of Transportation Director Mike Tooley Neil Gray,Patrick Jones AREDN Transbase.US, PBC Association of Global Automakers, Inc. FCC letter on behalf of FSS.pdf City of Fremont Comments Regarding FCC Proposed 5.9 Reallocation.pdf Minnesota DOT regarding FCC ET Docket No. 19-138.pdf 20200304_FCC-NPRM_CommentsRSH.pdf FCC Letter Signed Comment Letter.pdf 03-06 Use of 5.850-5.925 GHz Band [ET 19-138, FCC 19-129].pdf 2020 APWA March FCC Comments on 5.9 GHz v2.pdf APTA Comments on FCC Spectrum Proposal (03.04.20) (FNL).pdf ITE Comments to FCC on 5.9 GHz NPRM March 2020 - 030420 final.pdf Columbus_5.9GHz_Comments.pdf VisionZeroNetwork_Docket No. 19-138_Letter.pdf M H Dortch-Secretary FCC 03052020 THEA Waggoner.pdf Maricopa County DOT (ET Docket 19-138 FCC Docket 19-129) - Marlene Dortch - 3-5-20.pdf Center for Auto Safety Response to FCC comment request on Docket No. 19-138.pdf 20200304_FCC-NPRM_Comments-je.pdf FCC 5.850-5.925 GHZ Band.pdf ET Docket No. 19-138Hawaii Bicycling League.pdf 18-20-0020-19-0000-comments-on-fcc19-138-nprm-revisiting-use-of-the-5-850-5-925-ghz-band.pdf Idaho Comments on FCC proposal to reduce spectrum for transportation safety.docx Wyoming Comments FCC Docket ET Docket No. 19-138.docx GhZLetter.pdf 2020 IBTTA comments to FCC re 5.9 GHz band.docx AREDN Comments.pdf Comments ET Docket No.19-138.pdf Global Automakers Ex Parte Dkts 19-138 13-49 18-357.pdf Agenda Slide 5 Joseph Levy (InterDigital)
13 Mar 2020 doc.: IEEE 802.18-20/0038r02 Discussed technical issues regarding OOBE Panasonic Corporation of North America Panasonic V2X NPRM Comments.pdf American Honda Motor Co., Inc. FCC 5.9 GHz NPRM Honda Comments (85 FR 6841) 20200309.pdf General Motors LLC 3-09-20 GM FINAL.pdf Alliance for Automotive Innovation Final 5.9 GHz Comments.pdf NCTA - The Internet & Television Association NCTA 5.9 NPRM Comments.pdf US Technical Advisory Group to ISO/TC 204 Intelligent Transport Systems USTAG TC204 Comments on FCC NPRM 19-138 2020-03-09.pdf FINAL OMNIAIR CONSORTIUM COMMENTS - FCC Doc No 19-138 (03.09.20).pdf NAFA Fleet Management Association NAFA Comments FCC ET Docket No. 19-138 - Use of the 5.850-5.925 GHz Band.pdf Qualcomm Incorporated Qualcomm Comments on 5.9 GHz NPRM.pdf Broadcom, Inc.,Facebook, Inc. FINAL392020CommentsinResponseto5.9GHzNPRM392020 (1).pdf Wi-Fi Alliance 5.9 GHz Comments FINAL 3.9.20.docx Wireless Internet Service Providers Association Pai Ex Parte Letter_(CBRS 6 GHz_and 5.9 GHz).pdf Dynamic Spectrum Alliance DSA Comments to FCC on the use of the 5.850-5.925 GHz Band.pdf Denso International America, Inc. DENSO_FCC_Comments_March_9_2020.pdf Toyota Motor Corporation APPENDIX B 191219_Performance Analysis of LTE-V2X v7.pptx Microsoft Corporation Microsoft Comments on the use of the 5.850 - 5.925 GHz Band.pdf 5G Automotive Association 5GAA Comments (3-9-2020).pdf Comcast Corporation Comcast 5.9 GHz Comments 03.09.2020.pdf OmniAir Consortium, Inc. IEEE 1609 Working Group Ford Motor Company CAr 2 CAR Communication Consortium Robert L. Sumwalt, III 5G Automotive Association IEEE 1609 Filing on FCC NPRM 19-138 09 Mar 2020.pdf Ford Submission to FCC Mar 9 2020.pdf FCC_NPRM_2019_5.9 GHz_CAR2CAR_Communication_Consortium.pdf 64852_out.pdf 5.9 GHz Ex Parte Notice 12.05.19.pdf Agenda Slide 6 Joseph Levy (InterDigital)
