Insights into Realism and its Critiques in Literature

undefined
 
Modernism and
Post-Modernism
 
Reading Contemporary Fiction
Lecture Week Seven
 
Structure of the lecture
 
Realism, a brief recap.
Modernism
Modernist Fiction
Post-Structuralism and Post-Modernism
A Post-Modern text: 500 Days of Summer
 
Realism
 
In week three we looked at the features of a realist text.
Realist fiction became ‘the dominant literary form in Europe in
the first half of the nineteenth century’ (Walder, 1996, p.4).
Realism flourished during the Enlightenment; the period of
time in which scientific rationality became the dominant way
in which humans made sense of the world around them.
Morris suggests that traditionally realism has been viewed as a
“representational form” which was concerned with the “close
artistic imitation of social reality” (
Realism
 4-5).  Thus, Morris
argues, the term has been linked with notions such as mimesis
and verisimilitude (p. 5).
 
Mimesis: a concept linked to mime and imitation. Also
linked to verisimilitude.
Verisimilitude: ‘likeness to truth, and therefore, the
appearance of being true or real, even when fantastic . . .
an acceptable presentation of reality’ (
Dictionary of
Literary Terms and Literary Theory)
As Morris suggests, ‘the realist plot is typically structured
upon the epistemological progress of readers and
principal characters from ignorance to knowledge, and
characterisation normally focuses upon the highly
individualised inner subjective, self-development of
rational understanding and moral discrimination’
(
Realism 
28).
 
 
 
Critiques of Realism
 
‘Classic realism, still the dominant popular mode in
literature, film and television drama, roughly coincides
with the epoch of industrial capitalism.  It performs . . .
the work of ideology, not only in its representation of a
world of consistent subjects who are the origin of
meaning, knowledge and action, but also in offering the
reader, as the position from which the text is most readily
intelligible, the position of subject as the origin both of
understanding and of action in accordance with that
understanding’ (
Critical Practice
 67) .
 
Critiques of Realism
 
Morris:
 ‘There is one distinction between realist writing and actual
everyday reality beyond the text that must be quite
categorically insisted upon: realist novels 
never 
give us
life or a slice of life, nor do they reflect reality . . . realism
is a representational form and a representation can never
be identical with that which it represents’ ([emphasis in
original] 4).
 
Modernism
 
‘Modernism, in the infrastructural productive sense,
begins in the 1890s and 1900s, a time which experienced
mass technological innovations, the second tidal wave of
the Industrial Revolution begun nearly a century before.’
New Technology (automobile, tractor, bus, aeroplane,
telephone, typewriter)
Mass Media and Entertainment (advertising and mass
circulation newspapers, gramophone, wireless telegraph,
gramophone, movie theatres)
Science (genetics, psychoanalysis, theories of the atom,
and of relativity) (Appignanesi and Garratt, 1998, p.11)
 
Modernism
 
What we see here is nothing less than a new way of
looking at the world.  The world itself becomes inter-
connected due to advances in science and technology.
Freud’s theory of consciousness also has radical
implications for how the human subject sees itself.  For
the first time in history, humans have the sense of
themselves as having a psyche with different levels of
consciousness: the conscious, the subconscious and the
unconscious minds.
What effect do you think this might have had on writers
and/or artists?
 
The modernist context
 
Marx and Engels 
The Communist Manifesto
 1848
Darwin 
The Origin of the Species
 1872
Freud  
The Interpretation of dreams 
1899
Einstein 
Relativity
 1916
World War 1 1914-1918
 
Modernist Fiction
 
Virginia Woolf, 
Mrs Dalloway, To the Lighthouse, The Waves
James Joyce 
Ulysses
T.S. Eliot ‘The Wasteland’
Samuel Beckett  
Waiting for Godot
 
For  writers such as Virginia Woolf and James Joyce, the problem with the
realist form is that it does not accurately represent reality as it is
experienced.  Woolf  writes:
Life is not a series of gig-lamps symmetrically arranged; life is a luminous
halo, a semi-transparent envelope surrounding us from the beginning of
consciousness to the end.  Is it not the task of the novelist to convey this
varying, this unknown and uncircumscribed spirit, whatever aberration or
complexity it might display, with as little mixture of the alien and external
as possible? (
Collected Essays: Volume Two
 106)
She suggests that reality cannot be “contained any longer by such ill-fitting
vestments as [novelists] provide” (
Collected Essays: Volume Two
 105).
What does she mean by this?
 
Virginia Woolf
 
Morris uses the example of 
Mrs Dalloway
 to show how Woolf
breaks with the conventions of realism prevalent in her time:
‘plot’ is encompassed in a single day and resolves no
mysteries, leaves the future of the lives presented in the story
as uncertain as at the beginning, and refuses the reader any
objective knowledge of the main protagonists that could form
the basis of moral or epistemological evaluation.  Put in
technical terms, the novel refutes 
closure
: nothing and no one
is summed up in the writing as a coherent truth that can be
known. ([emphasis in original] 15)
What we see here is that Woolf applied her critical ideas about
fiction and pioneered a new style of writing.  Her critique of
realist fiction was that it didn’t actually reflect reality.
 
Post-Modern Fiction
 
Much of the fiction that comes after Woolf and Joyce is
influenced by their ideas.  Many writers take their ideas
forward and produce different kinds of texts.
The two short stories for this week ‘The Balloon’ and
‘How I contemplated my life . . .’ are clearly not realist
texts.
Both these stories are also influenced by the post-
structural critique of language.
This theoretical critique changes the way that texts are
written, read and studied.  Cultural Studies (and current
Literary Studies) owes a great debt to the work of writers
such as Joyce and Woolf and thinkers such as Jacques
Derrida and Roland Barthes (amongst others).
 
Structuralism
 
Post-structuralism is a critique of
structuralism and has its hey-day
in the late ‘60s and early ‘70s.
Ferdinand de Saussure, a
linguist, posited that language is
organised like a system.  For
Saussure  signifiers and signified
make up the SIGN (the meaning
of the word)
So, cat (the word) + cat (the
concept: the idea we get when
we see or hear the word) = sign.
 
Structuralists would argue is
that there is nothing about the
word ‘cat’ or the idea of a cat
which means cat.
Put another way, they believe
the SIGN is relational and
dependent on the relationship
between the signifier and the
signified.
 There is nothing about the
word or the concept that
universally  implies the
characteristics of a cat. ‘Cat’ is
an English word; in Italian it is
‘gatto’, in French it is ‘chat’.
 
Post-Structuralism: Derrida
 
 
Jacques Derrida uses structuralism to point out that a text’s
meaning is relational.  For Derrida, meaning is endlessly
deferred.  Or, to put it more simply, what happens if we look
up the word ‘table’ in the dictionary?
 
Another way of thinking about it is through binaries.  It is
almost impossible to define the word ‘cold’ without invoking
the concept of ‘hot’.
 
Derrida’s formulation of deconstruction has been one of the most
important ideas in post-structural literary theory.  Derrida posits
that if we deconstruct a text – which for the purposes of this unit
means seeing who is represented in the text and who is absent -
we can understand more about the text and the culture it was
created in.  We can reveal meanings in the text that the author
may not have intended.
Deconstruction is an important tool for Cultural Studies and
Literary Criticism.  When applied to the Literary Canon it allows
us to see whose work is valued and whose has been ignored.
Post-Structuralism: Derrida
Post-Structuralism: Barthes
 
Another central idea of post-structuralism is Roland Barthes’
assertion in 1967 that the author is dead’.  What might this mean?
For Barthes, ‘the death of the author’ means that all readers bring
their own meaning to a text. He makes a distinction between the
readerly text 
(a text whose interpretation is straightforward and
determined by the author)
 
and the 
writerly text 
(an open text,
which invites the reader to make up their own meaning).
The work of Derrida and Barthes has been critical in literature.
The period immediately after this post-structuralist critiques is rife
with experimental writing, which has often been labelled post-
modern.
 
Post-Modern Fiction
 
 
Post-modernist writers include Donald Barthelme, Carol
Shields, Thomas Pynchon, Margaret Atwood, A.S. Byatt,
Samuel Beckett, Yann Martel, Arundhati Roy and Dave
Eggers amongst many, many others.
 
‘If postmodernism has proved a synthetic discourse,
unanimated by personal concerns, at least it has given
writers a breath of that precious oxygen of permission, and
more important, time to see in what ways the old realism—
the mirror of the world—has failed us.  It was perhaps, not
real enough.’ (
Carol Shields: Narrative Hunger and the
Possibilities of Fiction
 34)
 
500 Days of Summer
 
Is this a postmodern
text?
 
Why is it a postmodern
text?
 
What does it have in
common with other
postmodern fiction?
 
Recommended Reading
 
Appegnanesi, Richard and Chris Garrat, 1998.
Introducing Postmodernism
,  Icon Books: Cambridge
 
Glendinning, Simon, 2011.  
Derrida: A Very Short
Introduction
.  Oxford University Press: Oxford
Slide Note
Embed
Share

Exploring the dominance of realist fiction in European literature, this content delves into the evolution of realism during the Enlightenment period, emphasizing its focus on mimicking social reality. It details the concept of mimesis and verisimilitude in creating a realistic narrative structure that facilitates character development and moral discernment. Additionally, critiques of classic realism are discussed, highlighting the ideological underpinnings and the distinction between literary representation and actual reality.


Uploaded on Sep 02, 2024 | 0 Views


Download Presentation

Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author. Download presentation by click this link. If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Modernism and Post-Modernism Reading Contemporary Fiction Lecture Week Seven

  2. Realism, a brief recap. Modernism Modernist Fiction Post-Structuralism and Post-Modernism A Post-Modern text: 500 Days of Summer Structure of the lecture

  3. In week three we looked at the features of a realist text. Realist fiction became the dominant literary form in Europe in the first half of the nineteenth century (Walder, 1996, p.4). Realism flourished during the Enlightenment; the period of time in which scientific rationality became the dominant way in which humans made sense of the world around them. Morris suggests that traditionally realism has been viewed as a representational form which was concerned with the close artistic imitation of social reality (Realism 4-5). Thus, Morris argues, the term has been linked with notions such as mimesis and verisimilitude (p. 5). Realism

  4. Mimesis: a concept linked to mime and imitation. Also linked to verisimilitude. Verisimilitude: likeness to truth, and therefore, the appearance of being true or real, even when fantastic . . . an acceptable presentation of reality (Dictionary of Literary Terms and Literary Theory) As Morris suggests, the realist plot is typically structured upon the epistemological progress of readers and principal characters from ignorance to knowledge, and characterisation normally focuses upon the highly individualised inner subjective, self-development of rational understanding and moral discrimination (Realism 28).

  5. Classic realism, still the dominant popular mode in literature, film and television drama, roughly coincides with the epoch of industrial capitalism. It performs . . . the work of ideology, not only in its representation of a world of consistent subjects who are the origin of meaning, knowledge and action, but also in offering the reader, as the position from which the text is most readily intelligible, the position of subject as the origin both of understanding and of action in accordance with that understanding (Critical Practice 67) . Critiques of Realism

  6. Morris: There is one distinction between realist writing and actual everyday reality beyond the text that must be quite categorically insisted upon: realist novels never give us life or a slice of life, nor do they reflect reality . . . realism is a representational form and a representation can never be identical with that which it represents ([emphasis in original] 4). Critiques of Realism

  7. Modernism, in the infrastructural productive sense, begins in the 1890s and 1900s, a time which experienced mass technological innovations, the second tidal wave of the Industrial Revolution begun nearly a century before. New Technology (automobile, tractor, bus, aeroplane, telephone, typewriter) Mass Media and Entertainment (advertising and mass circulation newspapers, gramophone, wireless telegraph, gramophone, movie theatres) Science (genetics, psychoanalysis, theories of the atom, and of relativity) (Appignanesi and Garratt, 1998, p.11) Modernism

  8. What we see here is nothing less than a new way of looking at the world. The world itself becomes inter- connected due to advances in science and technology. Freud s theory of consciousness also has radical implications for how the human subject sees itself. For the first time in history, humans have the sense of themselves as having a psyche with different levels of consciousness: the conscious, the subconscious and the unconscious minds. What effect do you think this might have had on writers and/or artists? Modernism

  9. Marx and Engels The Communist Manifesto 1848 Darwin The Origin of the Species 1872 Freud The Interpretation of dreams 1899 Einstein Relativity 1916 World War 1 1914-1918 The modernist context

  10. Virginia Woolf, Mrs Dalloway, To the Lighthouse, The Waves James Joyce Ulysses T.S. Eliot The Wasteland Samuel Beckett Waiting for Godot For writers such as Virginia Woolf and James Joyce, the problem with the realist form is that it does not accurately represent reality as it is experienced. Woolf writes: Life is not a series of gig-lamps symmetrically arranged; life is a luminous halo, a semi-transparent envelope surrounding us from the beginning of consciousness to the end. Is it not the task of the novelist to convey this varying, this unknown and uncircumscribed spirit, whatever aberration or complexity it might display, with as little mixture of the alien and external as possible? (Collected Essays: Volume Two 106) She suggests that reality cannot be contained any longer by such ill-fitting vestments as [novelists] provide (Collected Essays: Volume Two 105). What does she mean by this? Modernist Fiction

  11. Morris uses the example of Mrs Dalloway to show how Woolf breaks with the conventions of realism prevalent in her time: plot is encompassed in a single day and resolves no mysteries, leaves the future of the lives presented in the story as uncertain as at the beginning, and refuses the reader any objective knowledge of the main protagonists that could form the basis of moral or epistemological evaluation. Put in technical terms, the novel refutes closure: nothing and no one is summed up in the writing as a coherent truth that can be known. ([emphasis in original] 15) What we see here is that Woolf applied her critical ideas about fiction and pioneered a new style of writing. Her critique of realist fiction was that it didn t actually reflect reality. Virginia Woolf

  12. Much of the fiction that comes after Woolf and Joyce is influenced by their ideas. Many writers take their ideas forward and produce different kinds of texts. The two short stories for this week The Balloon and How I contemplated my life . . . are clearly not realist texts. Both these stories are also influenced by the post- structural critique of language. This theoretical critique changes the way that texts are written, read and studied. Cultural Studies (and current Literary Studies) owes a great debt to the work of writers such as Joyce and Woolf and thinkers such as Jacques Derrida and Roland Barthes (amongst others). Post-Modern Fiction

  13. Structuralists would argue is that there is nothing about the word cat or the idea of a cat which means cat. Put another way, they believe the SIGN is relational and dependent on the relationship between the signifier and the signified. There is nothing about the word or the concept that universally implies the characteristics of a cat. Cat is an English word; in Italian it is gatto , in French it is chat . Post-structuralism is a critique of structuralism and has its hey-day in the late 60s and early 70s. Ferdinand de Saussure, a linguist, posited that language is organised like a system. For Saussure signifiers and signified make up the SIGN (the meaning of the word) So, cat (the word) + cat (the concept: the idea we get when we see or hear the word) = sign. Structuralism

  14. Jacques Derrida uses structuralism to point out that a texts meaning is relational. For Derrida, meaning is endlessly deferred. Or, to put it more simply, what happens if we look up the word table in the dictionary? Another way of thinking about it is through binaries. It is almost impossible to define the word cold without invoking the concept of hot . Post-Structuralism: Derrida

  15. Derridas formulation of deconstruction has been one of the most important ideas in post-structural literary theory. Derrida posits that if we deconstruct a text which for the purposes of this unit means seeing who is represented in the text and who is absent - we can understand more about the text and the culture it was created in. We can reveal meanings in the text that the author may not have intended. Deconstruction is an important tool for Cultural Studies and Literary Criticism. When applied to the Literary Canon it allows us to see whose work is valued and whose has been ignored. Post-Structuralism: Derrida

  16. Another central idea of post-structuralism is Roland Barthes assertion in 1967 that the author is dead . What might this mean? For Barthes, the death of the author means that all readers bring their own meaning to a text. He makes a distinction between the readerly text (a text whose interpretation is straightforward and determined by the author) and the writerly text (an open text, which invites the reader to make up their own meaning). The work of Derrida and Barthes has been critical in literature. The period immediately after this post-structuralist critiques is rife with experimental writing, which has often been labelled post- modern. Post-Structuralism: Barthes

  17. Post-modernist writers include Donald Barthelme, Carol Shields, Thomas Pynchon, Margaret Atwood, A.S. Byatt, Samuel Beckett, Yann Martel, Arundhati Roy and Dave Eggers amongst many, many others. If postmodernism has proved a synthetic discourse, unanimated by personal concerns, at least it has given writers a breath of that precious oxygen of permission, and more important, time to see in what ways the old realism the mirror of the world has failed us. It was perhaps, not real enough. (Carol Shields: Narrative Hunger and the Possibilities of Fiction 34) Post-Modern Fiction

  18. Is this a postmodern text? Why is it a postmodern text? What does it have in common with other postmodern fiction? 500 Days of Summer

  19. Appegnanesi, Richard and Chris Garrat, 1998. Introducing Postmodernism, Icon Books: Cambridge Glendinning, Simon, 2011. Derrida: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford University Press: Oxford Recommended Reading

Related


More Related Content

giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#