Art and Information: Connecting Theory and Practice

REIMAGINING
THE FRAME:
 
CONNECTING ART TO THE FRAMEWORK IN THEORY AND IN PRACTICE
 
TODAY’S SESSION
 
1.
Framework Tool/Activity Lightning Talks
1.
Anna Boutin-Cooper: Searching as Strategic Exploration
2.
Alex Watkins: Authority is Constructed and Contextual
3.
Claire Powell: Information Has Value
4.
Shannon Robinson: Informed Learning and Assessment
2.
Workshop
3.
Summary and Questions
 
"CATALOGING" IMAGES:
LOOKING FOR KEYWORDS
 
Anna Boutin-Cooper
 
"Searching for information is often 
nonlinear 
and
iterative
, requiring the 
evaluation of a range
 of
information sources and the mental flexibility to pursue
alternative avenues as new understanding develops."
 
Searching As Strategic Exploration,
Framework for Information Literacy for Higher Education
 
SEARCHING AS STRATEGIC EXPLORATION
 
KNOWLEDGE PRACTICES
 
Matching information needs and search
strategies to the appropriate search
tools
Using different kinds of searching
language appropriately
 
DISPOSITIONS
 
Exhibiting mental flexibility and creativity
in searching
Understanding that first attempts at
searching do not always produce
adequate results
 
Text taken directly from the ACRL 
Framework for Information Literacy in Higher Education
, 2016.
 
SEARCHING AS STRATEGIC EXPLORATION
 
Importance of the "right" keywords
Discussion of what makes a "good" keyword v. a "bad" keyword
Context-specific!
How to loop searching frame in with art history class?
Development of "cataloging" image activity
 
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
 
By the end of class, students will understand how to construct successful keyword
strategies for image searching.
By the end of class, students will be able to search for images in Artstor and other image
databases, in order to fulfill their image needs.
 
KEYWORDS
 
Red
Blue
Textile
Embroidery
Quilt
 
Image credit: The Metropolitan Museum of Art
 
Woven
Shawl
Women
Flowers
Floral
 
SUCCESSFUL KEYWORDS
 
Red
Blue
Textile
Embroidery
Quilt
 
Woven
Shawl
Women
Flowers
Floral
 
Image credit: The Metropolitan Museum of Art
 
TEACHING INCLUSIVE SOURCE
EVALUATION FOR RESEARCHING
NATIVE ART
 
Alex Watkins
 
AUTHORITY IS CULTURALLY CONSTRUCTED
 
Culturally specific systems of knowledge determine who is an authority and what
knowledge is authoritative
Librarians traditionally teach just one construction of authority, academic, and the
specific markers and source types that are considered authoritative in this community
Academia excludes and silences knowledge that is not constructed in this way
IL instruction for research on Native art must acknowledge and value Native knowledge,
but traditional modes of source evaluation instruction excludes this knowledge
 
KNOWLEDGE SYSTEMS / WAYS OF KNOWING
 
ACADEMIC KNOWLEDGE
 
Citations to the written record
Credentials experts
Peer Review
 
NATIVE KNOWLEDGE
 
Oral tradition
Wisdom of elders
Community agreement, proven utility
 
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
 
Students understand that authority is constructed based on cultural systems of knowledge and
ways of knowing.
Students understand that indigenous authority is different from but not less than Western
conceptions of authority.
Students question the Western system of authority as default or natural.
Students can identify and explain the different markers of authority in Western and indigenous
cultures.
Students seek out native voices and can articulate how and why native understandings of art are
different from Western interpretations.
 
 
VALUING CONTRIBUTIONS: STUDENT
INFORMATIONAL INSIGHTS AS A
COMMODITY
 
Claire Powell
 
INFORMATION HAS VALUE
 
KNOWLEDGE PRACTICES
 
Deciding where and how their
information is published
Understand how the commodification of
their personal information and online
interactions affects the information they
receive and the information they
produce or disseminate online
 
DISPOSITIONS
 
Valuing the skills, time, and effort
needed to produce knowledge
Seeing themselves as contributors to the
information marketplace rather than
only consumers of it
 
Text taken directly from the ACRL 
Framework for Information Literacy in Higher Education
, 2016.
 
FACULTY COLLABORATION
 
Relaying the value of students’ own contributions to the art and design community
Identifying relevant publishing outlets
Connecting the dissemination of personal skills and knowledge to success in the industry
and networking opportunities
Authentic learning and professional opportunities related to commodifying their exclusive
information
 
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
 
Students will demonstrate an understanding of relevant publishing channels related to
their discipline and information type
Students will identify personal skills and information for potential publishing
opportunities
Students will be able to articulate the importance of information within their industry
and different forms of its commodification
 
INFORMED LEARNING
 
Shannon Robinson
 
INFORMED LEARNING
 
Informed learning brings learner-centered, experiential, and reflective approaches to the
information literacy agenda. (Bruce 2008)
Informed learning . . .
takes into account learners’ experiences
promotes the simultaneous development of discipline + process learning
is about changes in experience
 
INFORMED LEARNING
 
SEVEN FACES OF INFORMED LEARNING
 
Information Awareness +
Communication Experience
Sourcing Information Experience
Information Process Experience
Information Control Experience
 
Knowledge Construction Experience
Knowledge Extension Experience
Wisdom Experience
   (Bruce 1997, 2008)
 
INFORMED LEARNING
 
CONTENT what should learners know
about the subject + about information
literacy?
COMPETENCY what should learners be
able to do?
LEARNING TO LEARN what does it
mean to think like an informed learner in
the professional environment?
 
PERSONAL RELEVANCE what good is
information literacy to me?
SOCIAL IMPACT how does information
literacy impact society?
RELATIONAL bringing about awareness
of the critical ways of seeing or
experiencing (Bruce 2008)
 
 
INFORMED LEARNING TO FRAMEWORK
 
ASSESSMENT
 
CONTENT is objective + measures how
much has been learned
COMPETENCY determines level of skill
achieved
LEARNING TO LEARN is complex,
where contextual problems are posed
 
 
 
PERSONAL RELEVANCE is cumulative
(portfolio) + self-reflective
SOCIAL IMPACT prompts reflection on
the impact of information literacy
RELATIONAL is designed to reveal
ways of seeing or experiencing the
phenomenon
 
 
 
 
ASSESSMENT
 
WHEN YOU WERE A STUDENT (LEARNING SOMETHING NEW), HOW DID
A TEACHER / COACH / TUTOR / MENTOR…
 
Encourage you to consider your own
personal experiences 
+
 how they
contributed to your learning
Encourage you to consider the
experiences 
+
 perspectives of 
others
 
+
how that contributed to your learning
 
Help you adopt the language 
+
 methods
(practices, processes) of a particular subject
or discipline
Invite you into the discipline, to become
part of that community 
+
 engage with its
members
 
REFERENCES
 
Informed Learning Applications: Insights from Research + Practice
 edited by Kim L. Ranger (Bingley: Emerald, 2019)
IMPACT Learning: Librarians at the Forefront of Change in Higher Education
 by Clarence Maybee (Cambridge: Chandos
Publishing 2018)
Sociocultural Theories + Their Application in Information Literacy Research + Education
 by Li Wang, Christine Bruce 
+
 Hilary
Hughes (
Australian Academic + Research Libraries
 42(4) 2011)
Informed Learning
 by Christine Bruce (Chicago: Association of College & Research Libraries 2008)
The Seven Faces of Information Literacy
 by Christine Bruce (Adelaide: Auslib Press 1997)
Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation
 by Jean Lave + Etienne Wenger 1991
Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes
 by Lev Vygotsky (+ Michael Cole) [1981]
 
WORKSHOP
 
Developing activities and assessment that link art to the Framework in your classes
 
EXPLORING A FRAME AND DEVELOPING
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
 
~10 minutes
Working in your breakout room:
1.
Identify ways your frame manifests in the field of art and art history.
What are some of the unique issues, methods, or difficulties faced
by learners in visual arts disciplines in regards to this frame?
2.
Use worksheets to generate at least one learning objective for one
of your previously identified manifestations
 
DEVELOPING AN ACTIVITY AND ASSESSMENT
PLAN
 
~20 minutes
Working in your breakout room:
1.
Use worksheets to develop an activity for your learning
objectives
2.
Use the 
PDF ARLIS 2020 Informed Learning 
to discuss and
develop opportunities for assessing your learners.
 
DISCUSSION: bit.ly/3g8qOKp
 
Share what we came up with!
 
QUESTIONS?
 
Anna 
aboutinc@fandm.edu
Shannon 
smrob@upenn.edu
Claire 
cpowell3@c.ringling.edu
Slide Note

Introduction—abbreviated version of our interactive panel discussion. Our presenters today will be exploring how to connect the ACRL Framework to art and art information instruction.

Embed
Share

Explore the intersection of art and information through a framework that emphasizes strategic exploration and keyword strategies in searching for images. Lightning talks and workshops delve into the importance of keywords, cataloging images, and developing search strategies. Learning objectives include understanding successful keyword strategies for image searching and utilizing image databases effectively.

  • Art
  • Information
  • Exploration
  • Keywords
  • Image Searching

Uploaded on Aug 22, 2024 | 0 Views


Download Presentation

Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

You are allowed to download the files provided on this website for personal or commercial use, subject to the condition that they are used lawfully. All files are the property of their respective owners.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. REIMAGINING THE FRAME: CONNECTING ART TO THE FRAMEWORK IN THEORY AND IN PRACTICE

  2. TODAYS SESSION 1. Framework Tool/Activity Lightning Talks 1. Anna Boutin-Cooper: Searching as Strategic Exploration 2. Alex Watkins: Authority is Constructed and Contextual 3. Claire Powell: Information Has Value 4. Shannon Robinson: Informed Learning and Assessment 2. Workshop 3. Summary and Questions

  3. "CATALOGING" IMAGES: LOOKING FOR KEYWORDS Anna Boutin-Cooper

  4. "Searching for information is often nonlinear and iterative, requiring the evaluation of a range of information sources and the mental flexibility to pursue alternative avenues as new understanding develops." Searching As Strategic Exploration, Framework for Information Literacy for Higher Education

  5. SEARCHING AS STRATEGIC EXPLORATION KNOWLEDGE PRACTICES Matching information needs and search strategies to the appropriate search tools DISPOSITIONS Exhibiting mental flexibility and creativity in searching Understanding that first attempts at searching do not always produce adequate results Using different kinds of searching language appropriately Text taken directly from the ACRL Framework for Information Literacy in Higher Education, 2016.

  6. SEARCHING AS STRATEGIC EXPLORATION Importance of the "right" keywords Discussion of what makes a "good" keyword v. a "bad" keyword Context-specific! How to loop searching frame in with art history class? Development of "cataloging" image activity

  7. LEARNING OBJECTIVES By the end of class, students will understand how to construct successful keyword strategies for image searching. By the end of class, students will be able to search for images in Artstor and other image databases, in order to fulfill their image needs.

  8. KEYWORDS Red Blue Textile Embroidery Quilt Woven Shawl Women Flowers Floral Image credit: The Metropolitan Museum of Art

  9. SUCCESSFUL KEYWORDS Red Blue Textile Embroidery Quilt Woven Shawl Women Flowers Floral Image credit: The Metropolitan Museum of Art

  10. TEACHING INCLUSIVE SOURCE EVALUATION FOR RESEARCHING NATIVE ART Alex Watkins

  11. AUTHORITY IS CULTURALLY CONSTRUCTED Culturally specific systems of knowledge determine who is an authority and what knowledge is authoritative Librarians traditionally teach just one construction of authority, academic, and the specific markers and source types that are considered authoritative in this community Academia excludes and silences knowledge that is not constructed in this way IL instruction for research on Native art must acknowledge and value Native knowledge, but traditional modes of source evaluation instruction excludes this knowledge

  12. KNOWLEDGE SYSTEMS / WAYS OF KNOWING ACADEMIC KNOWLEDGE Citations to the written record NATIVE KNOWLEDGE Oral tradition Wisdom of elders Credentials experts Community agreement, proven utility Peer Review

  13. LEARNING OBJECTIVES Students understand that authority is constructed based on cultural systems of knowledge and ways of knowing. Students understand that indigenous authority is different from but not less than Western conceptions of authority. Students question the Western system of authority as default or natural. Students can identify and explain the different markers of authority in Western and indigenous cultures. Students seek out native voices and can articulate how and why native understandings of art are different from Western interpretations.

  14. Scholarly Knowledge Indigenous Knowledge How or in what form is this knowledge disseminated/communicated? What kind of people are considered to be authorities in these spheres of knowledge? What qualifies them to be authorities? Who s the audience of this knowledge? What is the purpose of this type of knowledge? How can each type of knowledge be useful in interpreting and understanding art?

  15. Through what ways/information formats do each of these groups communicate their ideas and knowledge? Where do these communities get information/what constitutes valid evidence in this community For what purpose, needs or questions would you seek out information from this community? What advantages as well as difficulties or challenges might there be to using information from this community: Who is considered an authority in this type of community and why? Communities: Wikipedia Gallery Museum Academic Indigenous

  16. VALUING CONTRIBUTIONS: STUDENT INFORMATIONAL INSIGHTS AS A COMMODITY Claire Powell

  17. INFORMATION HAS VALUE KNOWLEDGE PRACTICES Deciding where and how their information is published DISPOSITIONS Valuing the skills, time, and effort needed to produce knowledge Seeing themselves as contributors to the information marketplace rather than only consumers of it Understand how the commodification of their personal information and online interactions affects the information they receive and the information they produce or disseminate online Text taken directly from the ACRL Framework for Information Literacy in Higher Education, 2016.

  18. FACULTY COLLABORATION Relaying the value of students own contributions to the art and design community Identifying relevant publishing outlets Connecting the dissemination of personal skills and knowledge to success in the industry and networking opportunities Authentic learning and professional opportunities related to commodifying their exclusive information

  19. LEARNING OBJECTIVES Students will demonstrate an understanding of relevant publishing channels related to their discipline and information type Students will identify personal skills and information for potential publishing opportunities Students will be able to articulate the importance of information within their industry and different forms of its commodification

  20. INFORMED LEARNING Shannon Robinson

  21. INFORMED LEARNING Informed learning brings learner-centered, experiential, and reflective approaches to the information literacy agenda. (Bruce 2008) Informed learning . . . takes into account learners experiences promotes the simultaneous development of discipline + process learning is about changes in experience

  22. INFORMED LEARNING SEVEN FACES OF INFORMED LEARNING Knowledge Construction Experience Information Awareness + Communication Experience Knowledge Extension Experience Sourcing Information Experience Wisdom Experience (Bruce 1997, 2008) Information Process Experience Information Control Experience

  23. INFORMED LEARNING CONTENT what should learners know about the subject + about information literacy? PERSONAL RELEVANCE what good is information literacy to me? SOCIAL IMPACT how does information literacy impact society? COMPETENCY what should learners be able to do? RELATIONAL bringing about awareness of the critical ways of seeing or experiencing (Bruce 2008) LEARNING TO LEARN what does it mean to think like an informed learner in the professional environment?

  24. INFORMED LEARNING TO FRAMEWORK identifying disciplinary attributes of authority through observation of experts in their field a subjective notion that must be investigated by the learner, both personally + professionally critical awareness about how one's own background influences how authority is perceived + determined Competency Frame Authority is Constructed + Contextual is experienced as... Through the lens of the ... Learning to Learn Frame Personal Relevance Frame

  25. ASSESSMENT CONTENT is objective + measures how much has been learned PERSONAL RELEVANCE is cumulative (portfolio) + self-reflective COMPETENCY determines level of skill achieved SOCIAL IMPACT prompts reflection on the impact of information literacy LEARNING TO LEARN is complex, where contextual problems are posed RELATIONAL is designed to reveal ways of seeing or experiencing the phenomenon

  26. ASSESSMENT WHEN YOU WERE A STUDENT (LEARNING SOMETHING NEW), HOW DID A TEACHER / COACH / TUTOR / MENTOR Encourage you to consider your own personal experiences + how they contributed to your learning Help you adopt the language + methods (practices, processes) of a particular subject or discipline Encourage you to consider the experiences + perspectives of others + how that contributed to your learning Invite you into the discipline, to become part of that community + engage with its members

  27. REFERENCES Informed Learning Applications: Insights from Research + Practice edited by Kim L. Ranger (Bingley: Emerald, 2019) IMPACT Learning: Librarians at the Forefront of Change in Higher Education by Clarence Maybee (Cambridge: Chandos Publishing 2018) Sociocultural Theories + Their Application in Information Literacy Research + Education by Li Wang, Christine Bruce + Hilary Hughes (Australian Academic + Research Libraries 42(4) 2011) Informed Learning by Christine Bruce (Chicago: Association of College & Research Libraries 2008) The Seven Faces of Information Literacy by Christine Bruce (Adelaide: Auslib Press 1997) Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation by Jean Lave + Etienne Wenger 1991 Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes by Lev Vygotsky (+ Michael Cole) [1981]

  28. WORKSHOP Developing activities and assessment that link art to the Framework in your classes

  29. EXPLORING A FRAME AND DEVELOPING LEARNING OBJECTIVES ~10 minutes Working in your breakout room: 1. Identify ways your frame manifests in the field of art and art history. What are some of the unique issues, methods, or difficulties faced by learners in visual arts disciplines in regards to this frame? 2. Use worksheets to generate at least one learning objective for one of your previously identified manifestations

  30. DEVELOPING AN ACTIVITY AND ASSESSMENT PLAN ~20 minutes Working in your breakout room: 1. Use worksheets to develop an activity for your learning objectives 2. Use the PDF ARLIS 2020 Informed Learning to discuss and develop opportunities for assessing your learners.

  31. DISCUSSION: bit.ly/3g8qOKp Share what we came up with!

  32. QUESTIONS? Anna aboutinc@fandm.edu Shannon smrob@upenn.edu Claire cpowell3@c.ringling.edu

More Related Content

giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#giItT1WQy@!-/#