Messianic Interpretations in the Old Testament

IMMANUEL
PROPHECIES
ISAIAH 7-12
Dr. Ed Hindson
Rawlings School of Divinity
Liberty University
Lynchburg, VA
Old Testament is Not Messianic
Old Testament is Not Messianic
“It is impossible to establish
“It is impossible to establish
that any passage in its original
that any passage in its original
literary and historical context
literary and historical context
must or even should be
must or even should be
understood as portending a
understood as portending a
future messianic figure.”
future messianic figure.”
Tremper Longman III, “The Messiah: Explorations in the Law and
Writings,” in 
The Messiah in the Old and New Testaments
, ed. S. E.
Porter (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2007), p. 13
Old Testament is Not Messianic
Old Testament is Not Messianic
“The early church applied such texts
“The early church applied such texts
to Jesus because of their conviction
to Jesus because of their conviction
about his identity. The conviction
about his identity. The conviction
about his identity did not derive
about his identity did not derive
from the Old Testament. They
from the Old Testament. They
found Jesus and then saw how the
found Jesus and then saw how the
Scriptures fit with him.”
Scriptures fit with him.”
Kyle Snodgrass, “The Use of the Old Testament in the New,” in The
Right Doctrine from the Wrong Texts? ed. G.K. Beale (Grand Rapids:
Baker Book House, 1994), p. 39.
Old Testament is Not Messianic
Old Testament is Not Messianic
“How can we identify a passage as
“How can we identify a passage as
messianic if the Old Testament offers
messianic if the Old Testament offers
no such support for such an interpre-
no such support for such an interpre-
tation either conceptually or textually,
tation either conceptually or textually,
and the New testament suggests no
and the New testament suggests no
fulfillment connections?”
fulfillment connections?”
J.H. Walton, 
Genesis
, NIVAC (Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishing
Co., 2001), p. 233. The quote questions the classic messianic interpre-
tation of Genesis 3:15.
THE EVANGELICAL DEPARTURE FROM
OT MESSIANIC INTERPRETATION
“There is a growing movement by evangelicals
away from interpreting the Hebrew Bible (our OT)
as a messianic book … Although evangelical
scholarship still recognizes that there is something
messianic about the Hebrew Bible, for the most
part it sees it as a story that finds its climax in
Jesus, not as predictions that Jesus of Nazareth
fulfilled. As such, it is becoming quite common to
state that biblical authors did not have an
intentional messianic meaning.”
 
Michael Rydelnik, 
The Messianic Hope: Is the
 
Hebrew Bible Really Messianic? 
NAC Studies in Bible &
 
Theology 9 (Nashville: B&H Academic, 2010), pp. 3-4.
THEMATIC CONTEXT:
ISAIAH 7-12
7:14    Sign: Immanuel (“God is with us”)
8:8      Land of Immanuel
9:6-7   Divine Child = King
10:21  Remnant Returns to Mighty God
11:1-9 Branch of Jesse will rule in Peace
 
   & Righteousness
12:1-6 Yahweh…is with us
HISTORICAL ISSUES
 
THE COURSE OF THE
ASSYRIAN CONQUEST
Imminent
destruction of
Aram and Israel 
 
(Isa 8:1-4)
Assyrian progress
through Israel and
Judah (Isa 8:5-7)
IMMEDIATE THREAT
7:1-2
Rezin of Damascus (Syria)
Pekah of Samaria (Israel)
Alliance vs. Ahaz (Judah)
Threat: Remove and Replace
Ahaz with son of Tabeel = Cut
off 
Davidic Line
IMMEDIATE CONTEXT
7:3
Isaiah takes his
young son 
Shear-
Jashab
 (“remant
shall return”) to
meet Ahaz at the
upper pool. cf.
36:2
PROPHETIC PROMISE
7:4-9
“Be careful, be quiet, do
not
 fear…It shall 
not
stand…
not
 come to pass”
REFUSAL OF THE SIGN
Ask a Sign (
אוֹת
 
oth
)… deep as
Sheol or as high as Heaven-
implies miraculous sign.
Ahaz
Ch. 7
Threat-Syria and Ephraim
Promise: Not Succeed
Prediction: Kings
Removed
Location: Upper Pool
Sign: Rejected
Hezekiah
Ch. 36-37
Threat- Assyria
Promise: Not Enter City
Prediction: King
Removed
Location: Upper Pool
Sign: Accepted
IMMANUEL PROPHECY
“Behold, 
the virgin 
shall
conceive and bear a son,
and shall call his name
Immanuel” 
     
      
ESV
INTERPRETIVE VIEWS
1.
Messianic
: Virgin Birth of
Christ
2.
Non-Messianic
: Birth of a
child in Isaiah’s Day
3.
Dual Fulfillment
: Both:
Immediate and Ultimate
NON-MESSIANIC VIEW
1.
Refers to any woman
and 
any child
2.
Refers to birth of
Hezekiah
3.
Refers to birth of 
Isaiah’s
Son
CALVIN’S RESPONSE
“As to those who
think it was
Isaiah’s son, it is
an utterly frivolous
conjection; for we
do not read that
a deliverer would
be raised up from
the seed of
Isaiah.” p. 107
DUAL FULFILLMENT VIEW
Albert Barnes 
(1840).
Child of the prophet
about to be born:
Maher-shalal-hashbaz
.
Suggest Isaiah’s first
wife died and about
to remarry. Admits
prophecy not
completely fulfilled.
(p. 165)
THE MOTHER
1. Wife of King Ahaz
2. Wife of Isaiah
3. New Wife of Isaiah
4. Virgin in King’s Harem
5. 
Virgin Mary
THE VIRGIN 
עַלְמָה
 (ALMAH)
Unique Hebrew word for
“virgin” (8 times in OT).
Never used of married woman
A young woman (maiden) of
marriageable age who is a
virgin.
JEWISH STUDY BIBLE
“All modern scholars,
however, agree that the
Heb. merely denotes a
young woman of
marriageable
age…whether a virgin
or not.” p. 799
VIRGIN
בְּתוּלָה
 (BETHULAH)
More common but less
precise.
Motyer: Only 21 of 50
definitively mean virgin (p.
84). “Without a descriptive
clause added 
bethulah
does not convey a precise
meaning.”
Twice used of “young
widow” (Deut. 22:19; Joel
1:8).
SHALL CONCEIVE
(
הָרָה
 HARAH)
A feminine adjective
with an active
participle (“bearing”).
Denotes present
tense: “Behold the
pregnant virgin
bearing a son”
Edward J. Young
IMMANUEL
(
עִמָּנוּ אֵל
 “GOD WITH US”)
1.
Hezekiah
2.
Maher-shalal-hashbaz
3.
No one in particular
4.
Jesus
 (Matthew 1:23)
MATTHEW’S QUOTATION
Matthew1:23
Greek: 
παρθένος
Parthenos
Always means “virgin”
LXX
 translates 
almah
 as
parthenos
MICAH 5:2-3
Isaiah’s contemporary predicts
place
 of Messiah’s birth.
“She who is in labor” (present
tense) shall give birth to “ruler in
Israel” whose origin is “from
antiquity” (
miggedem
) “from
eternity
” (olam)
IMMEDIATE RELEVANCE
Removal of the threat
Child
 in v. 16
1.
Ideal child
2.
Hezekiah
3.
Maher-shalal-hashbaz
4.
Shear Jashub
CHAPTER 8
GOD IS WITH US
1.
Birth of Maher-shalal-hashbaz “spoil
speeds, prey hastens”
2.
Damascus and Samaria will fall
3.
Assyria will come vs. Israel (722 BC)
4.
Assyria will threaten Judah “your
land 
O Immanuel
” (8:8)
5.
But “God is with us” (Immanuel).
CHAPTER 9
Great Light in 
Galilee
 vs. 1-2 cf.
Matthew 4:13-16; Luke 1:79
Promised King
: “For unto us a
child is born, to us a son is given
and the government shall be
upon his shoulder…on the throne
of David…forevermore (meatah
olam)
DIVINE CHILD 9:6
Wonderful Counselor
 
פֶּלֶא יוֹעֵץ
pele yoets
Mighty God
 
אֵל גִּבּוֹר
el gibbor
Everlasting Father
 
אֲבִי-עַד
abi ad
Prince of Peace
 
שַׂר-שָׁלוֹם
sar shalom
CHAPTER 10
Assyria will be judged with a
“wasting sickness” (cf. ch. 36-
37)
Remnant of Israel will return
(Shear Jashub) to the “
mighty
God
” (el gibbor) 
(Vs. 21)
RIGHTEOUS BRANCH
CHAPTER 11
Prediction
: Tree of 
Davidic Line
will be cut down and a 
shoot
(
choter
) will spring from stump
(
geza’) 
of Jesse and a 
branch
(
netser
) from his roots.
Messiah
 is both the root and
branch of the Davidic Line.
ANOINTED MESSIAH
Coming King is anointed by
the 
Spirit
 of the Lord (
Ruach
Yahweh
) and endowed with
His gifts. “Counsel” and
“Might” are used in 9:6 to
describe the coming King.
CHAPTER 12
Closing Crescendo
1.
“Give thanks” v. 4
2.
“Sing praises” v. 5
3.
“Shout for joy” v. 6
Holy One of Israel is 
“with us”
Slide Note
Embed
Share

The discussion revolves around the rejection of defining the Old Testament as solely messianic and how the early Church ascribed such texts to Jesus based on their conviction rather than explicit Old Testament support. The evolving evangelical perspective towards the Hebrew Bible's messianic nature is explored, emphasizing the climax in Jesus over direct predictions fulfilled by Him. Themes in Isaiah 7-12, such as Immanuel, a divine child-king, and the rule in peace and righteousness by the Branch of Jesse, highlight the intricate tapestry of Old Testament prophecy and its relationship to Jesus.

  • Messianic Interpretations
  • Old Testament
  • Jesus
  • Immanuel
  • Evangelical Perspective

Uploaded on Oct 07, 2024 | 0 Views


Download Presentation

Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author. Download presentation by click this link. If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. IMMANUEL PROPHECIES ISAIAH 7-12 Dr. Ed Hindson Rawlings School of Divinity Liberty University Lynchburg, VA

  2. Old Testament is Not Messianic It is impossible to establish that any passage in its original literary and historical context must or even should be understood as portending a future messianic figure. Tremper Longman III, The Messiah: Explorations in the Law and Writings, in The Messiah in the Old and New Testaments, ed. S. E. Porter (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2007), p. 13

  3. Old Testament is Not Messianic The early church applied such texts to Jesus because of their conviction about his identity. The conviction about his identity did not derive from the Old Testament. They found Jesus and then saw how the Scriptures fit with him. Kyle Snodgrass, The Use of the Old Testament in the New, in The Right Doctrine from the Wrong Texts? ed. G.K. Beale (Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1994), p. 39.

  4. Old Testament is Not Messianic How can we identify a passage as messianic if the Old Testament offers no such support for such an interpre- tation either conceptually or textually, and the New testament suggests no fulfillment connections? J.H. Walton, Genesis, NIVAC (Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishing Co., 2001), p. 233. The quote questions the classic messianic interpre- tation of Genesis 3:15.

  5. THE EVANGELICAL DEPARTURE FROM OT MESSIANIC INTERPRETATION There is a growing movement by evangelicals away from interpreting the Hebrew Bible (our OT) as a messianic book Although evangelical scholarship still recognizes that there is something messianic about the Hebrew Bible, for the most part it sees it as a story that finds its climax in Jesus, not as predictions that Jesus of Nazareth fulfilled. As such, it is becoming quite common to state that biblical authors did not have an intentional messianic meaning. Michael Rydelnik, The Messianic Hope: Is the Hebrew Bible Really Messianic? NAC Studies in Bible & Theology 9 (Nashville: B&H Academic, 2010), pp. 3-4.

  6. THEMATIC CONTEXT: ISAIAH 7-12 7:14 Sign: Immanuel ( God is with us ) 8:8 Land of Immanuel 9:6-7 Divine Child = King 10:21 Remnant Returns to Mighty God 11:1-9 Branch of Jesse will rule in Peace & Righteousness 12:1-6 Yahweh is with us

  7. HISTORICAL ISSUES

  8. THE COURSE OF THE ASSYRIAN CONQUEST Imminent destruction of Aram and Israel (Isa 8:1-4) Assyrian progress through Israel and Judah (Isa 8:5-7)

  9. IMMEDIATE THREAT 7:1-2 Rezin of Damascus (Syria) Pekah of Samaria (Israel) Alliance vs. Ahaz (Judah) Threat: Remove and Replace Ahaz with son of Tabeel = Cut off Davidic Line

  10. IMMEDIATE CONTEXT 7:3 Isaiah takes his young son Shear- Jashab ( remant shall return ) to meet Ahaz at the upper pool. cf. 36:2

  11. PROPHETIC PROMISE 7:4-9 Be careful, be quiet, do not fear It shall not stand not come to pass

  12. REFUSAL OF THE SIGN Ask a Sign ( oth) deep as Sheol or as high as Heaven- implies miraculous sign.

  13. Ahaz Ch. 7 Hezekiah Ch. 36-37 Threat-Syria and Ephraim Threat- Assyria Promise: Not Succeed Promise: Not Enter City Prediction: Kings Removed Prediction: King Removed Location: Upper Pool Location: Upper Pool Sign: Rejected Sign: Accepted

  14. IMMANUEL PROPHECY Behold, the virgin shall conceive and bear a son, and shall call his name Immanuel ESV

  15. INTERPRETIVE VIEWS 1.Messianic: Virgin Birth of Christ 2.Non-Messianic: Birth of a child in Isaiah s Day 3.Dual Fulfillment: Both: Immediate and Ultimate

  16. NON-MESSIANIC VIEW 1.Refers to any woman and any child 2.Refers to birth of Hezekiah 3.Refers to birth of Isaiah s Son

  17. CALVINS RESPONSE As to those who think it was Isaiah s son, it is an utterly frivolous conjection; for we do not read that a deliverer would be raised up from the seed of Isaiah. p. 107

  18. DUAL FULFILLMENT VIEW Albert Barnes (1840). Child of the prophet about to be born: Maher-shalal-hashbaz. Suggest Isaiah s first wife died and about to remarry. Admits prophecy not completely fulfilled. (p. 165)

  19. THE MOTHER 1. Wife of King Ahaz 2. Wife of Isaiah 3. New Wife of Isaiah 4. Virgin in King s Harem 5. Virgin Mary

  20. THE VIRGIN (ALMAH) Unique Hebrew word for virgin (8 times in OT). Never used of married woman A young woman (maiden) of marriageable age who is a virgin.

  21. JEWISH STUDY BIBLE All modern scholars, however, agree that the Heb. merely denotes a young woman of marriageable age whether a virgin or not. p. 799

  22. VIRGIN (BETHULAH) More common but less precise. Motyer: Only 21 of 50 definitively mean virgin (p. 84). Without a descriptive clause added bethulah does not convey a precise meaning. Twice used of young widow (Deut. 22:19; Joel 1:8).

  23. SHALL CONCEIVE ( HARAH) A feminine adjective with an active participle ( bearing ). Denotes present tense: Behold the pregnant virgin bearing a son Edward J. Young

  24. IMMANUEL GOD WITH US ) 1.Hezekiah 2.Maher-shalal-hashbaz 3.No one in particular 4.Jesus (Matthew 1:23) (

  25. MATTHEWS QUOTATION Matthew1:23 Greek: Parthenos Always means virgin LXX translates almah as parthenos

  26. MICAH 5:2-3 Isaiah s contemporary predicts place of Messiah s birth. She who is in labor (present tense) shall give birth to ruler in Israel whose origin is from antiquity (miggedem) from eternity (olam)

  27. IMMEDIATE RELEVANCE Removal of the threat Child in v. 16 1.Ideal child 2.Hezekiah 3.Maher-shalal-hashbaz 4.Shear Jashub

  28. CHAPTER 8 GOD IS WITH US 1. Birth of Maher-shalal-hashbaz spoil speeds, prey hastens 2. Damascus and Samaria will fall 3. Assyria will come vs. Israel (722 BC) 4. Assyria will threaten Judah your land O Immanuel (8:8) 5. But God is with us (Immanuel).

  29. CHAPTER 9 Great Light in Galilee vs. 1-2 cf. Matthew 4:13-16; Luke 1:79 Promised King: For unto us a child is born, to us a son is given and the government shall be upon his shoulder on the throne of David forevermore (meatah olam)

  30. DIVINE CHILD 9:6 Wonderful Counselor pele yoets Mighty God el gibbor Everlasting Father - abi ad Prince of Peace - sar shalom

  31. CHAPTER 10 Assyria will be judged with a wasting sickness (cf. ch. 36- 37) Remnant of Israel will return (Shear Jashub) to the mighty God (el gibbor) (Vs. 21)

  32. RIGHTEOUS BRANCH CHAPTER 11 Prediction: Tree of Davidic Line will be cut down and a shoot (choter) will spring from stump (geza ) of Jesse and a branch (netser) from his roots. Messiah is both the root and branch of the Davidic Line.

  33. ANOINTED MESSIAH Coming King is anointed by the Spirit of the Lord (Ruach Yahweh) and endowed with His gifts. Counsel and Might are used in 9:6 to describe the coming King.

  34. CHAPTER 12 Closing Crescendo 1. Give thanks v. 4 2. Sing praises v. 5 3. Shout for joy v. 6 Holy One of Israel is with us

Related


More Related Content

giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#