Official Misconduct and Immunity Overview
Review and questions
- Our speaker tonight
- Official misconduct and immunity
- Compensation
- Your questions for Wednesday: what topics to
review?
•
Questions before we start?
•
Reminder: Kyle May questions about death row
•
Topics for Wednesday?
Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Henry McCollum and Leon Brown
•
See the CDPL overview on the web page for information about the
case.
•
Basics: Arrested, confession pulled out of them, “Deadliest DA in the
World” seeks and obtains death sentences; true perpetrator lives 100
feet from the crime scene, arrested 3 weeks later for a similar crime;
they all go to jail. Leon later has his sentence reduced from death to
LWOP. Both exonerated only after the case goes to the NC Innocence
Inquiry Commission, which has subpoena power, and they find a
cigarette butt in the files with DNA linking it to the true perpetrator.
Ken Rose had asked for these files numerous times over 20 years, but
they search was always done by the police department which was
responsible for the evidence. NCIIC has power to do its own search.
Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
The crime was particularly notorious
•
Justice Scalia in
Callins v. Collins
(1994), on the conditions of lethal
injection.
•
“For example, the case of the 11-year old girl raped by four men and then
killed by stuffing her panties down her throat. How enviable a quiet death by
lethal injection compared with that!”
•
2014 NC General Assembly election campaign, attack on Democratic
Rep. Hugh Holliman (Greensboro) for vote on the Racial Justice Act.
Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
2010 Campaign Flier featuring Henry
McCollum
Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Crimes of Wrongful Liberty
•
Three weeks after Henry and Leon were arrested, another crime happened.
That crime would not have happened if Roscoe Artis had been arrested for
his earlier crime. But with Henry and Leon signing a confession, they were
detained and the true perpetrator was left on the street.
•
1,000,000 felonies x 4% = 40,000
•
Say 25% have no underlying crime = 30,000 wrongfully at liberty
•
Say each does two more crimes = 60,000 crimes of wrongful liberty (that is,
one every 10 minutes!)
•
Say each crime affects 20 people, loved ones, jury members, etc.: 1.2
million people affected by such crimes, each year. Not a niche issue.
Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Absolute and partial immunity
•
Absolute immunity:
•
A trial witness has absolute immunity with respect to any claim based on the
witness’ testimony.
•
Therefore, perjury cannot give rise to a civil suit. This includes anyone who
testifies in trial.
•
Qualified immunity:
•
“protects government officials from liability so long as they could reasonably
believe that their conduct does not violate clearly established law”
•
Protects all but the plainly incompetent or those who knowingly violate the law.
•
Was a right violated? Was that right clearly established (so should have been known)?
•
Government agencies may not have a “pattern and practice” of constitutional
violations (
Monell
claim)
Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Case of John Thompson (Louisiana)
•
Sentenced to death in Angola Prison
•
Exonerated
•
Sues the Orleans Parish DA’s office for a “pattern and practice” of
such things as suppressing evidence.
•
Shows it in his case, and in many other cases
•
Awarded $14 million in 2008
•
State appealed, and in 2011 by 5-4 vote the USSC rescinded the award: while
they had done it to Thompson, they found no “pattern and practice”: isolated
errors are inevitable and do not merit compensation, ruled the Court.
Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Logic of immunity
•
Judges might be on the bench for 30 years.
•
If they did not have immunity, they might all end up bankrupt or in
jail at the end of their careers, or worried about an error they may
have made leading to such a lawsuit.
•
Ditto for DA’s.
•
So this is a well established area of law.
•
How high should the bar be for relief?
•
Note who will decide: other judges…
Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Compensation
•
27 states have some kind of compensation
•
New Hampshire: $20,000 maximum
•
New York: $80,000 per year, no maximum
•
Typically, nothing at all, many hurdles to get it
•
NC: Governor must issue a pardon of innocence to qualify for $700,000. Has
been done just a handful of times.
•
Civil Suits typically the only way to get significant compensation.
Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Why so hard?
•
“Criminal element”
•
Maybe they did something else…
•
Sometimes prosecutors feel the exoneration was the injustice, not the
conviction. That is, they do not believe they are innocent. Google any
person convicted then released. Information about the original
conviction will remain out there. Sometimes it’s hard to come to the
revised conclusion that they were innocent…
•
You can think of other reasons why governments are stingy here.
Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Duke Lacrosse case
•
Everything turned on its head
•
Privilege, wealth, good lawyers for the defendants
•
DA not only lost his position, but was later disbarred
•
Civil suit led to $50,000,000 award
•
Not a single defendant had spent a night in jail.
•
Compare to John Thompson: 18 years on Death Row, $14,000,000,
later reversed. 18 years on death row v. a wrongful accusation…
Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
The content explores cases of official misconduct and immunity, highlighting the wrongful convictions of Henry McCollum and Leon Brown. It delves into the challenges faced by innocent individuals within the justice system, including issues of absolute and partial immunity for witnesses and government officials. The discussion also touches on the impact of false confessions and the need for accountability in law enforcement.
Download Presentation
Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.
You are allowed to download the files provided on this website for personal or commercial use, subject to the condition that they are used lawfully. All files are the property of their respective owners.
The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.
E N D
Presentation Transcript
Review and questions - Our speaker tonight - Official misconduct and immunity - Compensation - Your questions for Wednesday: what topics to review? Questions before we start? Reminder: Kyle May questions about death row Topics for Wednesday? Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Henry McCollum and Leon Brown See the CDPL overview on the web page for information about the case. Basics: Arrested, confession pulled out of them, Deadliest DA in the World seeks and obtains death sentences; true perpetrator lives 100 feet from the crime scene, arrested 3 weeks later for a similar crime; they all go to jail. Leon later has his sentence reduced from death to LWOP. Both exonerated only after the case goes to the NC Innocence Inquiry Commission, which has subpoena power, and they find a cigarette butt in the files with DNA linking it to the true perpetrator. Ken Rose had asked for these files numerous times over 20 years, but they search was always done by the police department which was responsible for the evidence. NCIIC has power to do its own search. Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
The crime was particularly notorious Justice Scalia in Callins v. Collins (1994), on the conditions of lethal injection. For example, the case of the 11-year old girl raped by four men and then killed by stuffing her panties down her throat. How enviable a quiet death by lethal injection compared with that! 2014 NC General Assembly election campaign, attack on Democratic Rep. Hugh Holliman (Greensboro) for vote on the Racial Justice Act. Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
2010 Campaign Flier featuring Henry McCollum Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Crimes of Wrongful Liberty Three weeks after Henry and Leon were arrested, another crime happened. That crime would not have happened if Roscoe Artis had been arrested for his earlier crime. But with Henry and Leon signing a confession, they were detained and the true perpetrator was left on the street. 1,000,000 felonies x 4% = 40,000 Say 25% have no underlying crime = 30,000 wrongfully at liberty Say each does two more crimes = 60,000 crimes of wrongful liberty (that is, one every 10 minutes!) Say each crime affects 20 people, loved ones, jury members, etc.: 1.2 million people affected by such crimes, each year. Not a niche issue. Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Absolute and partial immunity Absolute immunity: A trial witness has absolute immunity with respect to any claim based on the witness testimony. Therefore, perjury cannot give rise to a civil suit. This includes anyone who testifies in trial. Qualified immunity: protects government officials from liability so long as they could reasonably believe that their conduct does not violate clearly established law Protects all but the plainly incompetent or those who knowingly violate the law. Was a right violated? Was that right clearly established (so should have been known)? Government agencies may not have a pattern and practice of constitutional violations (Monell claim) Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Case of John Thompson (Louisiana) Sentenced to death in Angola Prison Exonerated Sues the Orleans Parish DA s office for a pattern and practice of such things as suppressing evidence. Shows it in his case, and in many other cases Awarded $14 million in 2008 State appealed, and in 2011 by 5-4 vote the USSC rescinded the award: while they had done it to Thompson, they found no pattern and practice : isolated errors are inevitable and do not merit compensation, ruled the Court. Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Logic of immunity Judges might be on the bench for 30 years. If they did not have immunity, they might all end up bankrupt or in jail at the end of their careers, or worried about an error they may have made leading to such a lawsuit. Ditto for DA s. So this is a well established area of law. How high should the bar be for relief? Note who will decide: other judges Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Compensation 27 states have some kind of compensation New Hampshire: $20,000 maximum New York: $80,000 per year, no maximum Typically, nothing at all, many hurdles to get it NC: Governor must issue a pardon of innocence to qualify for $700,000. Has been done just a handful of times. Civil Suits typically the only way to get significant compensation. Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Why so hard? Criminal element Maybe they did something else Sometimes prosecutors feel the exoneration was the injustice, not the conviction. That is, they do not believe they are innocent. Google any person convicted then released. Information about the original conviction will remain out there. Sometimes it s hard to come to the revised conclusion that they were innocent You can think of other reasons why governments are stingy here. Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
Duke Lacrosse case Everything turned on its head Privilege, wealth, good lawyers for the defendants DA not only lost his position, but was later disbarred Civil suit led to $50,000,000 award Not a single defendant had spent a night in jail. Compare to John Thompson: 18 years on Death Row, $14,000,000, later reversed. 18 years on death row v. a wrongful accusation Baumgartner, POLI 203, Spring 2018
