Accounting and Taxation of Securities Organized by Belgaum Branch of ICAI

 
Accounting and
Taxation of securities
 
By CA Kinjal Shah
(B.Com., FCA, DISA(ICAI), M.Com., CAMS)
 
 
-Organized by Belgaum branch of
SIRC of ICAI
February 23, 2024
 
CONTENT
 
What are Securities?
Types of securities
Accounting treatment
Taxation of securities
Case studies
Other important points
 
2
 
What  are Securities?
 
 
Section 2(h) of Securities Contracts
(Regulation) Act, 1956:
 
“Securities” include—
Shares, scrip’s, stocks, bonds, debentures, or a pooled
investment vehicle
Derivative;
units or instrument issued by collective investment scheme;
Mutual fund units;
Pool investment vehicle units or instrument;
 
4
 
Section 2(h) of Securities Contracts
(Regulation) Act, 1956:
 
any certificate or instrument which possesses any debt or
receivable
Government securities;
rights or interest in securities;
Such other instruments as may be declared by the Central
Government to be Securities
 
“Securities" shall not include
any scrip or instrument with insurance in-built in the
product.
 
5
 
Types of Securities
 
 
7
 
Securities covered
 
Equity shares
Mutual funds
Exchange traded funds (ETFs)
Debt securities
Gold securities
Real estate investments (REITs)
Infrastructure investment trusts (INVITs)
Derivatives
 
8
 
Equity Shares
 
Ownership units in a company
Represent a claim on company assets and profits
Traded on stock exchanges
Prices fluctuate based on supply, demand, and company
performance
 
9
 
Mutual Funds
 
Pooled collection of assets that invests in stocks, bonds, and other
securities
Mutual Funds invest in various asset classes such as Equities, Debt,
or a combination of different asset classes.
Can be classified as
 
- Equity Mutual Funds
 
- Debt Mutual Funds
 
- Hybrid Mutual Funds.
Taxation rules of Mutual Funds differ based on the underlying
investments
 
10
 
Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs)
 
Similar to Mutual Funds as they have pooled investments but can be
traded on stock exchanges like Equity shares.
Currently the types of ETFs traded in India – Index ETFs, Sectoral
ETFs and Gold/Silver ETFs.
Index ETFs track the movement of indices such as the SENSEX or the
NIFTY. Sectoral ETFs invests solely in stocks from a specific sector
or industry such as Technology funds.
 
11
 
Debt securities
 
Represent a loan between an issuer (borrower) and an investor
(lender)
Investors received periodical interest on debt securities
Debt securities can be listed or unlisted
Examples of listed Debt securities are debentures, Government
Securities, corporate bonds, tax-free bonds, etc
Examples of unlisted debt securities are Non-convertible
debentures, debt securities raised through private placements
 
12
 
Gold Securities
 
Currently, there are multiple ways to invest in gold, even
though traditionally, the physical form has been most popular.
Gold is also purchased as financial products such as digital gold,
Gold ETFs, Gold Mutual Funds, and Sovereign Gold Bonds.
 
13
 
Real Estate Investments
 
Real Estate investments refers to real property that consists of land
and improvements, which include buildings, fixtures, roads,
structures, and utility systems.
In recent years, another type of Real Estate investment has gained
significant popularity in India.
These are Real Estate Investment Trusts or REITs. At present, there
are two key types of REITs available in India – Listed REITs and
Unlisted REITs.
REITs are companies that own, operate, and manage income-
generating real estate assets.
REITs pay investors in various forms such as interest, dividend,
loan repayment.
 
14
 
Infrastructure Investment Trusts (Invits)
 
A type of investment vehicle that allows investors to invest in
infrastructure assets such as roads, bridges, power plants, and
renewable energy projects.
Listed on stock exchanges, and investors can buy and sell units in
them just like they would buy and sell shares of stock.
Invits pay investors in various forms such as interest, dividend, loan
repayment.
 
15
 
Derivatives
 
Derivatives are financial instruments* whose value depend upon or
is derived from some underlying assets.
The underlying assets can be real assets such as commodities, gold
etc. or financial assets such as index, interest rate etc.
A derivative does not have its own physical existence. It emerges
out of the contract between the buyer and seller of the derivative
instrument
 
*Financial Instruments means any contract that gives rise to a financial
asset of one entity and a financial liability or equity instrument of
another entity.
 
16
 
Types of Derivatives
 
Forwards
Futures
Options
Swaps
 
17
 
Forwards
 
Holder is charged to perform the contract.
Forwards are not traded on stock exchanges. They are available
over-the-counter (OTC) and are not market-to-market.
Example: A farmer plans to grow 5000 Kgs of wheat this year. He
can sell his wheat for whatever the price is when he harvests it, or
he could lock in a price now by selling a forward contract that
obligates him to sell 5000 kgs of wheat to a company after the
harvest for a fixed or specified price. By locking in the price now,
he can actually eliminate the risk of falling wheat prices.
 
18
 
Futures
 
Standardized agreement: Buy or sell an asset (commodity, stock, etc.)
at a predetermined price on a specific future date.
Binding obligation: Both parties must fulfill the contract, ensuring
commitment.
Exchange-traded: Contracts are bought and sold on regulated stock
exchanges.
Equity Futures are cash settled or delivery setled but index futures are
always cash settled
Example: Purchasing a June futures contract for XYZ stock at Rs. 1,000
per share means buying/selling at that price on the designated date in
June.
 
19
 
Futures - Illustration
 
Example –
 
Initial margin:
On 12/04/2023: Mr. Bull to pay Initial Margin of Rs.3, 50, 000/-., i.e. 10% (1000 x 3500)
Mark to Market
:
On 12/04/2023 – Mr. Bull to receive Rs.50, 000/-, i.e. 1000 (3550 – 3500).
On 13/04/2023 – Mr. Bull to pay Rs.80, 000/-, i.e. 1000 (3550 – 3470).
On Squaring up of the Contract:
Mr. Bull will receive Rs.1,30,000/- i.e. 1000(3600-3470).
Actual gain in the transaction – Rs. 1,00,000- i.e. 1000(3600-3500)
 
 
20
 
Options
 
Contracts that give the buyer a right to buy and/ or sell the
underlying asset at the specified price during a particular period of
time.
The buyer of the contract has a right but not an obligation to perform
as per the terms of the contract. For acquiring this right the buyer
has to pay ‘Option Premium’ to the seller/writer.
The seller has the obligation to buy or sell the specified underlying
asset at an agreed price if the buyer chooses to exercise the option.
For this he charges the ‘Option Premium’ from the buyer/holder.
 
21
 
Options
 
Strike/Exercise Price: The price at which the buyer has a right to buy
or sell an underlying asset and the seller has an obligation to sell or
buy.
There are two types of options: Call Option and Put Option
A call option is a right to buy an underlying asset or contract at a
fixed price at a future date but at a price that is decided today.
A put option is the right to sell an underlying asset or contract at a
fixed price at a future date but at a price that is decided today.
 
22
 
Options
 
The rights and obligations of the parties involved in an option
contract can be summarized in a tabular form, as under:
 
23
 
Options - Illustration
 
Example- Purchase of Put option by Mr. Bear
 
24
 
Options - Illustration
 
As Mr. Bearer is the buyer of the put option, he has the right but not an
obligation to sell the underlying asset
Scenario I - Purchase of Put option by Mr. Bear and square up before contract expiry
On 12/04/2023 
: Put Premium  Payable by Mr. Bear - Rs.20,000/- i.e. 1000 * Rs.20/-.
Sale on 25/04/2023 (Before expiry):
Assumed Mr. Bear will square up his Put Option on 25/04/2023 i.e., before expiry
Net gain to Mr. Bear – Premium received Less Premium paid for the purchase of Put
Option
i.e Rs.5,000/- {Rs. 25,000 (-) Rs.20,000/-}.
 
 
 
25
 
Options - Illustration
 
Scenario II - Purchase of Put option by Mr. Bear and square up on contract expiry
On 12/04/2023 
: Put Premium  Payable by Mr. Bear - Rs.20,000/- i.e. 1000 *
Rs.20/-.
On 27/04/2023:
I – TCS Price is Rs.2,100/-  - Assumed  that Mr. Bear will not exercise the Put
Option.
Mr. Bear will incur a maximum loss of Rs.20,000/- i.e. the amount of premium paid.
II – TCS Price is Rs.1,900/- -  Mr. Bear will exercise his Put Option and will receive
Rs.1,50,000/- { 1000(2050-1900)}
On settlement:
Net gain to Mr. Bear - Profit on settlement of Put Option Less Premium paid for the
purchase of Put Option i.e Rs.1,30,000/- {Rs.1,50,000 (-) Rs.20,000/-}.
 
 
 
26
 
Options - Illustration
 
In the above example suppose Mr. Bull is the seller of the above-referred Put Option at the
same premium for the same strike price and for the same series.
 
F
rom the following tabulation the net position of profit/loss for both Mr. Bear (Buyer of Put
Option) and Mr. Bull (Seller of Put Option) at different levels of price of TCS on the
settlement date viz.27th April 2023 can be assessed.
 
27
 
Swaps
 
Two parties exchange their financial obligations under this contract.
Cash flows are based on a principal amount agreed by both the
parties without exchanging the principal. The amount is based on a
rate of interest.
While one cash flow remains fixed, the other changes based on the
benchmark rate of interest.
Swaps are OTC contracts between businesses and/ or financial
institutions and are not traded on stock exchanges.
 
Accounting treatment
 
 
29
 
Accounting treatment as per AS 13
 
AS 13  deals with accounting for assets held as Investments.
Classification of Investments
1.
Current Investments
Intended to be held for less than a year from the date
when such investment is done
Carried in the books at lower of cost or market price.
If there is any reduction in the carrying amount than the
cost the same should be debited to profit and loss
account as diminution in the value of investments.
 
30
 
Accounting treatment as per AS 13
 
2. Long-Term Investments
Investments other than the current investments
Carried in the books at cost.
If there is any permanent decline in the value of investments
the same will have to be recognized.  However a lenient view
can be taken for investments held of a strategic nature
 
31
 
Accounting treatment as per AS 13
 
Disposal
On disposal of current/long term investments:
the difference
between the carrying amount and the proceeds on disposal
net of expenses, if any
should be recognized in the profit and loss account.
 
32
 
Accounting treatment as per AS 13
 
Reclassification of investments
From long term to current:
Transfer to be made at lower of cost and carrying value on the date of such
transfer.
 
From current to long term:
Transfer to be made at lower of cost and fair value on the date of such
transfer.
 
33
 
Accounting treatment as per AS 13
 
Disclosures in the Financial Statements
:
The below mentioned are the disclosures in the financial statements with
respect to AS 13 Accounting for Investments is applicable:
(a) accounting policies employed for determining carrying amount of
investment
(b) the amounts which are included in the profit and loss statement for:
 
(i) Dividends, interest, and rentals on the investments presenting the
income from such long-term and current investments separately. Gross
income must be stated, amount of TDS (tax deducted at source) included
under the Advance Taxes Paid.
(ii) Profits and losses on the disposal of current investment and the
changes in carrying the amount of the investment
 
 
34
 
Accounting of Derivatives – Guidance
note by ICAI
 
All derivative contracts should be recognised on the balance sheet and
measured at fair value.
If any entity decides not to use hedge accounting, it should account for its
derivatives at fair value with changes in fair value being recognised in the
statement of profit and loss
Fair value represents the ‘exit price’ i.e. the price that would be paid to
transfer a liability or the price that would be received when transferring an
asset to a knowledgeable, willing counterparty.
 
35
 
Accounting of Derivatives
 
Example - Mr. Bull buys 1000 units 
NIFTY
 Future April 2023 expiry, at a
price of Rs. 3500/- on 28th March 2023. Initial margin is 10%
Daily Settlement price of this unit were as under:
 
36
 
Accounting of Derivatives
 
37
 
Accounting of Derivatives
 
On 31/03/23 – Open interest
Future contract asset will appear under “Current asset
 
Accounting of Derivatives
 
Sample contract note:
 
Accounting of Derivatives
 
Explanation of contract note:
B/F and C/F in the remarks column indicate that these are previous day’s
positions and that the 
position has not been squared off.
Net total (before levies) Rs. 48,500 and Rs. 21,440 is the mark to market.
Payin/ payout obligation (Net total) - Rs. 27,060 is the net mark to market for
the specific date.
 
40
 
Accounting of Derivatives (IND AS 109)
 
As per IND AS 109:
Classification: Derivatives to be classified as Financial liability or financial
asset.
Measurement: All derivatives are measured at fair value with changes in
fair value being recognized in profit and loss for the period, except
derivatives that qualify as hedging instruments.
Fair value of a financial instrument is a combination of its intrinsic value
and time value. In a fair and perfect market, it would be inappropriate to
conclude that immediately at the inception of a contract, it results in
creation of rights and obligations for two independent parties i.e. the
contract has no intrinsic value at inception
 
Taxation of securities
 
 
42
 
Equity shares
 
 
Listed Domestic Equity
Shares
STCG for shares held < 12
months.
        Tax rate: 15%.
Long-Term Capital Gains
(LTCG) for shares held ≥
12 months.
       Tax rate: 10%
       Exemption: Rs. 1,00,000
 
Unlisted Domestic Equity
Shares
STCG for shares held <
24 months.
        Tax rate: As per slab
 
rate 
 
of the investor
LTCG tax rate: 20% with
indexation.
 
Foreign Equity Shares
STCG for shares held <
24 months.
        Tax rate: As per slab 
 
rate
 
of the investor
LTCG tax rate: 20% with
indexation.
 
43
 
Mutual Funds
 
 
A) 
Equity Mutual Funds
:
They invest 65% or more of their
investable assets in Equity-oriented
assets such as domestic Equity shares
STCG for shares held < 12 months.
          Tax rate: 15%.
Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) for
shares held ≥ 12 months.
       Tax rate: 10%
       Exemption: Rs. 1,00,000
 
 
(B) Debt Mutual funds:
Debt Mutual Funds invest in Debt
instruments such as bonds, T-bills,
Certificates of Deposits, NCD. G-Sec,
overnight call and money market etc.
 
Bought till 31/03/2023
STCG for investments held < 36
months.
Tax rate: As per Slab rate of the investor
LTCG if held
 
 
36 months
Tax rate: 20% with indexation.
 
Bought after 31/03/2023
Taxed as STCG irrespective of holding
period
 
44
 
Mutual Funds
 
 
(C) 
Hybrid Funds
 
Equity Allocation < 35%: Taxed like Debt Mutual Funds.
Equity Allocation ≥ 65%: Taxed like Equity Mutual Funds.
Equity allocation between 35%-65%: Taxed at 20% with
indexation
 
 
45
 
ETFs
 
 
(A) 
Equity ETFs 
- Majorly
invest in equities or related
investment instruments.
STCG for ETFs held < 12
months.
       Tax rate: 15%.
Long-Term Capital Gains
(LTCG) for ETFs held ≥ 12
months.
       Tax rate: 10%
       Exemption: Rs. 1,00,000
 
(B) Gold and Debt ETFs
Bought till 31/03/2023
STCG for investments held <
36 months.
Tax rate: As per Slab rate of the
investor
LTCG if held
 
 
36 months
Tax rate: 20% with indexation.
 
Bought after 31/03/2023
Taxed as STCG irrespective of
holding period
 
46
 
Debt securities
 
 
 
(A) Listed Debt Instruments
STCG for investments held
<12 months.
Tax rate: As per slab rate of the
investor
 
LTCG tax rate: 10% without
Indexation.
 
 
(B) 
Unlisted Debt
Instruments
STCG for investments held <
36 months.
      Tax rate: As per Slab rate of
the investor
LTCG tax rate: 20% without
indexation
.
 
47
 
Gold securities
 
 
(A) Gold ETFs, Gold Mutual Funds
Bought till 31/03/2023
STCG for investments held < 36
months.
Tax rate: As per Slab rate of the
investor
LTCG if held
 
 
36 months
Tax rate: 20% with indexation.
 
Bought after 31/03/2023
Taxed as STCG irrespective of
holding period
 
(B) Sovereign Gold Bonds
Tax-free at maturity only for
individuals.
If exited before maturity.
STCG if held < 36 months.
       Tax rate: Slab rate.
Long-Term Capital Gains
(LTCG) if held ≥ 36 months.
       Tax rate: 10% without
indexation or 20% with
indexation
       Exemption: Rs. 1,00,000
Interest taxed as Income from other
sources at slab rate
 
48
 
REITs and Invits
 
 
Interest and rental income 
: Taxed at applicable slab rate.
Dividend income : 
If u/sec 115BAA of Income Tax Act, 1961, the REIT’s/Invit’s
Special Purpose Vehicle has:
1.
Not opted for the lower tax regime – Dividend is exempt
2.
Opted for the lower tax regime - Taxable at the applicable tax slab rate
for unit holder
At the time of sale of reits/invits
-STCG for REITs/Invits held < 36 months.
      Tax rate: 15%.
-Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) for REITs/Invits held ≥ 36 months.
      Tax rate: 10%
      Exemption: Rs. 1,00,000
 
49
 
REITs and Invits
 
 
‘Loan repayment’ i.e., return of capital must be reduced from the cost of
acquisition at the time of sale of unit by the investor for computation of capital
gain.
Loan repayment in excess of issue price will be taxed as “Income from other
sources” at applicable slab rate
 
50
 
Derivatives
 
 
The income from Derivatives instruments should be taxed as
Business income according to assessee’s income tax slab
It is irrespective of the frequency or volume of derivatives
transactions.
The business income is normally divided into speculative and non-
speculative income.
 
51
 
Derivatives
 
 
Calculation of turnover for Derivatives transactions:
(i) The total of favourable and unfavourable differences shall be taken as
turnover.
(ii) Premium received on sale of options is also to be included in turnover. (To
be done when position is squared off on expiry)
However, where the premium received is included for determining net profit
for transactions, the same should not be separately included. (To be done when
position is squared off on expiry)
(iii) In respect of any reverse trades entered, the difference thereon, should also
form part of the turnover.
 
52
 
Speculative transactions in securities
 
 
Speculative transactions
Meaning: Transaction in which a contract for the purchase or sale of any
commodity, including stocks and shares, is periodically or ultimately
settled otherwise than by the actual delivery or transfer of the commodity
or scrips
Example: Intraday trading.
 
53
 
Taxation of Speculative transactions in
securities
 
 
Income from speculative transactions:
Taxed as Business income according to assessee’s income tax slab
The contract is settled by paying out the difference which may be
positive or negative.
The aggregate of both positive and negative differences is to be
considered as the turnover of such transactions.
 
54
 
Case studies
 
 
Case study 1:
Mr. A sold 150 shares of Glenmark pharmaceuticals, details of which are
as follows:
Selling price per share: Rs. 479.3 each
Purchase cost per share: Rs. 200 each
Sale date: 03-04-2023
Purchase date: 05-04-2019
The amount invested at the time of purchase was borrowed as loan.
 
55
 
Case studies
 
 
 
Contract note
 
56
 
Case studies
 
 
 
Expenses incurred:
Brokerage – Rs. 360
Exchange Charges – Rs. 2.7
SEBI Turnover fees –Rs.0.04
Securities transaction charges – Rs. 72
GST -  Rs. 65.29
Interest expenses for loan (purchase cost) –Rs. 5,000
 
Which of the above charges are deductible under the Income Tax, 1961 in the following
scenarios?
(1)
Income from sale is treated as business income
(2)
Income from sale is treated as long term capital gain
 
57
 
Case studies
 
 
 
Response to case study 1:
Business income –
Section 37(1) states that any expenditure expended wholly or exclusively for the
purposes of the business or profession shall be allowed in computing “Business income”
Section 36 (1) (XV) states that STT paid by the assessee should be allowed to be
deducted in computing business income
Capital gain–
As per section 48 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, capital gain shall be computed by
deducting expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively in connection with such transfer
and cost of acquisition from full value of consideration.
 
 
58
 
Case studies
 
 
 
Response to case study 1:
 
59
 
Case studies
 
 
 
Case study 2
Mr. A deals in futures and options trading. During FY 23-24, he entered into the following
contracts:
Futures:
 
How will turnover for liability for audit under section 44AB be calculated?
 
60
 
Case studies
 
 
 
Case study 2
Options:
 
How will turnover for liability for audit under section 44AB be calculated?
 
61
 
Case studies
 
 
 
Response to Case study 2
 
Total turnover = Rs. 3,23,000
1.
Favorable and unfavorable differences to be considered as turnover
2.
Premium received on sale of options
 
ICICI (Square up on expiry)- Premium received has been added to the gain as the gain
is  difference between (strike price and settlement price)*Qty
 HUL (Square up before expiry) – Premium received has not been added to the gain as
the gain is difference between (Premium received-Premium paid)*Qty
 
62
 
Case studies
 
 
 
Case study 3
Mr. A has a portfolio with XYZ Portfolio Managers. In FY 22-23, the following transactions
took place in the said portfolio:
 
During the year, Mr. A paid Rs. 70,000 to XYZ Portfolio Managers as Portfolio Management fees.
 
63
 
Case studies
 
 
 
Case study 3
Computation of Capital gains by Mr. A
 
Would Portfolio Management fees be a deductible expense as per Income Tax Act, 1961?
 
64
 
Case studies
 
 
 
Response to case study 3
As per section 48 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, capital gain shall be computed by
deducting expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively in connection with such transfer
and cost of acquisition from full value of consideration.
As per Devendra Motilal Kothari vs. DCIT 132 ITD 173:
It was held by the Tribunal that the portfolio management fees was not deductible in
computing capital gain. The said fees was not inextricably linked with the particular
instance of purchase and sale of shares and securities and the assessee would have been
required to pay the fees regardless of any purchase or sale of securities.
 
65
 
Case studies
 
 
 
Response to case study 3
As per 
KRA Holding & Trading (P) Ltd. vs. DCIT 46 SOT 19
The Tribunal held that the
The expression ‘in connection with such transfer’ enjoyed much wider meaning and, therefore,
the fee paid to the portfolio manager had to have been expended for the purposes of acquisition
and transfer of the investment of the securities.
The expression ‘transfer’ involved various sub-components and the first subcomponent must
be of purchase and possession of the securities.
Unless the assessee was in possession of the asset, he could not transfer the same.
Thus the expenditure was allowable u/sec 48.
The above view taken by the Pune tribunal has been followed by the Pune and other Benches of the
Tribunal in several other cases.
Conclusion
: The deduction of Portfolio management fees for computation of capital gain
is a controversial matter.
 
66
 
Case studies
 
 
Case study 4
Company XYZ Ltd was dealing in agricultural products. In FY 22-23, it stopped doing said
business and started trading in shares and futures & options. The income of the company
is exclusively from trading activity.
 
What are the implications of this for an auditor?
 
67
 
Case studies
 
 
Response to case study 4
Since the principal business of the company is trading activity financial activity,
the criteria for NBFC gets fulfilled.
Financial activity as principal business is when a
 
1. Company’s financial assets constitute more than 50 per cent of the total
 
assets and
 
2. Income from financial assets constitute more than 50 per cent of the
 
gross  income.
Para 78 of Guidance note on CARO, 2020 requires the auditor to examine whether
the company is engaged in the business which attract the requirements of
registration as NBFC under RBI.
 
68
 
Case studies
 
 
Case study 5
During FY 23-24, the assessee has transacted in options and has incurred a loss. The
turnover computed under section 44AB of the Income Tax Act, 1961 is less than Rs. 2
crores and he is not liable for tax audit.
 
Is the assessee required to offer a minimum of 6% or 8% profit (as the case maybe) as
stipulated under section 44AD? If not, what are the implications?
 
69
 
Other important points
 
 
Dividend should be reported as “Income from other sources” even for companies
who account for dividend in their Profit and Loss statement.
While computing Capital gain/loss, assesee should not consider sale rate specified
in Annual information Statement (AIS) provided by the Income Tax Department.
The rate specified in AIS is closing market rate for the specific date instead of the
rate at which the security was sold.
As per section 10(34A) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, income arising to an assessee
on account of buy back of shares by a domestic company is exempt. This is to avoid
double taxation as the domestic company is required to pay income tax @20% on
such distributed income.
 
70
 
Other important points
 
 
Assessees should disclose/offer for tax the premium earned on sale of options (where
position is squared up on expiry).
Price adjustment of shares after demerger should be done by the investor in their
books in order to compute correct capital gain/loss. For example – Demerger of
Reliance to Jio Financial services. For every share held in Reliance, the investor would
receive one share of Jio Financial. The purchase cost of the shares would be
proportionate to the percentage of cost of acquisition of equity shares: Reliance –
95.32% and Jio Financial – 4.68%. Thus if an investor held 20 shares of reliance
bought at Rs. 500 each, on demerger, the purchase cost per share in the investor’s
books would be as follows:
 
Reliance – Rs. 476.6 per share (Rs. 500*95.32%)
 
Jio Financial – Rs. 23.4 per share (Rs. 500*4.68%)
 
71
 
Other important points
 
Bonus stripping
 Selling original shares soon after the bonus issue generally at a discounted
price due to market adjustment for bonus issuance.
 This is done in order to claim capital loss on sale of original shares, which
can be offset against other capital gains thus reducing tax liability.
 As per section 97(8) of the Income Tax Act, 1961
 Where a person buys securities or units within a period of 3 months
before the record date of bonus issue and sells the securities or units
within a period of 9 months from the record date while continuing to hold
the original securities or units, the capital loss arising out of such
transactions shall not be considered for the computation of income tax.
Assessee should periodically conduct stock reconciliation in order to account for
bonus, split, etc.
 
72
 
Other important points
 
 
As per section 73 of Income Tax Act, 1961, a company involved in the purchase and
sale of shares of other companies shall be considered to be carrying on speculation
business to the extent to which the business consists of purchase/sale of shares.
Loss on such speculation business can be set off against profits of speculative
business only.
      Explanation-  Where any part of the business of a company (other than a company
whose gross total income consists mainly of income which is chargeable under the
heads "Interest on securities", "Income from house property", "Capital gains" and
"Income from other sources", or a company the principal business of which is the
business of trading in shares or banking or the granting of loans and advances)
consists in the purchase and sale of shares of other companies, such company shall,
for the purposes of this section, be deemed to be carrying on a speculation business
to the extent to which the business consists of the purchase and sale of such shares.
 
73
 
Decision making
 
 
People
 use
IT 
to work with
Information
 
74
 
References
 
 
AS 13 - Accounting for Investments
IND AS 109 – Financial Instruments
Guidance Note on Accounting for Derivatives contracts issued by the
ICAI
Guidance Note on Tax Audit under Section 44AB of the Income-tax
Act, 1961 issued by the ICAI
Accounting Standards for Non-Company entities issued by the ICAI
Guidance note on CARO, 2020 issued by the ICAI
Slide Note
Embed
Share

Explore the accounting treatment and taxation of securities in a seminar organized by the Belgaum branch of ICAI. Learn about various types of securities, their accounting principles, taxation rules, and important points through case studies and insightful discussions led by CA Kinjal Shah. Gain valuable insights into securities regulations and understand the nuances of different investment vehicles in the market.

  • Accounting
  • Taxation
  • Securities
  • Seminar
  • ICAI

Uploaded on Mar 23, 2024 | 4 Views


Download Presentation

Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author. Download presentation by click this link. If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Accounting and Taxation of securities -Organized by Belgaum branch of SIRC of ICAI February 23, 2024 By CA Kinjal Shah (B.Com., FCA, DISA(ICAI), M.Com., CAMS)

  2. CONTENT What are Securities? Types of securities Accounting treatment Taxation of securities Case studies Other important points 2

  3. What are Securities?

  4. Section (Regulation) Act, 1956: Securities include Shares, scrip s, stocks, bonds, debentures, or a pooled investment vehicle Derivative; units or instrument issued by collective investment scheme; Mutual fund units; Pool investment vehicle units or instrument; 2(h) of Securities Contracts 4

  5. Section (Regulation) Act, 1956: any certificate or instrument which possesses any debt or receivable Government securities; rights or interest in securities; Such other instruments as may be declared by the Central Government to be Securities 2(h) of Securities Contracts Securities" shall not include any scrip or instrument with insurance in-built in the product. 5

  6. Types of Securities

  7. Securities covered Equity shares Mutualfunds Exchange traded funds (ETFs) Debt securities Gold securities Real estate investments (REITs) Infrastructure investment trusts (INVITs) Derivatives 7

  8. Equity Shares Ownership units in a company Represent a claim on company assets and profits Traded on stock exchanges Prices fluctuate based on supply, demand, and company performance 8

  9. Mutual Funds Pooled collection of assets that invests in stocks, bonds, and other securities Mutual Funds invest in various asset classes such as Equities, Debt, or a combination of different asset classes. Can be classifiedas - Equity MutualFunds - Debt MutualFunds - Hybrid Mutual Funds. Taxation rules of Mutual Funds differ based on the underlying investments 9

  10. Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) Similar to Mutual Funds as they have pooled investments but can be traded on stock exchanges like Equity shares. Currently the types of ETFs traded in India Index ETFs, Sectoral ETFs and Gold/Silver ETFs. Index ETFs track the movement of indices such as the SENSEX or the NIFTY. Sectoral ETFs invests solely in stocks from a specific sector or industry such as Technology funds. 10

  11. Debt securities Represent a loan between an issuer (borrower) and an investor (lender) Investors received periodical interest on debt securities Debt securities can be listed or unlisted Examples of listed Debt securities are debentures, Government Securities, corporatebonds, tax-freebonds, etc Examples of unlisted debt securities are Non-convertible debentures, debt securities raised through private placements 11

  12. Gold Securities Currently, there are multiple ways to invest in gold, even though traditionally, the physical form has been most popular. Gold is also purchased as financial products such as digital gold, Gold ETFs, Gold Mutual Funds, and Sovereign Gold Bonds. 12

  13. Real Estate Investments Real Estate investments refers to real property that consists of land and improvements, which include buildings, fixtures, roads, structures, and utility systems. In recent years, another type of Real Estate investment has gained significant popularityin India. These are Real Estate Investment Trusts or REITs. At present, there are two key types of REITs available in India Listed REITs and Unlisted REITs. REITs are companies that own, operate, and manage income- generating real estate assets. REITs pay investors in various forms such as interest, dividend, loan repayment. 13

  14. Infrastructure Investment Trusts (Invits) A type of investment vehicle that allows investors to invest in infrastructure assets such as roads, bridges, power plants, and renewable energy projects. Listed on stock exchanges, and investors can buy and sell units in them just like they would buy and sell shares of stock. Invits pay investors in various forms such as interest, dividend, loan repayment. 14

  15. Derivatives Derivatives are financial instruments* whose value depend upon or is derived from some underlying assets. The underlying assets can be real assets such as commodities, gold etc. or financialassets such as index, interest rate etc. A derivative does not have its own physical existence. It emerges out of the contract between the buyer and seller of the derivative instrument *Financial Instruments means any contract that gives rise to a financial asset of one entity and a financial liability or equity instrument of another entity. 15

  16. Types of Derivatives Forwards Futures Options Swaps 16

  17. Forwards Holder is charged to perform the contract. Forwards are not traded on stock exchanges. They are available over-the-counter (OTC) and are not market-to-market. Example: A farmer plans to grow 5000 Kgs of wheat this year. He can sell his wheat for whatever the price is when he harvests it, or he could lock in a price now by selling a forward contract that obligates him to sell 5000 kgs of wheat to a company after the harvest for a fixed or specified price. By locking in the price now, he can actually eliminate the risk of falling wheat prices. 17

  18. Futures Standardized agreement: Buy or sell an asset (commodity, stock, etc.) at a predeterminedprice on a specific future date. Binding obligation: Both parties must fulfill the contract, ensuring commitment. Exchange-traded: Contracts are bought and sold on regulated stock exchanges. Equity Futures are cash settled or delivery setled but index futures are always cash settled Example: Purchasing a June futures contract for XYZ stock at Rs. 1,000 per share means buying/selling at that price on the designated date in 18 June.

  19. Futures - Illustration Example Date of Transaction Contract Specification Contract Price 12/04/2023 NIFTYFUTApr23 Rs. 3,500/- 200 5 (1000 Units of NIFTY) 10% Rs.3,550/- Rs.3,470/- Rs.3,600/- Market Lot (No. of Units) No. of Contracts Bought Initial Margin Price as on close of 12/04/2023 Price as on close of 13/04/2023 Position Squared off on 14/04/2023 Initial margin: On 12/04/2023: Mr. Bull to pay Initial Margin of Rs.3, 50, 000/-., i.e. 10% (1000 x 3500) Mark to Market: On 12/04/2023 Mr. Bull to receive Rs.50, 000/-, i.e. 1000 (3550 3500). On 13/04/2023 Mr. Bull to pay Rs.80, 000/-, i.e. 1000 (3550 3470). On Squaring up of the Contract: Mr. Bull will receive Rs.1,30,000/-i.e. 1000(3600-3470). Actual gain in the transaction Rs. 1,00,000-i.e. 1000(3600-3500) 19

  20. Options Contracts that give the buyer a right to buy and/ or sell the underlying asset at the specified price during a particular period of time. The buyer of the contract has a right but not an obligation to perform as per the terms of the contract. For acquiring this right the buyer has to pay Option Premium to the seller/writer. The seller has the obligation to buy or sell the specified underlying asset at an agreed price if the buyer chooses to exercise the option. For this he charges the OptionPremium from the buyer/holder. 20

  21. Options Strike/Exercise Price: The price at which the buyer has a right to buy or sell an underlying asset and the seller has an obligation to sell or buy. There are two types of options: Call Option and Put Option A call option is a right to buy an underlying asset or contract at a fixed price at a futuredate but at a price that is decided today. A put option is the right to sell an underlying asset or contract at a fixed price at a futuredate but at a price that is decided today. 21

  22. Options The rights and obligations of the parties involved in an option contract can be summarized in a tabular form, as under: Option Call Buyer/Holder Right but not an obligation to buy the underlying asset Seller/Writer Obligation but no right to sell the underlying asset. Put Right but not an obligation to sell the underlying asset Obligation but no right to buy the underlying asset 22

  23. Options - Illustration Example- Purchase of Put option by Mr. Bear Date of transaction Contract specification Strike price Market lot (No. of units) No. of put options bought Premium on 12/04/2023 Price as on last day of settlement (Expiry date: 27/04/2023) 12/04/2023 TCSApr23 Rs. 2,050/- 200 5 (1,000 shares of TCS) Rs. 20/- per unit I Rs. 2,100/- II Rs. 1,900 Price as on 25/04/2023 (i.e., before expiry) Rs. 2,000 Selling price (Premium receivable) as on 25/04/2023 Rs. 25/- per unit 23

  24. Options - Illustration As Mr. Bearer is the buyer of the put option, he has the right but not an obligationto sell the underlying asset Scenario I - Purchase of Put option by Mr. Bear and squareup before contract expiry On 12/04/2023: Put Premium Payableby Mr. Bear - Rs.20,000/-i.e. 1000* Rs.20/-. Sale on 25/04/2023(Before expiry): Assumed Mr. Bear will squareup his Put Option on 25/04/2023 i.e., before expiry Net gain to Mr. Bear Premium received Less Premium paid for the purchase of Put Option i.e Rs.5,000/-{Rs. 25,000(-) Rs.20,000/-}. 24

  25. Options - Illustration Scenario II - Purchase of Put option by Mr. Bear and squareup on contract expiry On 12/04/2023 : Put Premium Payable by Mr. Bear - Rs.20,000/- i.e. 1000 * Rs.20/-. On 27/04/2023: I TCS Price is Rs.2,100/- - Assumed that Mr. Bear will not exercise the Put Option. Mr. Bear will incur a maximum loss of Rs.20,000/-i.e. the amount of premium paid. II TCS Price is Rs.1,900/-- Mr. Bear will exercise his Put Option and will receive Rs.1,50,000/-{ 1000(2050-1900)} On settlement: Net gain to Mr. Bear - Profit on settlement of Put Option Less Premium paid for the purchase of Put Option i.e Rs.1,30,000/- {Rs.1,50,000(-) Rs.20,000/-}. 25

  26. Options - Illustration In the above example suppose Mr. Bull is the seller of the above-referred Put Option at the same premium for the same strike price and for the same series. From the following tabulation the net position of profit/loss for both Mr. Bear (Buyer of Put Option) and Mr. Bull (Seller of Put Option) at different levels of price of TCS on the settlement date viz.27th April 2023 can be assessed. Price of TCS as on 27th April 2023 (Maturity) Mr. Bear (Buyer of 1000 Put Options) Profit/(Loss) (20000) Mr. Bull (Seller of 1000 Put Options) Profit/(Loss) 20000 2150 2100 (20000) 20000 2050 (20000) 20000 2000 30000 (30000) 1950 80000 (80000) 1900 130000 (130000) 26

  27. Swaps Two parties exchange their financialobligations under this contract. Cash flows are based on a principal amount agreed by both the parties without exchanging the principal. The amount is based on a rate of interest. While one cash flow remains fixed, the other changes based on the benchmark rate of interest. Swaps are OTC contracts between businesses and/ or financial institutions and are not traded on stock exchanges. 27

  28. Accounting treatment

  29. Accounting treatment as per AS 13 AS 13 deals with accounting for assets held as Investments. Classification of Investments 1.Current Investments Intended to be held for less than a year from the date when such investment is done Carried in the books at lower of cost or market price. If there is any reduction in the carrying amount than the cost the same should be debited to profit and loss account as diminutionin the value of investments. 29

  30. Accounting treatment as per AS 13 2. Long-Term Investments Investments other than the current investments Carried in the books at cost. If there is any permanent decline in the value of investments the same will have to be recognized. However a lenient view can be taken for investments held of a strategic nature 30

  31. Accounting treatment as per AS 13 Disposal On disposal of current/long term investments: the difference between the carrying amount and the proceeds on disposal net of expenses, if any should be recognized in the profit and loss account. 31

  32. Accounting treatment as per AS 13 Reclassification of investments From long term to current: Transfer to be made at lower of cost and carrying value on the date of such transfer. From current to long term: Transfer to be made at lower of cost and fair value on the date of such transfer. 32

  33. Accounting treatment as per AS 13 Disclosures in the FinancialStatements: The below mentioned are the disclosures in the financial statements with respect to AS 13 Accounting for Investments is applicable: (a) accounting policies employed for determining carrying amount of investment (b) the amounts which are included in the profit and loss statement for: (i) Dividends, interest, and rentals on the investments presenting the income from such long-term and current investments separately. Gross income must be stated, amount of TDS (tax deducted at source) included under the Advance Taxes Paid. (ii) Profits and losses on the disposal of current investment and the changes in carrying the amount of the investment 33

  34. Accounting of Derivatives Guidance note by ICAI All derivative contracts should be recognised on the balance sheet and measured at fair value. If any entity decides not to use hedge accounting, it should account for its derivatives at fair value with changes in fair value being recognised in the statement of profit and loss Fair value represents the exit price i.e. the price that would be paid to transfer a liability or the price that would be received when transferring an asset to a knowledgeable, willing counterparty. 34

  35. Accounting of Derivatives Example - Mr. Bull buys 1000 units NIFTY Future April 2023 expiry, at a price of Rs. 3500/- on 28th March 2023. Initial marginis 10% Daily Settlement price of this unit were as under: Date Daily Settlement price MTM Receivable/ (Payable) [(Daily settlement price Contract price)*units] Cumulative gain/(loss) 28/03/2023 3,550 50,000 50,000 29/03/2023 3,525 25,000 75,000 30/03/2023 3,460 (40,000) 35,000 31/03/2023 3,480 (20,000) 15,000 01/04/2023 Market closed - 15,000 02/04/2023 Market closed - 15,000 03/04/2023 3,575 75,000 90,000 35

  36. Accounting of Derivatives Date Particulars Debit Amount Credit amount 28/03/20 23 At the inception of the contract Future contract asset a/c Dr To Stock broker a/c (Margin = Rs.3,500*1,000 units*10%) 35,000 35,000 31/03/20 23 Open Interest as on Balance sheet Date Stock Broker a/c Dr To MTM (P&L) a/c 15,000 15,000 03/04/20 23 On expiry Stock Broker a/c Dr Bank a/c Dr 20,000 90,000 To Futures contract asset a/c To MTM (P&L) a/c 35,000 75,000 36

  37. Accounting of Derivatives On 31/03/23 Open interest Future contract asset will appear under Current asset 37

  38. Accounting of Derivatives Sample contract note:

  39. Accounting of Derivatives Explanation of contract note: B/F and C/F in the remarks column indicate that these are previous day s positions and that the position has not been squared off. Net total (before levies) Rs. 48,500 and Rs. 21,440 is the mark to market. Payin/ payout obligation (Net total) - Rs. 27,060 is the net mark to market for the specific date.

  40. Accounting of Derivatives (IND AS 109) As per IND AS 109: Classification: Derivatives to be classified as Financial liability or financial asset. Measurement: All derivatives are measured at fair value with changes in fair value being recognized in profit and loss for the period, except derivatives that qualify as hedging instruments. Fair value of a financial instrument is a combination of its intrinsic value and time value. In a fair and perfect market, it would be inappropriate to conclude that immediately at the inception of a contract, it results in creation of rights and obligations for two independent parties i.e. the contract has no intrinsic value at inception 40

  41. Taxation of securities

  42. Equity shares Listed Shares Domestic Equity Unlisted Domestic Equity Shares STCG for shares held < 24 months. Tax rate: As per slab rate of the investor LTCG tax rate: 20% with indexation. STCG for shares held < 12 months. Tax rate: 15%. Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) for shares held 12 months. Tax rate: 10% Exemption: Rs. 1,00,000 Foreign Equity Shares STCG for shares held < 24 months. Tax rate: As per slab rate of the investor LTCG tax rate: 20% with indexation. 42

  43. Mutual Funds A) Equity Mutual Funds: They invest 65% or more of their investable assets assets such as domestic Equity shares STCG for shares held < 12 months. Tax rate: 15%. Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) for shares held 12 months. Tax rate: 10% Exemption: Rs. 1,00,000 (B) Debt Mutual funds: Debt Mutual Funds invest in Debt instruments such as bonds, T-bills, Certificates of Deposits, NCD. G-Sec, overnight call and money market etc. in Equity-oriented Bought till 31/03/2023 STCG for investments held < 36 months. Tax rate: As per Slab rate of the investor LTCG if held 36 months Tax rate: 20% with indexation. Bought after 31/03/2023 Taxed as STCG irrespective of holding period 43

  44. Mutual Funds (C) Hybrid Funds Equity Allocation< 35%: Taxed like Debt MutualFunds. Equity Allocation 65%: Taxed like Equity MutualFunds. Equity allocation between 35%-65%: Taxed at 20% with indexation 44

  45. ETFs (A) Equity ETFs - Majorly invest in equities or related investment instruments. STCG for ETFs held < 12 months. Tax rate: 15%. Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) for ETFs held 12 months. Tax rate: 10% Exemption:Rs. 1,00,000 (B) Gold and Debt ETFs Bought till 31/03/2023 STCG for investments held < 36 months. Tax rate: As per Slab rate of the investor LTCG if held 36 months Tax rate: 20% with indexation. Bought after31/03/2023 Taxed as STCG irrespective of holding period 45

  46. Debt securities (B) Instruments STCG for investments held < 36 months. Tax rate: As per Slab rate of the investor LTCG tax rate: 20% without indexation. Unlisted Debt (A) ListedDebt Instruments STCG for investments held <12 months. Tax rate: As per slab rate of the investor LTCG tax rate: 10% without Indexation. 46

  47. Gold securities (B) Sovereign Gold Bonds Tax-free individuals. If exited before maturity. STCG if held < 36 months. Tax rate: Slab rate. Long-Term (LTCG) if held 36 months. Tax indexation indexation Exemption: Rs. 1,00,000 Interest taxed as Income from other sources at slab rate (A) Gold ETFs, Gold Mutual Funds Bought till 31/03/2023 STCG for investments held < 36 months. Tax rate: As per Slab rate of the investor LTCG if held 36 months Tax rate: 20% with indexation. at maturity only for Capital Gains rate: 10% or without with 20% Bought after 31/03/2023 Taxed as STCG holding period irrespective of 47

  48. REITs and Invits Interest and rental income : Taxed at applicable slab rate. Dividend income : If u/sec 115BAA of Income Tax Act, 1961, the REIT s/Invit s Special Purpose Vehicle has: 1. Not opted for the lower tax regime Dividend is exempt 2. Opted for the lower tax regime - Taxable at the applicable tax slab rate for unit holder At the time of sale of reits/invits -STCG for REITs/Invits held < 36 months. Tax rate: 15%. -Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) for REITs/Invits held 36 months. Tax rate: 10% Exemption: Rs. 1,00,000 48

  49. REITs and Invits Loan repayment i.e., return of capital must be reduced from the cost of acquisition at the time of sale of unit by the investor for computation of capital gain. Loan repayment in excess of issue price will be taxed as Income from other sources at applicable slab rate 49

  50. Derivatives The income from Derivatives instruments should be taxed as Business income according to assessee s income tax slab It is irrespective of the frequency or volume of derivatives transactions. The business income is normally divided into speculative and non- speculative income. 50

More Related Content

giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#