Water Quality Assessment Process Summary for EMC Approval
undefined
REQUEST PERMISSION TO
PROCEED TO
EMC
FOR
APPROVAL OF
2014 303(D)
LISTING METHODOLOGY
Kathy Stecker
Schedule
2
March 13-14
– 303(d) Listing Methods to WQC/
EMC for approval
DWQ applies methods, conducts review
Jan. – Feb. 2014
– Public review of 303(d) List
March
– EMC info item on results
April 1
– Submit List to EPA for approval
May-June
– Public comment on 2016 listing methods
Status
3
Documents
A.
2014 303(d) Listing Methodology
B.
2014 Assessment Process Comments and Responses
C.
2014 Water Quality Assessment Process
DWQ meeting with commenters
February 18, 2013
2014 Assessment Process
Comments and Responses
303(d) listing methods
1.
Single benthos or fish community results
2.
Shellfish harvesting classifications
3.
Fish consumption listings
4.
Quantify statistical confidence
More information requested
1.
Rationale for each listing
2.
Natural conditions
3.
All assessment categories
4.
Data acceptability
5.
De-listing process
2014 Water Quality
Assessment Process
Comprehensive, transparent, understandable
description of entire assessment process
“De-listing”
Data submittal
Assessment units
Categories 1-5
303(d) List
1
2
3
4
5
Assessment Categories
Meeting criteria
Criteria exceeded
No info/inconclusive
2014 Water Quality
Assessment Process
Changes from 2012
Fish tissue data
Category 5 = site-specific fish consumption advisories
developed using fish tissue data
Develop guidance for moving waters from Category 4t to
Category 1t for mercury, consistent with EPA guidance
90% statistical confidence for Categories 4 and 5
For certain numeric criteria
With 10% exceedance allowance
2014 Water Quality
Assessment Process
Categories 4 and 5
Greater than
10%
of samples exceed criteria, with
greater than or equal to
90%
statistical confidence
Category 3
Greater than or equal to
10%
of samples exceed
criteria, with less than
90%
statistical confidence
Category 1
Less than
10%
of samples exceed criteria
Example – Turbidity Assessment
(2012 Data Set)
2014 303(d) Listing Methodology
Changes
Fish tissue data
90% statistical confidence for listing
REQUEST PERMISSION TO
PROCEED TO
EMC
FOR
APPROVAL OF
2014 303(D)
LISTING METHODOLOGY
The request seeks EMC approval for the 2014 303(d) listing methodology by Kathy Stecker. The process involves conducting reviews, public comments, and submitting lists for EPA approval. It includes assessment categories, response to comments, statistical confidence, and criteria exceedance. Changes from 2012 include fish tissue data updates and site-specific advisories. Categories 4 and 5 require statistical confidence, while Category 1 has fewer criteria exceedances.
Download Presentation
Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author. Download presentation by click this link. If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.
E N D
Presentation Transcript
REQUEST PERMISSION TO PROCEED TO EMC FOR APPROVAL OF 2014 303(D) LISTING METHODOLOGY Kathy Stecker
Schedule 2 March 13-14 303(d) Listing Methods to WQC/ EMC for approval DWQ applies methods, conducts review Jan. Feb. 2014 Public review of 303(d) List March EMC info item on results April 1 Submit List to EPA for approval May-June Public comment on 2016 listing methods
Status 3 Documents 2014 303(d) Listing Methodology 2014 Assessment Process Comments and Responses 2014 Water Quality Assessment Process A. B. C. DWQ meeting with commenters February 18, 2013
2014 Assessment Process Comments and Responses 303(d) listing methods Single benthos or fish community results Shellfish harvesting classifications Fish consumption listings Quantify statistical confidence More information requested Rationale for each listing Natural conditions All assessment categories Data acceptability De-listing process 1. 2. 3. 4. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
2014 Water Quality Assessment Process Comprehensive, transparent, understandable description of entire assessment process De-listing Data submittal Assessment units Categories 1-5
1 Meeting criteria 2 3 No info/inconclusive 4 Criteria exceeded 5 303(d) List
2014 Water Quality Assessment Process Changes from 2012 Fish tissue data Category 5 = site-specific fish consumption advisories developed using fish tissue data Develop guidance for moving waters from Category 4t to Category 1t for mercury, consistent with EPA guidance 90% statistical confidence for Categories 4 and 5 For certain numeric criteria With 10% exceedance allowance
2014 Water Quality Assessment Process Categories 4 and 5 Greater than 10% of samples exceed criteria, with greater than or equal to 90% statistical confidence Category 3 Greater than or equal to 10% of samples exceed criteria, with less than 90% statistical confidence Category 1 Less than 10% of samples exceed criteria
Example Turbidity Assessment (2012 Data Set) Estimated Number of Locations Old Method 877 55 118 Category 1 3 4+5 New Method 877 117 56
2014 303(d) Listing Methodology Changes Fish tissue data 90% statistical confidence for listing
REQUEST PERMISSION TO PROCEED TO EMC FOR APPROVAL OF 2014 303(D) LISTING METHODOLOGY
