Fieldwork Brief on Fair Work Principles

 
Researcher
Dept. Information Systems
University of Cape Town
 
Paul Mungai, PhD
 
t
: @paulmungaiw
e: paul.mungai@uct.ac.za
 
w
: Fair.Work
 
t
:  
@towardsfairwork
 
Brief on Data Collection Process
 
F
i
e
l
d
w
o
r
k
 
B
r
i
e
f
 
B
a
s
e
d
 
o
n
 
F
a
i
r
.
W
o
r
k
 
P
r
i
n
c
i
p
l
e
s
 
Pay (min wage)
Bottles, NoSweat, PicUp, Uber,  Bolt (Taxify), SweepSouth
We were making more money in meter taxi where 1km was charged R10, but only R5/km for uber
platform
” – Uber worker
They keep decreasing our rate. They don’t pay us per kilometer. It’s a fixed rate. I often end up
spending more on petrol with no profit
.
” Bottles
I haven’t found a job on NoSweat. The competition is very very high
.
” NoSweat
Asylum seekers (refugees) are not marginalized in most platforms
It’s a problem for us foreigners. We are facing a kind of discrimination in other jobs. Bottles should
always be there, it helps us a lot. Many companies do not employ people with refugee status. They
say the job is for South Africans only
” – Bottles worker
Conditions (H&S)
Nosweat (Embedded in client/employer SLA), Uber (insurance + SOS button),
Bolt-Taxify (insurance + SOS button), SweepSouth
For insurance, they say they want SA ID book to get health and disability cover.
” – SweepSouth
“Taxify does not do something right, it must be fixed, you know my name, but other people does not
register using their real name, they put their false name like Spiderman”
 – Taxify
 
 
 
 
Fieldwork Brief Based on Fair.Work Principles
 
Contracts
T&Cs access - Bottles, Nosweat, PicUp, SweepSouth
None genuinely reflects the nature of the relationship
Management (clear, dependable, responsive)
Due process of decision making: Bottles, NoSweat, PicUp, Uber,  Bolt (Taxify), SweepSouth
Consent for data collection: Bottles, NoSweat, PicUp
Most use in-app support (chats)
Yes, but it is always difficult to get help via the in-app chat. It is easier to go to their office,
which takes more time. 
” - SweepSouth worker
No clear support mechanism regarding performance and ratings
Uber should verify client complaints before penalising or asking you to make changes in
the car i.e there are cases when riders request for things not allowed in uber, like smoking
in the car. When you deny them, they rate you badly. In such cases, they uber should tell
you what caused the low rating
” – Uber worker
Representative (collective representation)
Provides collective worker voice mechanism: Bottles, NoSweat,  SweepSouth?
Recognizes collective body for bargaining: Bottles would if one existed.
 
 
 
 
 
 
w
: Fair.Work
 
t
:  
@towardsfairwork
 
Paul Mungai, PhD
 
t
: @paulmungaiw
e:
 paul.mungai@uct.ac.za
Slide Note
Embed
Share

This document explores the challenges faced by workers in various platforms like Bottles, NoSweat, Uber, Bolt (Taxify), and SweepSouth, focusing on issues such as pay rates, worker conditions, contracts, consent for data collection, and collective representation. Workers highlight concerns like decreasing pay rates, discrimination against foreigners, lack of clear support mechanisms, and the need for better management practices in line with fair work principles.

  • Fair Work Principles
  • Worker Challenges
  • Platform Labor
  • Data Collection
  • Collective Representation

Uploaded on Feb 24, 2025 | 0 Views


Download Presentation

Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

You are allowed to download the files provided on this website for personal or commercial use, subject to the condition that they are used lawfully. All files are the property of their respective owners.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Paul Mungai, PhD Researcher Dept. Information Systems University of Cape Town t: @paulmungaiw e: paul.mungai@uct.ac.za w: Fair.Work t: @towardsfairwork

  2. Brief on Data Collection Process

  3. Fieldwork Brief Based on Fieldwork Brief Based on Fair.Work Fair.Work Principles Principles Pay (min wage) Bottles, NoSweat, PicUp, Uber, Bolt (Taxify), SweepSouth We were making more money in meter taxi where 1km was charged R10, but only R5/km for uber platform Uber worker They keep decreasing our rate. They don t pay us per kilometer. It s a fixed rate. I often end up spending more on petrol with no profit. Bottles I haven t found a job on NoSweat. The competition is very very high. NoSweat Asylum seekers (refugees) are not marginalized in most platforms It s a problem for us foreigners. We are facing a kind of discrimination in other jobs. Bottles should always be there, it helps us a lot. Many companies do not employ people with refugee status. They say the job is for South Africans only Bottles worker Conditions (H&S) Nosweat (Embedded in client/employer SLA), Uber (insurance + SOS button), Bolt-Taxify (insurance + SOS button), SweepSouth For insurance, they say they want SA ID book to get health and disability cover. SweepSouth Taxify does not do something right, it must be fixed, you know my name, but other people does not register using their real name, they put their false name like Spiderman Taxify

  4. Fieldwork Brief Based on Fair.Work Principles Contracts T&Cs access - Bottles, Nosweat, PicUp, SweepSouth None genuinely reflects the nature of the relationship Management (clear, dependable, responsive) Due process of decision making: Bottles, NoSweat, PicUp, Uber, Bolt (Taxify), SweepSouth Consent for data collection: Bottles, NoSweat, PicUp Most use in-app support (chats) Yes, but it is always difficult to get help via the in-app chat. It is easier to go to their office, which takes more time. - SweepSouth worker No clear support mechanism regarding performance and ratings Uber should verify client complaints before penalising or asking you to make changes in the car i.e there are cases when riders request for things not allowed in uber, like smoking in the car. When you deny them, they rate you badly. In such cases, they uber should tell you what caused the low rating Uber worker Representative (collective representation) Provides collective worker voice mechanism: Bottles, NoSweat, SweepSouth? Recognizes collective body for bargaining: Bottles would if one existed.

  5. w: Fair.Work t: @towardsfairwork Paul Mungai, PhD t: @paulmungaiw e: paul.mungai@uct.ac.za

More Related Content

giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#