Comparative Study on Mongolic and Tungusic Languages

 
Об одном совпадении между
тунгусо-маньчжурскими и
монгольскими языками
:
*
-
r
 
как показатель множественного числа
 
Ю. А. Янхунен
Языки от Сибири до Аляски
К 70-летию Е. В. Головко
Санктпетербург 26 января 2024 г.
 
Sources on the history of Mongolic
 
Philology 
  
Middle Mongol and Written Mongol
Linguistics 
  
Mutual comparison of the modern
   
Mongolic languages
 
   
External comparison of Mongolic with
   
Para-Mongolic / Khitanic
 
   
External comparison of Mongolic with
   
Turkic and Tungusic
 
   
Internal reconstruction of Mongolic /
   
Proto-Mongolic
 
 
 
I
nternal reconstruction
 
Dissecting synchronically indivisible words
Discovering repeating elements and patterns
Identifying lost component structure
 
Lexicalized compounds
Obscured derivatives
Petrified forms
 
      
           Robert Austerlitz 1923–1994
 
 
Mongolo-Tungusic parallels
 
General typology: syntax, morphosyntax
Sound systems: phonology, phonotactics
Lexicon: a few basic words, e.g. *
moo 
‘tree, wood’
Lexicon: a few cultural items, e.g. *
örke 
‘door’
Lexicon: a large corpus of borrowings: Doerfer 1986
Morphology: some borrowings Mo > Tu
Morphology: a few shared systematic patterns
 
 
 
 
Class markers
 
c
ountable objects 
  
uncountable masses
 
*mo-d.u/n 
 
‘tree’
   
*u-s.u/n
 
‘water’
*xo-d.u/n 
 
‘star’
   
*ü-s.ü/n
 
‘milk’
*xö-d.ü/n 
 
‘feather’
  
*to-s.u/n 
 
‘oil’
*so-d.u/n
 
‘quill’
   
*cï-s.u/n 
 
‘blood’
*ni-d.ü/n 
 
‘eye’
   
*nï-s.u/n
 
‘mucus’
*si-d.ü/n 
 
‘tooth’ 
  
*ca-s.u/n 
 
‘snow’
     
*xü-s.ü/n
 
‘hair’
     
*ya-s.u/n 
 
‘bone’
 
c
f. PL *-d, Tungusic *-k-tA
  
cf. PL *-s, Tungusic *-k-sA
 
Tungusic plural
 
Vowel stems: *-l  
  
beye : beye-l
Consonant stems: *.V-l
 
juug : juug.i-l
Nasal stems: *-r 
   
oro/n : oro-r
 
Secondary: *-sA-l
  
beye : beye-sel
2 *jöö-r  
    
Nanai 
juer
d
aa.r ‘fathom’  
   
Nanai 
daa/r
 
PL *-r in ethnonyms
 
Daghur -r < *-d 
   
Jucher
Bulghar Turkic -r < *-s 
  
Oghur
Turkic PTCP -V.r 
   
Bulghar
Tungusic *-r 
    
Samar
 
Ambiguous 
    
Tatar
Obscure
     
Avar etc.
 
Mongolic PL *-r
 
 
       
Turkic
 
*emün- ‘front’ 
  
*ebü.r ‘front’ 
 
kökü-z
    
*ebe.r ‘horn/s’ 
 
büŋü-z
 
    
[*koxur ‘fiddle’
 
kopu-z]
 
 
*nekün > Ew nekun 
 
*nekü.r ‘friend’
*n
axun [r. Nonni] 
  
*naxu.r ‘lake’
 
 
 
 
 
Face
 
Pre-Proto-Turkic 
  
PL *düü-s ‘face’
Pre-Proto-Bulgharic
 
*dür/i
 
→ Mongolic 
 
*düri ‘shape, look’
 
→ Mongolic 
 
*dür-sü/n ‘shape, form’
Common Turkic 
  
*yüüz > *jüz
 
→ Mongolic 
 
*jüs.ü/n ‘complexion, colour’
 
Mongolic  
   
PL *nïxu-r
Nanai 
   
PL dere-l : dereg-
Finnish   
   
PL kasvo-t
 
Reflexive marker
 
Written Mongol †öber vs. Proto-Mongolic *öxer
Daghur 
een
 < *exen
 
: 
weer 
< *öxer
Pre-Proto-Mongolic *epen : *öper < *epe/n : *epe-r
 
 
 
Mongolic 
  
Tungusic
 
ABS
  
*e.pe-n
 
 
 
*bee-n > *mee-n
PL
  
*e.pe-r
   
*bee-r >  *mee-r
RX SG
  
*-pA-n > *-xAn
 
*-bA-(y)I > *-bII
RX PL
     
*-bA-r-I
 
Etymons with *-r
 
2 *ji-r-
    
*koxa.r ‘pair’ > 2
3 *gu-r-
    
*kaca.r ‘cheek/s’
4 *dö-r- 
    
*kaba.r ‘nose’
10 *pa-r-
     
*gar ‘hand/s, arm/s’
     
*ka-pu-r ‘spring’
     
*na-pu-r ‘autumn’
     
cf. *po/n ‘time’
 
Cf. Turkic *-s > -z/-r
 
1PL bi-z : PX -miz
   
agï-z ‘mouth, lip/s’
2PL si-z : PX –ƞiz
   
bäƞi-z ‘cheek/s’
VX 1PL -z  
    
büƞü-z ‘horn/s’
     
di-z ‘knee/s’
2 iki-z ‘twins’
   
gö-z ‘eye/s’
8 seki-z 
    
kökü-z ‘breast/s’
9 toku-z
    
omu-z ‘shoulder/s’
30 otu-z  
    
yamï-z ‘groin’
100 yü-z  
    
yü-z ‘face’
     
yïldï-z ‘star’
 
Mongolic plural
 
Early primary? SG */n :
  
*-r
 
Early secondary 
 
 SG */n : 
  
*-d
Early secondary  SG *-V-
  
*-s cf. Turkic
 
Late secondary 
    
+nAr
Late tertiary 
    
*-U.d
Late quaternary 
    
*-nUxU-d
 
etc.
 
What about *-l?
 
      
Turkic
*uru(xu).l ‘lip/s’
    
agï-z
 
*dexe.l ‘clothes’
*gutu-l ‘shoes’ (p.c. P. Rykin 26 Jan 2024)
*suda-l : *suda-su/n 
vein’
 
Conclusions
 
 
Tungusic *
-
r old, productive, widely attested
 
 
but: diachronically enigmatic
 
Mongolic *-r marginal, non-productive, residual
 
but: remains a vague possibility
 
 
Спасибо!
Slide Note
Embed
Share

Explore the fascinating linguistics of Mongolic and Tungusic languages, delving into their historical sources, internal reconstruction, morphology, syntax, and class markers. Discover the parallels and differences between these language families, analyzing aspects such as sound systems, lexicon, and plurals. Uncover the intricate structure of countable objects and uncountable masses, as well as the plural forms and ethnonyms of these languages. Engage with the rich linguistic heritage and shared patterns of Mongolic and Tungusic languages through this detailed comparative study.

  • Linguistics
  • Mongolic
  • Tungusic
  • Comparative Study
  • Language Families

Uploaded on Sep 27, 2024 | 0 Views


Download Presentation

Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author. Download presentation by click this link. If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. - : *-r . . 70- . . 26 2024 .

  2. Sources on the history of Mongolic Philology Middle Mongol and Written Mongol Linguistics Mutual comparison of the modern Mongolic languages External comparison of Mongolic with Para-Mongolic / Khitanic External comparison of Mongolic with Turkic and Tungusic Internal reconstruction of Mongolic / Proto-Mongolic

  3. Internal reconstruction Dissecting synchronically indivisible words Discovering repeating elements and patterns Identifying lost component structure Lexicalized compounds Obscured derivatives Petrified forms Robert Austerlitz 1923 1994

  4. Mongolo-Tungusic parallels General typology: syntax, morphosyntax Sound systems: phonology, phonotactics Lexicon: a few basic words, e.g. *moo tree, wood Lexicon: a few cultural items, e.g. * rke door Lexicon: a large corpus of borrowings: Doerfer 1986 Morphology: some borrowings Mo > Tu Morphology: a few shared systematic patterns

  5. Class markers countable objects uncountable masses *mo-d.u/n tree *xo-d.u/n *x -d. /n *so-d.u/n *ni-d. /n *si-d. /n *u-s.u/n * -s. /n *to-s.u/n *c -s.u/n *n -s.u/n *ca-s.u/n *x -s. /n *ya-s.u/n water milk oil blood mucus snow hair bone star feather quill eye tooth cf. PL *-d, Tungusic *-k-tA cf. PL *-s, Tungusic *-k-sA

  6. Tungusic plural Vowel stems: *-l Consonant stems: *.V-l Nasal stems: *-r beye : beye-l juug : juug.i-l oro/n : oro-r Secondary: *-sA-l 2 *j -r daa.r fathom beye : beye-sel Nanai juer Nanai daa/r

  7. PL *-r in ethnonyms Daghur -r < *-d Bulghar Turkic -r < *-s Turkic PTCP -V.r Tungusic *-r Jucher Oghur Bulghar Samar Ambiguous Obscure Tatar Avar etc.

  8. Mongolic PL *-r Turkic *em n- front *eb .r front *ebe.r horn/s k k -z b -z [*koxur fiddle kopu-z] *nek n > Ew nekun *naxun [r. Nonni] *nek .r friend *naxu.r lake

  9. Face Pre-Proto-Turkic Pre-Proto-Bulgharic Mongolic Mongolic Common Turkic Mongolic PL *d -s face *d r/i *d ri shape, look *d r-s /n shape, form *y z > *j z *j s. /n complexion, colour Mongolic Nanai Finnish PL *n xu-r PL dere-l : dereg- PL kasvo-t

  10. Reflexive marker Written Mongol ber vs. Proto-Mongolic * xer Daghur een < *exen : weer < * xer Pre-Proto-Mongolic *epen : * per < *epe/n : *epe-r Mongolic Tungusic ABS PL RX SG RX PL *e.pe-n *e.pe-r *-pA-n > *-xAn *bee-n > *mee-n *bee-r > *mee-r *-bA-(y)I > *-bII *-bA-r-I

  11. Etymons with *-r 2 *ji-r- 3 *gu-r- 4 *d -r- 10 *pa-r- *koxa.r pair > 2 *kaca.r cheek/s *kaba.r nose *gar hand/s, arm/s *ka-pu-r spring *na-pu-r autumn cf. *po/n time

  12. Cf. Turkic *-s > -z/-r 1PL bi-z : PX -miz 2PL si-z : PX iz VX 1PL -z ag -z mouth, lip/s b i-z cheek/s b -z horn/s di-z knee/s g -z eye/s k k -z breast/s omu-z shoulder/s yam -z groin y -z face y ld -z star 2 iki-z twins 8 seki-z 9 toku-z 30 otu-z 100 y -z

  13. Mongolic plural Early primary? SG */n : *-r Early secondary SG */n : Early secondary SG *-V- *-d *-s cf. Turkic Late secondary Late tertiary Late quaternary +nAr *-U.d *-nUxU-d etc.

  14. What about *-l? Turkic ag -z *uru(xu).l lip/s *dexe.l clothes *gutu-l shoes (p.c. P. Rykin 26 Jan 2024) *suda-l : *suda-su/n vein

  15. Conclusions Tungusic *-r old, productive, widely attested but: diachronically enigmatic Mongolic *-r marginal, non-productive, residual but: remains a vague possibility

  16. !

More Related Content

giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#